WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE REGISTRAR IN RELATION TO COSTS
CITATION:Piening-Cochrane v PL & MR Wilde t/as Wilde Earthmoving [2006] NSWWCCPD 340
APPELLANT: Terence Piening-Cochrane
RESPONDENT: PL & MR Wilde t/as Wilde Earthmoving
INSURER:Cambridge Integrated Services Australia Pty Ltd
FILE NUMBER: WCC19445-05
DATE OF REGISTRAR’S DECISION: 7 April 2006
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 8 December 2006
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Appeal against the Registrar’s decision in relation to costs: professional costs - claims under Items 2.06, 4.07, 4.12 and 10.01 of the Compensation Costs Table in Schedule 6 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2003.
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Acting Deputy President Robin Handley
HEARING:On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: McCabe Partners Lawyers
Respondent: Moray & Agnew Solicitors
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: The Registrar’s determination of Mr Piening-Cochrane’s costs in this matter, dated 7 April 2006, is amended in accordance with these reasons.
The Respondent, PL & MR Wilde t/as Wilde Earthmoving is to pay the Appellant, Mr Piening-Cochrane $605.00 inclusive of GST in respect of his costs in this appeal.
BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL
On 3 May 2006, Terence Piening-Cochrane filed an appeal against a costs determination made by the Registrar of the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) on 7 April 2006. The Respondent to the appeal is PL & MR Wilde t/as Wilde Earthmoving. The Wilde’s workers compensation insurer is Cambridge Integrated Services Australia Pty Ltd (‘Cambridge’), formerly Vero Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd (‘Vero’). On 30 May 2006, Cambridge filed their ‘Notice of Opposition’ to the appeal.
Mr Piening-Cochrane was born on 13 October 1970 and is aged 36. He claims to have injured his back, right shoulder and right hip while working for the Wildes between 2001 and 9 March 2004. On 23 August 2004, the Commission registered Mr Piening-Cochrane’s ‘Application to Resolve a Dispute’ in respect of his claim for compensation for permanent impairment and pain and suffering. On 13 September 2004, Vero filed a ‘Reply’. Following a teleconference with an Arbitrator on 5 November 2004, Mr Piening-Cochrane was referred to an Approved Medical Specialist (‘AMS’) for assessment of his injuries. On 24 May 2005, the Commission issued the AMS’s Medical Assessment Certificate. At a further teleconference with the parties on 30 June 2005, the Arbitrator assisted the parties in reaching a resolution of their dispute and, on 1 July 2005, the Commission issued a Certificate of Determination in the following terms:
“1. That the Respondent pay the Applicant as lump-sum compensation under s 66 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 as follows (for injuries on and from 01.01.02), $7,500.00 in respect of 6% whole person permanent [sic].
2. That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs as agreed or assessed.”
On 9 November 2005, the parties having failed to agree on the costs payable, Mr Piening-Cochrane’s solicitors lodged an ‘Application for Assessment of Costs’ with the Commission in respect of their Bill of Costs dated 1 July 2005. On 7 December 2005, Vero filed its submissions in reply.
The Registrar delegated the assessment…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Piening-Cochrane v PL & MR Wilde t/as Wilde Earthmoving and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWWCCPD 340
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues in the appeal were whether the Registrar had correctly assessed the costs claimed by Mr Piening-Cochrane's solicitors under the specified items of the Compensation Costs Table. The appellant's solicitors argued that the Registrar had erred in law by disallowing certain costs, while the insurer contended that the assessment was correct. The Acting Deputy President examined the relevant legislation, case law, and the specific items in question to determine the validity of the claims.
Acting Deputy President Handley found that the Registrar had indeed made errors in the assessment of costs. For Item 2.06, relating to the request for a review of the claim from the insurer, the Acting Deputy President concluded that the appellant's solicitors were entitled to the $500 claimed, as they had requested a review from the insurer. For Item 4.07, concerning the application to refer a matter to an approved medical specialist, the Acting Deputy President allowed a claim of $50, considering the work associated with reviewing the AMS's report. Regarding Item 4.12, the Acting Deputy President determined that the appellant's solicitors were entitled to an additional $190 for reporting to their client on the outcome of a teleconference, bringing the total allowable under this item to $380. Lastly, for Item 10.01, the Acting Deputy President upheld the Registrar's disallowance of the claim for instructing an agent, as the work in question was either not reasonably necessary or already covered under another item.
In conclusion, the Acting Deputy President amended the Registrar’s determination of costs, increasing the total allowable costs by $814.00, to a total of $9,113.60. Furthermore, the Acting Deputy President ordered the respondent to pay the appellant $605.00 inclusive of GST for the costs of the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
On 3 May 2006, Terence Piening-Cochrane filed an appeal against the Registrar's decision in relation to costs, dated 7 April 2006. The Respondent, PL & MR Wilde t/as Wilde Earthmoving, opposed the appeal. The appeal was heard by Acting Deputy President Robin Handley on 8 December 2006, on the papers, following submissions from both parties. The Registrar's determination of Piening-Cochrane's costs was amended based on the reasons provided by Acting Deputy President Handley.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Delegate made errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 2.06 of the Compensation Costs Table.
2. Whether the Delegate made errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 4.07 of the Compensation Costs Table.
3. Whether the Delegate made errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 4.12 of the Compensation Costs Table.
4. Whether the Delegate made errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 10.01 of the Compensation Costs Table.
Held
1. The court held that the Delegate made errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 2.06 of the Compensation Costs Table. The court concluded that the Delegate should have allowed $500 (plus GST of $50) under this Item.
2. The court held that the Delegate made errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 4.07 of the Compensation Costs Table. The court concluded that the Delegate should have allowed $50 (plus GST of $5) under this Item.
3. The court held that the Delegate made errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 4.12 of the Compensation Costs Table. The court concluded that the Delegate should have allowed $380 (plus GST of $38) under this Item.
4. The court held that the Delegate did not make errors of law by not allowing costs claimed under Item 10.01 of the Compensation Costs Table. The court confirmed the Delegate's decision in this regard.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the appeal against a costs determination made by the Registrar of the Workers Compensation Commission. The appeal focused on four specific Items in the Compensation Costs Table, where the Delegate disallowed certain costs claimed by Mr Piening-Cochrane's solicitors. The court examined the submissions of both parties and relevant legal authorities to determine whether the Delegate made errors of law.
Regarding Item 2.06, the court found that Mr Piening-Cochrane's solicitors had indeed requested a review from the insurer, as evidenced by the attached letters. The court held that it was fair and reasonable to allow an allowance of two hours for the work undertaken, amounting to $500 (plus GST of $50).
Concerning Item 4.07, the court noted that the referral to an AMS was made by the Arbitrator, and the AMS was selected by the Registrar. The court held that it was fair and reasonable to allow $50 (plus GST of $5) under this Item, as Mr Piening-Cochrane's solicitors had claimed costs for reviewing the AMS' report.
As for Item 4.12, the court found that the Delegate had misinterpreted the relevant decisions. The court held that the claim was not limited to one teleconference or one conciliation/arbitration and that the Delegate should have allowed a further $190 (plus GST of $19) under this Item in respect of the teleconference on 30 June 2005.
Lastly, in relation to Item 10.01, the court held that there was no reason why the documents could not have been filed and served through the post or via DX, and it did not consider the instructions in respect of filing to be reasonably necessary. The court confirmed the Delegate's decision in disallowing the claim under Item 10.01.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Delegate must properly interpret and apply the Compensation Costs Table in assessing costs claims, and errors of law in this regard may be subject to judicial review.