Phillips v Le and Wanlin Holdings Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Phillips v Le and Wanlin Holdings Pty Limited [2019] NSWCATCD 87
Hearing dates: 1 July 2019
Date of orders: 15 July 2019
Decision date: 15 July 2019
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: J Rose, General Member
Decision:

The whole of the application in proceedings RT19/16911 is dismissed because the Tribunal is not satisfied at the civil standard of proof (being the balance of probabilities) that grounds exist for the orders sought to be made.

Catchwords:

LEASES AND TENANCIES — Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW) - Standard of proof - Dismissal

Legislation Cited:

Australian Consumer Law

Civil and Administrative TribunalAct 2013 (NSW)

Consumer, Trader and Tenancy Tribunal Act 2001 (NSW)

Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 2002 (NSW)

Property, Stock and Business Agents Regulation2014 (NSW)

Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW)

Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010 (NSW)

Swimming Pools Act 1992 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Bhandari v Laming [2015] NSWCATAP 224

Carnley v Grafton Ngerrie Local Aboriginal Land Council [2010] NSWSC 837

Cogan v King [1998] NSWRT 352

De Soleil v Palmhide Pty Limited [2010] NSWCTTT 464

Felice v Cutting [1992] NSWRT 70

Gray v Queensland Housing Commission [2004] QSC 276

Hall v Hawkins [2015] NSWCATAP 197

Hampel v South Australian Housing Trust [2007] SADC 64

Hearn v Lake Illawarra Park Pty Limited [2013] NSWCTTT 206

Kjoller v Tailford [2016] NSWCATAP 4

McCarthy v Isgai [2009] NSWCTTT 643

Mohr v Marks [1991] NSWRT 172

Morgan v Liverpool Corporation [1927] 2 KB 131

Peebles v Mayfield [2013] NSWCTTT 337

Proudfoot v Hart (1890) 25 QBD 42

Roland Rosenbach v Stewart Harris [2014] NSWCATCD 233

Sonya Pham (Cyclical Pty Ltd) v Terry (Tenancy) [2011] NSWCTTT 476

Summers v Salford Corporation [1943] AC 283

Swinburne v Puco Pty Limited (1995) NSWRT 86

Warner v Hung, in the matter of Bellpac Pty Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In Liquidation) (No 2) [2011] FCA 1123; (2011) 297 ALR 56

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Katrina Phillips and Mark Phillips (Applicants)
Yen Hsiao Lu (First Respondent)
Wanlin Holdings Pty Limited (Second Respondent)
File Number(s): RT19/16911
Publication restriction: Nil

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The Applicants and the first-named Respondent in these proceedings were parties to a residential tenancy agreement dated 15 November 2018 (the Agreement). In these reasons I will refer to:

  1. the Applicants as the "Tenants";

  2. Katrina Phillips, the first-named Applicant as “Mrs Phillips”;

  3. Tiffany Heggie, a witness called by the Tenants, as “Ms Heggie”;

  4. the first-named Respondent as the “Landlord";

  5. the second-named Respondent (who is the Landlord's managing agent for the Premises) as the “Agent”; and

  6. Tracy Le, the Property Investment Manager with the Agent, as “Ms Le”.

I do not intend any disrespect to any person in doing so.

  1. I will also refer to:

  1. the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW) as the “NCAT Act”;

  2. the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW) as the “RT Act”; and

  3. the Property, Stock and Business Agents Act 2002 (NSW) as the “PS&BA Act”.

  1. Under the Agreement, the Tenants…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillips v Le and Wanlin Holdings Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWCATCD 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Phillips v Le and Wanlin Holdings Pty Limited, the dispute involved the interpretation of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 (NSW) concerning the condition of residential premises at the end of a lease term. The respondent, Mr Phillips, sought a declaration and compensation for the landlord's failure to provide residential premises fit for habitation. The first appellant, Ms Le, and the second appellant, Wanlin Holdings Pty Limited, were the landlords of the premises. The case was heard in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales, Appeal Division.

The legal issues before the court revolved around the standard of proof required to establish the condition of the premises at the end of the tenancy and the appropriate weight to be given to various forms of evidence, particularly photographic evidence and condition reports. The court had to determine whether the Tribunal erred in its approach to evaluating evidence and whether the Tribunal was correct in its assessment of the condition of the premises. The court also needed to address whether the statutory presumption under s 30(1) of the Act deprived other evidence, such as photographs, of cogency or reliability.

The court found that the Tribunal did not err in concluding that the photographic evidence and the non-compliant condition report were not sufficient to establish that the premises were in a state of disrepair at the end of the tenancy. The court held that while a compliant condition report is valuable, it is not the exclusive evidence that can be considered. The Tribunal was correct in its approach to evaluating all the evidence presented and determining that it was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the respondent had proven his case. The court also noted that the statutory presumption under s 30(1) does not exclude other forms of evidence and that the weight given to such evidence should be determined on a case-by-case basis.

The application was dismissed, and the whole of the appeal was ultimately unsuccessful. The Tribunal's decision was upheld, and no orders were made in favour of the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

The whole of the application in proceedings RT19/16911 is dismissed because the Tribunal is not satisfied at the civil standard of proof (being the balance of probabilities) that grounds exist for the orders sought to be made.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Thirdly, s. 30(1) does not deprive evidence, other than a condition report signed by both parties, of cogency or reliability. The statement made by the Tribunal below that “[a]lthough photos can be useful evidence, the most cogent evidence is a compliant condition report” may be true in a particular case, but that will depend on all of the evidence considered in the particular circumstances of the case. Such a statement is not correct as a proposition to be applied in all cases or even as a general rule to be applied without regard to all of the evidence. Section 30(1) does not provide a basis for rejecting or ignoring photographic or other evidence as to the state of the premises at the relevant time, where that evidence happens not to be contained in a condition report signed by both the landlord and the tenant. At common law, in the absence of the statutory presumption, the condition of the Premises on any particular date is an issue of fact to be determined by the Tribunal based on the evidence before it. Where the statutory presumption does not apply, the Tribunal normally adopts the approach suggested by the Appeal Panel in Kjoller v Tailford [2016] NSWCATAP 4 at [30]-[34]: Just because an outgoing condition report does not comply with s. 29(4) of the Residential Tenancies Act, that does not mean that no weight can be attributed to it when a claim for damages is made. … … Giving “no weight” to the condition report was an error of law. That evidence deserved some weight. … The evidence needs to be sufficient to persuade the Tribunal, on the balance of probabilities, that the tenant had not left the residential premises as nearly as possible in the same condition, fair wear and tear excepted ... as when the agreement was entered into. … the Tribunal should … identif[y] and evaluate[] all the evidence that had some probative value and given reasons for accepting or rejecting that evidence. … However, it must also be remembered that the parties agreed to modify the operation of the common law between them by clause 46 of the Agreement. That clause provided: Where the landlord has in compliance with the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 provided the tenant with the landlord’s signed condition report and the tenant has not returned the condition report within 7 days of receipt the tenant will be deemed to have accepted the condition report. The obligation to provide residential premises fit for habitation is mandatory and, according to language used in the provision, unqualified. Relevantly, the obligation is not expressed to be contingent on reasonable steps or to be dependent on the landlord being at fault or having control over the event or circumstance affecting the state of the premises. This is in contrast with the obligation on the landlord to provide and maintain the residential premises in a reasonable state of repair (s 63 RTA) and the obligation that arises in respect of the tenant’s entitlement to quiet enjoyment of the residential premises (s 50 RTA). The landlord’s obligations under sections 50, 63 and 52 (in relation to the state of cleanliness of the residential premises) are mandatory and ongoing but qualified by the concept of reasonableness.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.