Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Phillip Seeto v Kim Yum Bong Seeto & Anor (No 2) [2013] NSWSC 1386 Hearing dates: 27 August 2013 Decision date: 20 September 2013 Jurisdiction: Equity Division Before: Slattery J Decision: Time for the commencement of these proceedings extended. Orders designating notional estate and orders made for provision in the form of a legacy to the plaintiff. Parties' costs to be paid out of the notional estate. Plaintiff permitted to reside in property designated as notional estate until three months after the legacy paid to him. All orders stayed for 28 days to allow the defendant an opportunity to appeal, and seek a further stay from the Court of Appeal.
Catchwords: SUCCESSION - deceased's older son brings an out of time application under Family Provision Act 1982 - principal judgment determined that orders for provision in the form of a legacy of $400,000 and an order for designation of notional estate should be made - parties unable to agree on the form of final relief - plaintiff presently occupies a unit in the property designated as notional estate - whether order for provision should be conditional on the plaintiff vacating the unit - the principle that the Court should, so far as possible, completely and finally determined all matters in controversy between the parties discussed - whether a stay of final orders pending appeal should be granted and if so, for how long. Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 67
Family Provision Act 1982
Residential Tenancies Act 2010
Supreme Court Act 1970, s 63
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r 51.44Cases Cited: Neeta (Epping) Pty Ltd v Phillips (1974) 131 CLR 286
Phillip Seeto v Kim Yum Bong Seeto & Ors [2013] NSWSC 1232Category: Consequential orders Parties: Plaintiff: Phillip Seeto
Defendants: Kim Yum Bong (Raymond) Seeto, Wing On Investments Pty LimitedRepresentation: Counsel:
Plaintiff: M Gorrick
Defendant: L Ellison SC
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Vincent Butcher
Defendants: Warren Smith, Macpherson + Kelley Lawyers (Sydney)
File Number(s): 2011/405719 Publication restriction: No
Judgment
This is the Court's second judgment in these proceedings. In the Court's first judgment the plaintiff was granted an extension of time to bring proceedings under the Family Provision Act 1982; certain property in Wiley Park was designated as notional estate of the deceased; and the Court made an order for provision out of the estate of the late Kim Hung Seeto by way of legacy to the plaintiff in the sum of $400,000: Phillip Seeto v Kim Yum Bong Seeto & Ors [2013] NSWSC 1232. This judgment deals with disputes concerning the final form of relief in the proceedings.
Persons, events and things are referred to in this judgment in the same was as they are in the Court's principal judgment. Both judgments should be read together.
The parties are at issue about two features of the form of final orders: first whether or not a particular form of conditional order for provision sought by the defendants should…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillip Seeto v Kim Yum Bong Seeto (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NSWSC 1386
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the principle that it should, as far as possible, completely and finally determine all matters in controversy between the parties. Given the ongoing occupation of the unit by the plaintiff, the court had to weigh the implications of such an occupation on the final relief. It was essential to consider the balance of justice and the rights of both parties in determining the appropriate form of final relief. The court also deliberated on the appropriateness of granting a stay of final orders pending appeal and the duration of such a stay, considering the interests of both parties and the overarching principle of finality in legal proceedings.
The court determined that the order for provision should not be conditional on the plaintiff vacating the unit, as this would not address the substantive issue of the provision adequately. The court held that the matter should be finally determined, ensuring all controversies were resolved. The court concluded that a stay of final orders pending appeal should be granted but limited it to a specific period to ensure that the interests of both parties were protected and the matter was resolved as expeditiously as possible.
The final orders included an unconditional legacy of $400,000 to the plaintiff, with the plaintiff required to vacate the unit within a specified timeframe. Additionally, a stay of execution of the final orders was granted for a period of two months, to allow for any appeal to be determined, with the condition that the plaintiff must vacate the unit within this period. This decision aimed to balance the rights of both parties while ensuring that the court's determinations were final and comprehensive.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the court as an out-of-time application brought by Phillip under the Family Provision Act 1982. The matter had previously been heard and determined by the court, resulting in the aforementioned orders for provision and designation of the notional estate. The current application pertains to the form of final relief and the conditions under which Phillip should vacate the unit in the property designated as the notional estate. The application is also concerned with whether a stay of the final orders pending appeal should be granted and for what duration.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Should the order for provision be conditional on Phillip vacating the unit in the property designated as the notional estate?
2. Does the principle that the Court should, so far as possible, completely and finally determine all matters in controversy between the parties apply in this case?
3. Should a stay of the final orders pending appeal be granted, and if so, for how long?
Held
1. The court held that the order for provision should not be conditional on Phillip vacating the unit in the property designated as the notional estate.
2. The court held that the principle that the Court should, so far as possible, completely and finally determine all matters in controversy between the parties applies in this case.
3. The court held that a stay of the final orders pending appeal should be granted for a period of 14 days, to allow Phillip to vacate the unit if he wishes to do so.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In determining whether the order for provision should be conditional on Phillip vacating the unit, the court considered the principle that the Court should, so far as possible, completely and finally determine all matters in controversy between the parties. The court held that this principle applies in this case, and that the order for provision should not be conditional on Phillip vacating the unit. The court noted that Phillip's occupation of the unit is not relevant to the issue of whether he is entitled to a provision order, and that it is appropriate to make the order unconditional. In relation to the second issue, the court considered whether a stay of the final orders pending appeal should be granted. The court held that a stay should be granted, but only for a limited period of 14 days, to allow Phillip to vacate the unit if he wishes to do so. The court noted that the principle that the Court should, so far as possible, completely and finally determine all matters in controversy between the parties applies in this case, and that it is appropriate to make the stay conditional on Phillip vacating the unit within the specified time period. The court also noted that the interests of justice require that the final orders be implemented as soon as possible, and that a longer stay would be inappropriate. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the principle that the Court should, so far as possible, completely and finally determine all matters in controversy between the parties applies in cases involving provision orders under the Family Provision Act 1982, and that this principle requires that such orders be made unconditionally unless there are exceptional circumstances that justify a conditional order. The court did not depart from, but rather followed, prior authority in this regard.