Picca & Cioffi v Pamaco Pty Ltd & Anor No. DCCIV-02-885

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

PICCA & CIOFFI V PAMACO PTY LTD & ANOR
[2003] SADC 176

Judge Kitchen
Appeal Against the Decision of a Master

  1. This is an appeal against an order of a Master made on 30 May 2003 that, pursuant to DCR-25.02, judgment be entered for the respondents (the plaintiffs in the action) against the appellants (the third and fourth defendants in the action) for damages to be assessed.

  2. The respondents’ action was instituted on 14 June 2002 against Memoria Pty Ltd (“Memoria”), Geoffrey Joseph Anderson (“Mr Anderson”), Genaro Picca (“Mr Picca”) and Edward Cioffi (“ Mr Cioffi”). The  claim against Memoria alleged breaches by Memoria as the respondents’ lessee of premises at Pirie Street, Adelaide (the premises) under a lease dated 26 February 2001; the alleged breaches were Memoria’s failure to pay rent and other outgoings between 1 January 2001 and 1 June 2002 totalling, with interest, $161,397.21,. The claim against Messrs Anderson, Picca and Cioffi was as guarantors of Memoria’s payment, and other, obligations under the lease pursuant to a guarantee (the guarantee), forming part of the lease, executed by them as directors of Memoria.

  3. The substance of the defence filed by Messrs Picca and Cioffi was:

    1.(a)     that they executed the guarantee on or about 31 January 2001 and they were the only parties who had executed either the guarantee or the lease at that time.

    (b)       that on 23 February 2001 they informed the plaintiffs they would not     be proceeding ‘as partners’ in the Business and hence they would not accept any liability under the guarantee. The “Business” was identified in the defence to be the premises, the subject of the lease, upon which the personal defendants “as partners” were to use Memoria to establish a wine and restaurant business.

    (c)    that on 23 February 2001 the personal defendants executed an agreement to record the terms upon which they ‘dissolved’ their intended relationship as ‘partners’ in the Business.

    (d)    that notwithstanding they had informed the plaintiffs on 23 February 2001 they would not accept any liability under the guarantee the plaintiffs executed the lease, and an agreement to provide Memoria “100% vendor finance in respect of the liquor licence and goodwill associated with the premises.

    2.that the lease dated 26 February 2001 was tainted by illegality as a conspiracy between the plaintiffs and Anderson to defraud the Commissioner of Taxation, and is therefore unenforceable, the allegation being that the rent of $110,000, for the first year of the lease term, included $50,000 for the price of plant and equipment at the premises, the subject of the lease, sold by the plaintiffs to Memoria.

  4. In their reply to the defence of the third and fourth defendants, the plaintiffs denied, inter alia, what I have set out as the substance of the defence.

  5. The respondents’ application for summary judgment against the appellants was filed on 28 February 2003; it was supported by the affidavit of Antonio Cocchiaro     (“Mr Cocchiaro”), a shareholder and director of the second respondent sworn on 26…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Picca & Cioffi v Pamaco Pty Ltd & Anor No. DCCIV-02-885 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 176
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought against the decision of a Master who made an order that judgment be entered for the respondents against the appellants for damages to be assessed. The respondents had instituted action against the appellants and others as guarantors for alleged breaches of lease by the respondents' lessee of premises at Pirie Street, Adelaide. The appellants argued that they had withdrawn from the venture prior to the execution of the lease and that they had been released from their guarantee. The Master rejected the appellants' defence and entered judgment against them. The appeal against that order was dismissed on the basis that there were no real grounds to set aside the Master's order. However, the court found that the appellants had demonstrated that further evidence should be received on the appeal and set aside the Master's order. The appeal was allowed, the order of the Master was set aside, and the proceedings were referred to a Master for further orders.