Phillips v Phillips

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2010] QDC 503

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE JONES

No 1165 of 2009

JOLENE MAREE PHILLIPS Plaintiff

and

RICHARD LEON PHILLIPS Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 24/11/2010

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  This is an application for compensation pursuant
to section 24 of the Criminal Offences Victims Act 1995.  The
application arises out of injuries suffered by the applicant
as a result of offences committed by the respondent on
25 December 2005.  The respondent was the applicant's husband at the time.

The respondent was in Court earlier this morning but
he was not present when this application was heard at 2.30.
There is an affidavit of service which exists which no doubt
would explain his attendance here earlier in the day.  His
name was called three times by the bailiff but he was not
present so the application proceeded in his absence.

As I said previously, this application arises out of offences
committed by the respondent.  On 4 May 2006 the respondent
pleaded guilty in this Court to one count of deprivation of
liberty and one count of common assault.  The respondent was
sentenced to a period of imprisonment for two years suspended
after eight months with an operational period of two years.
At the time of the offences the applicant was 30 years of age
and the respondent 36 years of age.

The particulars of the offences as set out in the Schedule of
Facts presented to the sentencing Judge indicate that the
incident would have been a terrifying experience for the
applicant and the children.  In the house occupied by the
applicant and the children at the time, they were confronted
with the respondent who was armed with a kitchen knife in what
the respondent himself described as a "hostage" situation.  When the police arrived the respondent had locked all the doors and taken door keys from the possession of the applicant.

During the course of these events the applicant was required
to pass the children through a window of the house to the
police who were standing outside.  It was while this was
occurring that the respondent pushed the complainant into the
bedroom door with such force as to cause her a significant
shoulder injury.  Thereafter the respondent held the applicant
against the bathroom door and punched the door immediately
above her head on several occasions.  All this occurred while
the respondent was still holding a knife and the applicant
clutching a six month old child of the marriage.  As I have
said, not surprisingly the incident would have been extremely
traumatic for the applicant and the children.

In respect of the shoulder injury the applicant was treated
and in particular was treated by a Mr Skippen, a
physiotherapist.  In Mr Skippen's opinion the applicant had
sustained a ligamentous injury to her left shoulder and soft
tissue damage to her neck resulting in an incapacity or loss
of function in the order of five to 10 per cent.  In
Mr Skippen's opinion it was likely that the applicant would
continue to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillips v Phillips and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QDC 503
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the District Court of Queensland, Jolene Maree Phillips brought a claim against her former husband, Richard Leon Phillips, under the Criminal Offences Victims Act 1995, seeking compensation for injuries sustained as a result of offences committed by Richard on December 25, 2005. The injuries included a significant shoulder injury and mental or nervous shock, diagnosed as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The case proceeded in Richard's absence as he did not attend the hearing despite being present in court earlier that day. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate compensation for the injuries suffered by Jolene.

The primary legal issue was to ascertain the correct percentage of the maximum allowable compensation of $75,000 for each injury sustained by Jolene. For the shoulder injury, Jolene sought 7 per cent, which is at the upper limit of the minor injury range. The court considered the likely permanent incapacity and symptomatology, ultimately deciding that 7 per cent was reasonable. Regarding the mental or nervous shock, Jolene claimed 34 per cent, the upper limit of the severe range for such injuries. However, the court noted that the incident was one in a series of domestic violence events, leading to an argument to reduce the percentage to 20 per cent. The court found that despite Jolene's predisposition to PTSD, reducing the impact below the upper end of the moderate form of injury would be unreasonable.

The court concluded that the compensation for the shoulder injury should be $5,250 and for the mental or nervous shock, $15,000, resulting in a total compensation of $20,250. The court made orders for this amount to be paid to Jolene.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 25 December 2005, Jolene Maree Phillips suffered injuries as a result of offences committed by her then husband, Richard Leon Phillips. The respondent, armed with a kitchen knife, confronted Jolene and the children in their home, creating a terrifying "hostage" situation. The respondent locked all the doors and took the keys, requiring Jolene to pass the children through a window to the police outside. During this ordeal, Richard pushed Jolene into a bedroom door with significant force, causing a shoulder injury. He then held her against a bathroom door and punched the door above her head several times while still holding the knife and Jolene was holding a six-month-old child.

Following the incident, Jolene was treated by a physiotherapist, Mr Skippen, who diagnosed a ligamentous injury to her left shoulder and soft tissue damage to her neck, resulting in a 5 to 10 per cent incapacity or loss of function. The ongoing instability in her shoulder has persisted, causing Jolene to continue suffering five years after the incident. In terms of mental health, Jolene was examined by psychiatrist Ms Deborah McGuire, who diagnosed post-traumatic stress disorder, characterised by severe symptoms such as flashbacks, nightmares, emotional numbing, and hypervigilance. Although Jolene had experienced domestic violence from Richard over many years, the 25 December 2005 incident was described as the worst she had endured, significantly impacting her ability to function in various roles.

This case represents an application for compensation pursuant to section 24 of the Criminal Offences Victims Act 1995, arising from injuries sustained by the applicant as a result of offences committed by the respondent, who was the applicant's husband at the time. The respondent had previously pleaded guilty to charges of deprivation of liberty and common assault, for which he was sentenced to a period of imprisonment suspended after serving eight months. The respondent was present in court earlier that day but did not attend the hearing of the compensation application, which proceeded in his absence. The application seeks compensation for both physical injuries, namely a shoulder injury, and mental or nervous shock, which was diagnosed as post-traumatic stress disorder. The court considered the severity of the injuries and the impact they had on the applicant, taking into account both the immediate incident and the broader context of domestic violence experienced by the applicant over many years.

Procedurally, the case began with the respondent's criminal conviction and sentencing in this Court on 4 May 2006. Following this, the applicant initiated proceedings under the Criminal Offences Victims Act 1995 to seek compensation for the injuries sustained. The application was heard by Judge Jones, who considered affidavits and medical evidence provided by the applicant. Judge Jones assessed the severity of the injuries and determined the appropriate percentage of the statutory maximum compensation to be awarded. The court deliberated on the extent to which the applicant's pre-existing condition and predisposition to mental health issues should affect the compensation award. Ultimately, the court awarded compensation for both physical and mental injuries, totaling $20,250.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant's shoulder injury is appropriately categorized within the minor injury range and if so, what percentage of the maximum compensation should be awarded.
2. Whether the applicant's mental or nervous shock injury is appropriately categorized within the moderate to severe injury range and if so, what percentage of the maximum compensation should be awarded.
3. Whether the applicant's predisposition to suffering post-traumatic stress disorder due to previous episodes of domestic violence should reduce the percentage compensation for the mental or nervous shock injury.

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant's shoulder injury is appropriately categorized within the minor injury range, awarding 7% of the maximum compensation, resulting in $5,250.

2. The court determined that the applicant's mental or nervous shock injury falls within the moderate to severe injury range, awarding 20% of the maximum compensation, resulting in $15,000.

3. The court decided that the applicant's predisposition to suffering post-traumatic stress disorder due to previous episodes of domestic violence should not reduce the percentage compensation for the mental or nervous shock injury.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining the appropriate compensation for the applicant's injuries under the Criminal Offences Victims Act 1995, the Court examined both the physical and psychiatric injuries sustained by the applicant as a result of the respondent's criminal acts. The Court commenced by assessing the shoulder injury, which the applicant argued fell within the minor injury range. The Court considered the evidence from the physiotherapist, Mr. Skippen, who diagnosed the applicant with a ligamentous injury to her left shoulder and soft tissue damage to her neck, resulting in a five to ten percent loss of function. The physiotherapist also opined that the applicant would continue to experience ongoing instability in her shoulder. Given these findings, the Court recognized that the 7 percent compensation sought by the applicant, while generous, was reasonable considering the permanent incapacity and the symptoms the applicant still exhibited five years after the incident. Consequently, the Court awarded $5,250 for the shoulder injury.

Next, the Court addressed the mental or nervous shock injury, which the applicant argued should be categorized within the severe injury range. The psychiatrist, Ms. Deborah McGuire, diagnosed the applicant with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), characterized by severe symptoms such as flashbacks, nightmares, emotional numbing, and hypervigilance. The applicant contended that the upper limit of the severe range, 34 percent, was appropriate for this injury. However, the Court noted that the applicant had a predisposition to suffering from PTSD due to previous episodes of domestic violence. Despite this, the Court concluded that the subject incident was severe enough to cause significant psychiatric harm, independent of the applicant's predisposition. The Court reasoned that reducing the compensation below the upper end of the moderate range or the bottom end of the severe range was unreasonable, given the severity of the symptoms and their impact on the applicant's life. Therefore, the Court awarded $15,000 for the mental or nervous shock injury.

The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the Court's approach to determining compensation for injuries within the framework of the Criminal Offences Victims Act 1995. The Court emphasized the necessity of a broadbrush approach when assessing the appropriate level of compensation, especially in cases involving psychiatric injuries. The Court recognized that while a predisposition to suffering psychiatric harm may exist, the severity of the incident in question could still warrant a high level of compensation. The Court balanced the applicant's predisposition with the severity of the injury caused by the specific incident, ultimately determining that the upper end of the moderate range for mental or nervous shock injuries was justified.

The Court followed established principles in assessing compensation, applying the statutory scheme's percentage regime to categorize the injuries. In doing so, the Court distinguished the impact of previous domestic violence episodes from the severity of the specific incident in question, ensuring that the compensation reflected the harm caused by the latter. The Court's decision underscores the importance of considering both the physical and psychiatric consequences of criminal acts when determining appropriate compensation under the Act.