Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd v Tom McArthur Pty Ltd [No 4]

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   PHOENIX EAGLE COMPANY PTY LTD -v- TOM McARTHUR PTY LTD [No 4] [2021] WASC 244

CORAM:   ALLANSON J

HEARD:   29 APRIL 2021

DELIVERED          :   23 JULY 2021

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1746 of 2016

BETWEEN:   PHOENIX EAGLE COMPANY PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

TOM McARTHUR PTY LTD

First Defendant

TREVOR HOWARD BRICKHILL

Second Defendant

LAURA COSTANTINA BRICKHILL

Third Defendant

LAURA COSTANTINA BRICKHILL ATF THE TLAJ TRUST

Fourth Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure – Where plaintiff/defendant by counterclaim applied to strike out two paragraphs of counterclaim – Where defendant/plaintiff by counterclaim applied to amend counterclaim to delete the challenged paragraphs – Whether paragraphs should be struck out or counterclaim amended

Costs – Where counterclaim amended after application to strike out – Where balance of counterclaim not challenged – Where plaintiff/defendant by counterclaim applied for 75% of costs attributable to counterclaim on an indemnity basis – Turns on facts

Practice and procedure – Pleading – Whether statement of claim sufficiently particularises claim – Turns on facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

On the plaintiff's application

  1. Counterclaim amended to delete paragraphs 97 and 98

  2. The plaintiff to have the costs of its application to strike out and any costs thrown away by reason of the amendment

On the defendants' application

  1. The defendants have leave to bring the application

  2. Paragraphs 87D and 97F of the statement of claim struck out with leave to replead

  3. Defendants' application otherwise dismissed

Category:  B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr L A Warnick
First Defendant : Mr G D Cobby
Second Defendant : Mr G D Cobby
Third Defendant : Mr G D Cobby
Fourth Defendant : Mr G D Cobby

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : KD Legal
First Defendant : Roe Legal Services
Second Defendant : Roe Legal Services
Third Defendant : Roe Legal Services
Fourth Defendant : Roe Legal Services

Cases referred to in decision:

Banque Commerciale SA, en Liquidation v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279

Edwards Madigan Torzillo Briggs Pty Ltd v Stack [2003] NSWCA 302

English v Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd [2021] WASCA 47

Forrest v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2012] HCA 39; (2012) 247 CLR 486

Krakowski v Eurolynx Properties Ltd (1995) 183 CLR 563

One.Tel Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2000] FCA 270; (2000) 101 FCR 548

Oshlack v Richmond River Company [1998] HCA 11; (1998) 193 CLR 72

Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Lai Qin [1997] HCA 6; (1997) 186 CLR 622

Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd v Donnelly [No 4] [2019] WASC 398

ALLANSON J:

Introduction

  1. The plaintiff (Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd) and the defendants brought cross applications.

  2. Phoenix Eagle applied for leave to apply for summary judgment on part of the counterclaim of the first defendant (Tom McArthur Pty Ltd); alternatively, it applied for an extension of time to apply to strike out two paragraphs of the counterclaim.[1]

    [1] In these reasons I will refer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd v Tom McArthur Pty Ltd [No 4] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASC 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd v Tom McArthur Pty Ltd [No 4], the parties were engaged in a legal dispute that was ultimately discontinued without being determined on its merits. The matter was before the court to decide the legal issues surrounding the allocation of costs in such a scenario. The court had to determine whether the successful party was entitled to costs, and if so, the proportion of costs attributable to the claim that was abandoned. The court also had to consider whether any special order should be made in relation to the costs.

The legal issues before the court included whether Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd was entitled to costs after their claim under the Corporations Act was discontinued, and if so, the proportion of the costs of the counterclaim that should be attributed to the abandoned claim. The court considered whether the general rule of costs allocation, which allows for separate actions to be treated as if they were brought individually, should apply in this case. The court also had to determine whether it was appropriate to leave the allocation of costs to the taxing officer due to the difficulty in assessing the proportion of work attributable to the abandoned claim.

The court concluded that Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd was entitled to costs as the successful party, but the allocation of those costs should be left to the taxing officer. The court reasoned that it was not possible to allocate costs reasonably between different issues and causes of action until all had been determined. The court found that determining the proportion of work attributable to the abandoned claim should be left to the taxing officer, as it was not possible to make a reasonable assessment based on the evidence before the court.

The court's final orders were that Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd was entitled to costs of the application and the costs of the claim now abandoned. The proportion of the work attributable to the counterclaim and the proportion of that work attributable to the abandoned claim should be determined by the taxing officer. The court also noted that it would be necessary to determine the proportion of the work which was attributable to the counterclaim, and the proportion of that work which was attributable to the cause of action which was now abandoned.

Background

Background to the litigation

Phoenix Eagle Company Pty Ltd commenced proceedings against Tom McArthur Pty Ltd (TMPL) alleging breach of contract, misrepresentation, and seeking an account of profits and damages. TMPL counterclaimed against Phoenix Eagle, alleging breach of the Corporations Act. The case proceeded to a hearing where the primary judge determined that Phoenix Eagle had succeeded on the contract claim but not on the misrepresentation claim. Phoenix Eagle also succeeded on the counterclaim. However, Phoenix Eagle discontinued the claim under the Corporations Act before the final hearing. The matter was brought before the court to determine the costs associated with the discontinued claim and the counterclaim.

The case was initially heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where the primary judge delivered a judgment on liability. Following this, Phoenix Eagle discontinued the claim under the Corporations Act. The matter was subsequently brought before the court for the determination of costs, including those associated with the abandoned claim and the successful counterclaim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Phoenix Eagle is entitled to costs for the abandoned claim under the Corporations Act.
2. Whether Phoenix Eagle is entitled to costs for the successful counterclaim.
3. How to allocate costs between the abandoned claim and the successful counterclaim.

Held
1. The court held that Phoenix Eagle is not entitled to costs for the abandoned claim under the Corporations Act. Although Phoenix Eagle argued that the claim could not have been sustained on the case pleaded, the court found that no order should be made as to costs of the proceedings because both parties acted reasonably in commencing and defending the claim until it was challenged.
2. The court held that Phoenix Eagle is entitled to costs for the successful counterclaim. As the defendant to the counterclaim, Phoenix Eagle is entitled to recover its costs under section 183 of the Corporations Act.
3. The court held that the allocation of costs between the abandoned claim and the successful counterclaim should be left to the taxing officer. The court found it was not possible to allocate costs reasonably between different issues and causes of action until all have been determined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Where a claim is not determined on its merits, but is discontinued, the successful party will not always be entitled to costs. If it appears that both parties have acted reasonably in commencing and defending the claim which has now been abandoned, until the claim was challenged, the proper exercise of the costs discretion may result in no order being made as to costs of the proceedings.[4] However, if after litigating for some time, one party effectively surrenders to the other, then the court may make a costs order against that party.[5][4] Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Lai Qin [1997] HCA 6; (1997) 186 CLR 622, 625.[5] One.Tel Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2000] FCA 270; (2000) 101 FCR 548, 552 ‑ 553 (Burchett J); Edwards Madigan Torzillo Briggs Pty Ltd v Stack [2003] NSWCA 302. In the present matter, I accept the submissions on behalf of Phoenix Eagle that the claim under the Corporations Act could not have been sustained on the case pleaded. TMPL does not argue against it being required to pay the costs of the applications. It did not strongly contest that it should also pay the costs of that part of the counterclaim. Subject to the question of delay, I am satisfied that a costs order should be made in favour of Phoenix Eagle as to the costs of the application and the costs of the claim now abandoned. The general rule, in the absence of any special order, is that where a plaintiff pleads more than one cause of action and succeeds on only one or more of them, costs shall be allowed to the plaintiff on the causes of action on which the plaintiff succeeds, and to the defendant on the causes on which the defendant succeeds, as if separate actions had been brought.[6] [6] Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) O 66 r 2(a). This is not a case for a special order. Phoenix Eagle, as the defendant to the counterclaim, should recover its costs of the counterclaim under s 183 of the Corporations Act. It will be necessary to determine the proportion of the work which is attributable to the counterclaim, and the proportion of that work which is attributable to the cause of action which is now abandoned. Many costs issues are described as involving elements of impression rather than strict proof. I am not satisfied that, even as a matter of impression, it will be possible to allocate costs reasonably between different issues and causes of action until all have been determined. For example, I cannot now say whether documents discovered by Phoenix Eagle might relate solely to the issue now abandoned or, on trial, prove of wider relevance. Even if it were possible to estimate to what extent discovery was confined, or primarily directed to, the claim under the Corporations Act, I do not have evidence before me to justify an assessment of 75% of the costs of the counterclaim being so attributed, when the balance of the counterclaim (including all pleas of material facts) is not challenged. Determining the proportion of work attributable to the abandoned claim should be left to the taxing officer.