Phillips v Commissioner of State Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Phillips v Commissioner of State Revenue  [2023] QCAT 426

PARTIES:

LOUISE MAREE PHILLIPS

(applicant)

v

COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR676-21

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

30 October 2023

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member King-Scott

ORDERS:

1.     The Commissioner’s decision of 6 October 2021 is set aside;

2.     The Applicant be paid the HomeBuilder Grant of $25,000;

3.     The parties may file and exchange any application for costs supported by evidence and written submissions by 4:00 pm on 30 November 2023.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – review of decision to refuse payment of Home Builder Grant – where home owner held title in company shares and not by way of strata title – where grant refused by Commissioner – where Administrative Direction conferred discretion in Commissioner to change requirement or process necessary to ensure proper administration and integrity of the Home Builder Grant – where Commissioner refused to exercise discretion – where Administrative Direction did not align with homeowner grant under same legislation which included company title – Tribunal exercised discretion in favour of applicant

First Home Owner’s Grant and Other Grants Act 2000 (Qld)

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), ss 18-20.

Aurizon Operations Limited v Commissioner of State Revenue; Australian Eastern Railroad Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2021] QCAT 338

IC Assets Pty Ltd & Anor v Commissioner of State Revenue [2011] QSC

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The Applicant, Louise Maree Phillips, owns her home through a "company title" structure. Company title was an alternative method of ownership of a home unit before strata legislation was introduced.

  2. Strata legislation provides for the individual ownership of a unit (called a lot) and shared ownership over driveways, foyers, lifts, gardens, etc (called common property) through a body corporate.

  3. Company title also provides for shared ownership of common property through shareholding in a company and individual ownership of units through perpetual leases from the company to the shareholders of the company.

  4. Ms Phillips applied to the Commissioner for the HomeBuilder Grant (the “Grant"). The Commissioner refused the grant because Ms Phillips owns her home through a company title structure.

  5. Ms Phillips objected to the Commissioner's decision and requested the Commissioner exercise their discretion under the relevant administrative direction to allow the grant. Ms Phillips requested the discretion be exercised so as to provide for the grant to be paid to homeowners in company title structures.

  6. The Commissioner has refused to exercise the discretion.

History

  1. Toorak Holdings Pty Ltd (ACN 009 680 380) is the owner of an estate in fee simple in the land described as Lot 2 on RP 97150.[1] In the late 1950s, the “Camden" apartment building was built on this land.

    [1]Respondent’s documents…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillips v Commissioner of State Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 426
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Phillips v Commissioner of State Revenue, the respondent, the Commissioner of State Revenue, refused to pay a Home Builder Grant to the applicant, Ms Phillips, because she held title to the property in question in company shares rather than by way of a strata title. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was tasked with reviewing this decision. The key issue for the tribunal was whether the Commissioner had discretion under the Administrative Direction to alter the requirements or processes of the Home Builder Grant program to accommodate Ms Phillips' situation, and if so, whether this discretion should have been exercised. Ms Phillips argued that the Commissioner's refusal to exercise this discretion was erroneous, as the Administrative Direction explicitly provided for such flexibility. The Commissioner contended that the discretion was not intended for ad hoc application to individual cases but rather to make general changes to the Administrative Direction over time. The tribunal found that the Administrative Direction did indeed grant the Commissioner the discretion to modify the requirements of the program, and that this discretion was applicable to Ms Phillips' specific case. The tribunal further held that the Commissioner had the authority to exercise this discretion and that Ms Phillips' situation warranted such an exercise. Consequently, the tribunal set aside the Commissioner's decision and ordered that Ms Phillips be paid the Home Builder Grant of $25,000. The parties were also instructed to file and exchange any application for costs supported by evidence and written submissions by a specified deadline.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Commissioner’s decision of 6 October 2021 is set aside;

2. The Applicant be paid the HomeBuilder Grant of $25,000;

3. The parties may file and exchange any application for costs supported by evidence and written submissions by 4:00 pm on 30 November 2023.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 60 provides:QCAT to decide review on evidence before the commissioner(1) This section applies to a proceeding for a review by QCAT of a decision of the commissioner on an objection.(2) QCAT must—a. hear and decide the review of the decision by way of a reconsideration of the evidence before the commissioner when the decision was made, unless QCAT considers it necessary in the interests of justice to allow new evidence; andb. decide the review of the decision in accordance with the same law that applied to the making of the original decision. (3) The grounds on which the application for review is made are limited to the grounds of the relevant objection unless QCAT otherwise orders.(4) If QCAT decides, under the QCAT Act, section 139, that the proceeding should be reopened, the issues in the proceeding that are reheard must be—a. heard and decided by way of a reconsideration of the evidence given in the proceeding for the review of the decision; andb. decided in accordance with the same law that applied to the making of the original decision.(5) In this section—new evidence means evidence that was not before the commissioner when the decision on the objection was made.original decision means the decision of the commissioner that was the subject of the relevant objection.relevant objection means the objection to which the decision of the commissioner relates. Ms Phillips principal ground of objection is that the Commissioner erred in failing to exercise the discretion vested in him by paragraph 63 of the Amended Direction. Paragraph 63 of the Amended Direction confers on the Commissioner a discretion to amend or vary the Amended Direction. A similar discretion is not contained in the Original Direction. The Commissioner submits that the Original Direction applies, being the administrative direction in force on the date Ms Phillips submitted her application for the Grant online. Ms Phillips submits that the Amended Direction applies, being the administrative direction in force on the date the Commissioner made their decision. The Commissioner submits that the discretion was not conferred to make concessions for particular applications on an ad hoc basis, rather it was conferred to amend (for all purposes) the requirements of the Administrative Direction from time to time. For this reason, the Commissioner submits that they cannot be compelled to exercise the discretion by Ms Phillips, nor does the Tribunal have the power to exercise the discretion. Ms Phillips submits that the Tribunal has all the functions of the decision-maker for the reviewable decision being reviewed. For this reason, Ms Phillips submits that that the Tribunal has the power to exercise the discretion. Ms Phillips was advised by letter dated 3 August 2021 inter alia that:Paragraph 24 of the Administrative Direction states that for a substantial renovation contract, the applicant must be the sole registered freehold owner of the property as at the contract commencement date.Documentation provided for your HomeBuilder Grant application indicates that you have entered into a contract for the renovation of the property located at 3A/11 Hillside Crescent, Hamilton on 2 November 2020Records obtained from the title registry office evidence that the registered freehold owner of property is to Toorak Holdings Pty limited. As you are not the sole registered freehold owner of the property as at 2 November 2020, paragraph 1.c and 24 are not satisfied.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established