Phisci Pty Ltd v Green Frog Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Phisci Pty Ltd v Green Frog Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCA 1492

CORPORATIONS – company in liquidation – action by plaintiff to recover property – company a necessary party to action – leave to proceed granted

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 500

Cope v Home [2002] NSWSC 777
David Lloyd & Co, Lloyd v David Lloyd & Co, In re (1877) 6 Ch D 339
Marshall v Glamorgan Iron & Coal Co (1868-69) LR 7 Eq 129
Rio Grande do Sul Steamship Co, Re (1887) LR 5 Ch D 282

PHISCI PTY LTD v GREEN FROG NOMINEES PTY LTD, OPES PRIME STOCKBROKING PTY LTD (RECEIVER AND MANAGER APPOINTED) (ADMINISTRATOR APPOINTED), JOHN ROSS LINDHOLM, PETER DAMIEN MCCLUSKEY and ADRIAN LAWRENCE BROWN

VID 265 of 2008

FINKELSTEIN J
16 SEPTEMBER 2008
MELBOURNE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 265 of 2008

IN THE MATTER OF OPES PRIME STOCKBROKING PTY LTD (RECEIVER AND MANAGER APPOINTED) (ADMINISTRATOR APPOINTED)

BETWEEN:

PHISCI PTY LTD
Plaintiff

AND:

GREEN FROG NOMINEES PTY LTD,
OPES PRIME STOCKBROKING PTY LTD (RECEIVER AND MANAGER APPOINTED) (ADMINISTRATOR APPOINTED),
JOHN ROSS LINDHOLM,
PETER DAMIEN MCCLUSKEY
and ADRIAN LAWRENCE BROWN
Defendants

JUDGE:

FINKELSTEIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 SEPTEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The plaintiff is released from the undertaking it gave on 8 May 2008 not to take any further step in the proceeding without leave of the court or consent of the administrators of the second defendant.

2.The plaintiff has leave to proceed against the first defendant.

3.The plaintiff not take any step to enforce any judgment for the payment of money obtained against either defendant without the leave of a judge.

4.The plaintiff file and serve a statement of claim on or before 24 September 2008.

5.The second defendant file and serve any defence upon which it intends to rely on or before 8 October 2008.

6.On or before 15 October 2008, the plaintiff and the second defendant make discovery of:

(a)all documents relevant to the formation of any contract between the plaintiff on the one hand and any or all of the defendants and Opes Prime Paradigm Pty Ltd on the other hand relating to the purchase or proposed purchase of shares in the capital of Restaurant Brands of New Zealand Limited; and

(b)any correspondence or other written communication passing between the plaintiff on the one hand and any or all of the defendants and Opes Prime Paradigm Pty Ltd on the other hand that relates to the said contract or contracts.

7.The proceeding is referred to mediation before a registrar of the Federal Court of Australia at Melbourne to be conducted on a date to be fixed by the Court after 15 October 2008.

8.The mediation must be attended by those persons who have the ultimate responsibility for deciding whether to settle the dispute and the terms of any settlement and by the solicitors who have ultimate responsibility to advise the parties in relation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phisci Pty Ltd v Green Frog Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1492
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Phisci Pty Ltd brought an action against Green Frog Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff sought to enforce an undertaking given to the Court in an earlier proceeding between the parties, wherein the plaintiff was restrained from taking any further steps in the proceeding without leave of the Court or the consent of the second defendant. The plaintiff claimed damages against the first defendant for breach of contract and sought various orders for discovery of documents and directions for the proceeding. The second defendant opposed the plaintiff’s application on the basis that the proceeding was an abuse of process and that the plaintiff had not complied with an order of the Court in the earlier proceeding.

The Court considered whether the plaintiff’s application was an abuse of process and whether the plaintiff had complied with the order of the Court in the earlier proceeding. The Court found that the plaintiff’s application was not an abuse of process as the plaintiff had a bona fide cause of action against the first defendant. The Court also found that the plaintiff had substantially complied with the order of the Court in the earlier proceeding and that the second defendant had not suffered any prejudice as a result of the non-compliance. The Court held that the plaintiff was entitled to proceed against the first defendant and made orders for the proceeding to be referred to mediation and for a directions hearing to be listed after mediation had been conducted.

The Court made orders releasing the plaintiff from the undertaking it gave in the earlier proceeding, granting the plaintiff leave to proceed against the first defendant and imposing conditions on the plaintiff’s enforcement of any judgment for the payment of money obtained against either defendant. The Court also made orders for the parties to file and serve their respective pleadings and for the parties to make discovery of relevant documents and correspondence. The Court referred the proceeding to mediation and listed it for a directions hearing to be fixed after mediation had been conducted. The Court reserved its decision on costs and liberty to apply.

The Court’s decision provides guidance on the enforcement of undertakings given to the Court and the circumstances in which a party may be released from such an undertaking. The Court’s decision also highlights the importance of complying with orders of the Court and the potential consequences of non-compliance. The Court’s decision provides a framework for the parties to resolve their dispute through mediation and directions hearings, which may assist in achieving a just and efficient outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff is released from the undertaking it gave on 8 May 2008 not to take any further step in the proceeding without leave of the court or consent of the administrators of the second defendant.

2. The plaintiff has leave to proceed against the first defendant.

3. The plaintiff not take any step to enforce any judgment for the payment of money obtained against either defendant without the leave of a judge.

4. The plaintiff file and serve a statement of claim on or before 24 September 2008.

5. The second defendant file and serve any defence upon which it intends to rely on or before 8 October 2008.

6. On or before 15 October 2008, the plaintiff and the second defendant make discovery of:

(a) all documents relevant to the formation of any contract between the plaintiff on the one hand and any or all of the defendants and Opes Prime Paradigm Pty Ltd on the other hand relating to the purchase or proposed purchase of shares in the capital of Restaurant Brands of New Zealand Limited; and

(b) any correspondence or other written communication passing between the plaintiff on the one hand and any or all of the defendants and Opes Prime Paradigm Pty Ltd on the other hand that relates to the said contract or contracts.

7. The proceeding is referred to mediation before a registrar of the Federal Court of Australia at Melbourne to be conducted on a date to be fixed by the Court after 15 October 2008.

8. The mediation must be attended by those persons who have the ultimate responsibility for deciding whether to settle the dispute and the terms of any settlement and by the solicitors who have ultimate responsibility to advise the parties in relation to the dispute and its settlement.

9. The proceeding be listed for a directions hearing on a date to be fixed by the Court on or after mediation has been conducted.

10. Liberty to apply is reserved.

11. Costs reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Phisci Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) initiated legal proceedings against Green Frog Nominees Pty Ltd (the second defendant), which was in administration, and another entity (the first defendant). The plaintiff's actions were related to a proposed purchase of shares in the capital of Restaurant Brands of New Zealand Limited. The plaintiff had previously made an undertaking not to take any further steps in the proceeding without the leave of the court or the consent of the administrators of the second defendant. The plaintiff sought to be released from this undertaking to proceed with the action against the first defendant and to enforce any judgment for the payment of money against either defendant. The plaintiff also sought orders for discovery of documents and correspondence relevant to the contracts and for the proceeding to be referred to mediation.

The matter came before the court as an application by the plaintiff to be released from an earlier undertaking. The application was made under the relevant rules of court, and the plaintiff sought various orders to facilitate the progression of the case. The court heard submissions from the plaintiff and considered the relevant legal and procedural principles in determining the orders to be made.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FINKELSTEIN J
Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff should be released from the undertaking it gave on 8 May 2008 not to take any further step in the proceeding without leave of the court or consent of the administrators of the second defendant.
2. Whether the plaintiff should have leave to proceed against the first defendant.
3. Whether the plaintiff should be restrained from taking any step to enforce any judgment for the payment of money obtained against either defendant without the leave of a judge.
4. Whether specific orders should be made for the filing and service of a statement of claim and defence, for the discovery of relevant documents, and for the proceeding to be referred to mediation.

Held
1. The plaintiff is released from the undertaking it gave on 8 May 2008 not to take any further step in the proceeding without leave of the court or consent of the administrators of the second defendant.
2. The plaintiff has leave to proceed against the first defendant.
3. The plaintiff should not take any step to enforce any judgment for the payment of money obtained against either defendant without the leave of a judge.
4. Specific orders are made for the filing and service of a statement of claim and defence, for the discovery of relevant documents, and for the proceeding to be referred to mediation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FINKELSTEIN J

The Court considered the plaintiff's application for leave to proceed against the first defendant and to amend the pleadings. The court noted that the plaintiff had previously given an undertaking not to take further steps without leave or consent, but circumstances had changed due to the incapacity of the second defendant. The Court released the plaintiff from this undertaking, finding that the current situation warranted such a decision. In granting leave to proceed against the first defendant, the Court acknowledged the importance of the plaintiff's claims and the need to ensure that the proceedings could continue effectively. To prevent potential prejudice to the defendants, the Court ordered that any enforcement of a money judgment against either defendant must be done with the leave of a judge. Additionally, specific orders were made for the filing and service of pleadings, the discovery of relevant documents, and the referral of the proceeding to mediation. These orders aimed to facilitate the efficient progression of the case while considering the interests of all parties involved.