Phillip Lawrence Cohen v Damon Peter Fealy

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2021] QCA 72

COURT OF APPEAL

McMURDO JA
MULLINS JA
BRADLEY J

Appeal No 12597 of 2020
DC No 9 of 2020

PHILLIP LAWRENCE COHEN  Applicant

v

DAMON PETER FEALY  Respondent

BRISBANE

THURSDAY, 15 APRIL 2021

JUDGMENT

McMURDO JA:  This is an application for leave to appeal against an interlocutory decision of Judge Chowdhury which set aside subpoenas for the production of documents.  The applicant, who is a qualified but not a practising lawyer, is the plaintiff in a proceeding in the District Court in which he claims damages for an alleged defamatory statement made by the defendant.  This was commenced in May last year and the pleadings closed on 23 June.  Less than a week later, he caused subpoenas to be issued to six persons who are said to have been present at a board meeting at which the defendant is said to have made the defamatory statement.  The defendant denies doing so.

The subpoenas were in very wide terms.  They called for the production of documents in paper or electronic form, and whether the originals, copies, or backups, of all correspondence between the recipient and any person which contained any reference to the applicant or his position, and of all diaries, notes, minutes, recordings and other records relating to any such correspondence.  Each subpoena was accompanied by a cheque for $50 for conduct money.  One of the recipients, Mr Cook, swore an affidavit saying that he had responded to the subpoena and had handed his cheque back, saying that this was because he did not want any payment from the applicant.  Another recipient, Mr Bass, presented his cheque but did not respond to the subpoena.  The other individuals did not present their cheques or respond to their subpoenas.  The subpoenas required a response by 31 July, however, that date was to be extended to 28 August.

The application to set aside the subpoenas was not made by the recipients.  It was made by the defendant in the proceeding.  At the same time, the applicant applied for orders, ex parte, against the recipients, apart from Mr Cook, for orders that they be arrested and brought before the Court to be dealt with for contempt for their failure to comply with the subpoenas.  The judge identified the question of whether the subpoenas were an abuse of process as the fundamental issue on each application.

He held that they were an abuse of process, not because the width of their terms made them oppressive or because the material sought was irrelevant to the proceeding, but because the applicant should have issued a notice of non-party disclosure to each of those persons pursuant to r 242 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.  His Honour rejected the submission that the respondent, as the defendant in the proceeding, had no standing to apply to set aside the subpoenas issued to non-parties.

As this application recognises the decision can be appealed only the leave of this Court.  Ordinarily, leave is not granted in a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillip Lawrence Cohen v Damon Peter Fealy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCA 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Phillip Lawrence Cohen has made an application for leave to appeal against a decision of Judge Chowdhury which set aside subpoenas that he had issued for the production of documents. The subpoenas were issued to six persons who were present at a board meeting at which the respondent, Damon Peter Fealy, allegedly made a defamatory statement. The respondent denies making the statement and had applied to set aside the subpoenas. The primary judge held that the subpoenas were an abuse of process because the applicant should have issued a notice of non-party disclosure to each of those persons pursuant to r 242 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The applicant submits that the decision was wrong in principle, but the Court held that the primary judge was correct to hold that the respondent had standing to bring the application and that the subpoenas were an abuse of process because the procedure of a subpoena should not be used to bypass the safeguards to a non-party which were provided by the rules for the process of non-party disclosure. The Court held that there was no basis for this Court to reverse the judgment so that these subpoenas would have effect and that it was more expeditious for the applicant to pursue the documents by the process of a non-party disclosure. The Court also held that there was no denial of procedural fairness in that order for costs being made and that costs should follow the event. Leave to appeal was refused and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondent’s costs of the application for leave to appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Phillip Lawrence Cohen, a qualified but not practising lawyer, initiated a defamation proceeding against Damon Peter Fealy in the District Court in May 2020. The plaintiff claimed damages for an alleged defamatory statement made by the defendant. The pleadings in the case concluded on 23 June 2020. Shortly after, the plaintiff issued subpoenas to six individuals who were allegedly present at a board meeting where the defendant is said to have made the defamatory statement. The defendant denies this. The subpoenas, which were in very wide terms, called for the production of documents in paper or electronic form, and whether originals, copies, or backups, of all correspondence between the recipients and any person which contained any reference to the plaintiff or his position, and of all diaries, notes, minutes, recordings, and other records relating to any such correspondence. The subpoenas required a response by 31 July, later extended to 28 August. One of the recipients, Mr Cook, responded to the subpoena and returned his cheque, stating he did not want payment from the plaintiff. Another recipient, Mr Bass, presented his cheque but did not respond to the subpoena. The other individuals did not respond or present their cheques.

The defendant in the proceeding, Damon Peter Fealy, applied to set aside the subpoenas, arguing they were an abuse of process. The plaintiff, Phillip Lawrence Cohen, applied for orders, ex parte, against the recipients, apart from Mr Cook, for orders that they be arrested and brought before the Court to be dealt with for contempt for their failure to comply with the subpoenas. The primary judge, Judge Chowdhury, held that the subpoenas were an abuse of process and set them aside. The judge rejected the plaintiff's contention that the defendant had no standing to apply to set aside the subpoenas issued to non-parties. The plaintiff now seeks leave to appeal against this interlocutory decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the defendant have standing to apply for the subpoenas to be set aside as an abuse of process?
2. Was the decision to set aside the subpoenas as an abuse of process correct in principle?
3. Should the application to adduce further evidence be allowed?
4. Should the plaintiff be allowed to appeal the interlocutory decision?

Held
1. The defendant had standing to apply for the subpoenas to be set aside as an abuse of process.
2. The decision to set aside the subpoenas as an abuse of process was not correct in principle.
3. The application to adduce further evidence should be refused.
4. The plaintiff's application for leave to appeal the interlocutory decision should be refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the defendant's standing to apply for the subpoenas to be set aside as an abuse of process. The Court held that the defendant, as the respondent in the proceeding, had standing to make the application. This decision was based on the reasoning of Judge Alan Wilson in Darwen v Pacific Reef Fisheries (Australia) Pty Ltd [2009] QPELR 616, which stated that a party to a proceeding has standing to argue that a subpoena issued to a non-party should be set aside as an abuse of process. The Court also referred to Justice Powell's judgment in Botany Bay Instrumentation & Control Pty Ltd v Stewart [1984] 3 NSWLR 98, which supported the view that a party to a proceeding can exercise the Court's power to prevent an abuse of its own process.

The Court further considered the correctness of the decision to set aside the subpoenas as an abuse of process. The Court disagreed with the primary judge's view that the use of subpoenas in every case where documents could be sought by non-party disclosure will always be an abuse of process. The Court held that the primary judge may have been too strict in his view, and that there could be cases where the urgent production of documents of evidentiary value and where there is an imminent risk that the documents would be lost or destroyed would not necessarily be an abuse of process.

However, the Court found that despite the applicant's claim that there were circumstances of urgency requiring the production of these documents now, the evidence presented fell short of demonstrating that it was necessary to employ this process. The Court noted that the applicant also issued a subpoena to the organisation in question, which could have been used to pursue the documents by the process of a non-party disclosure.

The Court then considered the application to adduce further evidence, which related to a substantial controversy between different factions within the organisation in question. The Court held that the application should be refused, as the further evidence post-dated the hearing below and could not have affected the outcome.

Finally, the Court considered the plaintiff's application for leave to appeal the interlocutory decision. The Court held that there was no basis for this Court to reverse the judgment so that these subpoenas would have effect, and that it would be more expeditious for the applicant to pursue the documents by the process of a non-party disclosure. The Court also held that the application for leave to appeal should be refused, and ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs of the application for leave to appeal.