Phillip John Carmody v Walter Merriman & Sons Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
__________________________________________________________________

CITATION:

Phillip John Carmody v Walter Merriman & Sons Pty Ltd

[2003] NSW WCC PD 27

APPELLANT: Phillip John Carmody
RESPONDENT: Walter Merriman & Sons Pty Ltd
INSURER: Zurich Australian Workers Compensation Ltd
FILE NO: WCC  2976-2002
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 19 June 2003
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 20 October 2003
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Application for leave to appeal against a decision of an Arbitrator, powers of an Approved Medical Specialist, referral to Approved Medical Specialist, status of medical assessment.
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Dr Gabriel Fleming
HEARING: On the Papers
REPRESENTATION:

Appellant: Robb and Associates, Solicitors

Respondent: Goldrick Farrell Mullan, Solicitors

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

Leave to Appeal the Arbitrator’s decision is granted.

The decision of the Arbitrator is revoked and the following decision is made in its place:

The Medical Assessment Certificate of the Approved Medical Specialist, Dr Peter Isbister dated 9 April 2003 is conclusively presumed to be correct as to the assessment of the whole of the Applicant’s permanent impairment suffered as a result of his injury on 28 May 2001.

The Respondent is to pay the Appellant’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or assessed

The matter is referred to the Registrar for allocation to an Arbitrator to determine the remaining issues in dispute.

THE APPEAL

  1. On 11 July 2003, Philllip John Carmody, (‘the Appellant’), lodged an ‘Application for Appeal Against a Decision of an Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision dated 19 June 2003.  The Respondent to the appeal is Walter Merriman & Sons Pty Ltd (‘the Respondent’) and the relevant Insurer is Zurich Australian Workers Compensation Ltd (‘the Insurer’).

THE DECISION UNDER REVIEW

  1. On 19 December 2002 the Arbitrator referred this dispute to an Approved Medical Specialist (AMS), Dr Peter Isbister, with a request that the AMS report on the following matters:

    A.Has the Applicant’s injury stabilized?

    B.If so, what is the degree of permanent impairment of his back?

    C.What percentage, if any, of any impairment of the back is attributable to the Applicant’s condition pre-existing the injury sustained on 22 May 2001?

  2. On 9 April 2003 Dr Isbister issued a Medical Assessment Certificate which concluded, among other things, that Mr Carmody had suffered a permanent impairment as a result of his injury at work on 28 May 2001, this injury had stabilized and had resulted in a 15% impairment of his back and 5% impairment of his left leg at or above the knee.  Dr Isbister opined that:

    I note that his claim is for his back only, however, although his leg symptoms have reduced he still has evidence of Radiculopathy, including loss of ankle jerk and restriction of full leg raising ability. In my opinion this constitutes 5% permanent loss of efficient use of his left leg at or above the knee due to his back condition.

  3. The AMS’s report was referred to the Arbitrator.  On 19 June 2003 a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phillip John Carmody v Walter Merriman & Sons Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWWCCPD 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Phillip John Carmody has applied for leave to appeal against an arbitrator’s decision, issued on 19 June 2003, under section 352 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The application for leave was lodged within the statutory 28-day period, on 11 July 2003, and the appeal was referred to the court on 13 October 2003. The court must decide whether the appeal meets the statutory criteria for leave to appeal, specifically, whether the amount of compensation at issue is at least $5,000 and at least 20% of the amount awarded in the arbitrator’s decision. The court must also determine whether the decision of the arbitrator should be revoked and a new decision made in its place. The court was required to decide whether the amount of compensation at issue in the appeal meets the statutory criteria for leave to appeal, and whether the decision of the arbitrator should be revoked and a new decision made in its place.

The court held that the amount of compensation at issue in the appeal was $3,750 for 5% permanent impairment for the permanent loss of efficient use of the left leg at or above the knee, and $15,000 claimed for pain and suffering. The court held that this amount met the statutory criteria for leave to appeal, as it was at least $5,000 and at least 20% of the amount awarded in the arbitrator’s decision. The court also held that the decision of the arbitrator should be revoked and a new decision made in its place, as the medical assessment certificate of the approved medical specialist, Dr Peter Isbister, dated 9 April 2003, was conclusively presumed to be correct as to the assessment of the whole of the applicant’s permanent impairment suffered as a result of his injury on 28 May 2001. The court also held that the respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or assessed. The matter is referred to the Registrar for allocation to an Arbitrator to determine the remaining issues in dispute.

The court granted leave to appeal the arbitrator’s decision, revoked the decision and made a new decision in its place. The court held that the medical assessment certificate of the approved medical specialist, Dr Peter Isbister, dated 9 April 2003, is conclusively presumed to be correct as to the assessment of the whole of the applicant’s permanent impairment suffered as a result of his injury on 28 May 2001. The court also held that the respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or assessed. The matter is referred to the Registrar for allocation to an Arbitrator to determine the remaining issues in dispute.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to Appeal the Arbitrator’s decision is granted.

The decision of the Arbitrator is revoked and the following decision is made in its place:

The Medical Assessment Certificate of the Approved Medical Specialist, Dr Peter Isbister dated 9 April 2003 is conclusively presumed to be correct as to the assessment of the whole of the Applicant’s permanent impairment suffered as a result of his injury on 28 May 2001.

The Respondent is to pay the Appellant’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or assessed

The matter is referred to the Registrar for allocation to an Arbitrator to determine the remaining issues in dispute.

Background

Background to the litigation

Phillip John Carmody, the appellant, was injured in an accident on 28 May 2001, which resulted in a claim for workers' compensation. The dispute arose over the assessment of his permanent impairment and the quantum of compensation awarded. An Arbitrator, who was part of the Commission, made a decision on 19 June 2003, which assessed the appellant's permanent impairment at 5% for the loss of efficient use of his left leg at or above the knee. Additionally, the Arbitrator considered the appellant's claim for pain and suffering under section 67 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The appellant sought to appeal this decision, arguing that the amount at issue met the threshold criteria set out in section 352 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998.

The appeal was lodged with the Commission on 11 July 2003, within 28 days of the Arbitrator's decision, in accordance with section 352(4) of the 1998 Act and Rule 77 of the Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2003. The appellant's written submissions were received by the Commission on 28 July 2003. However, there was a significant delay in the sealing and registration of the application, which occurred on 22 September 2003. The appeal was subsequently referred to a member of the Commission on 13 October 2003 for determination of the application for leave to appeal. The appellant argued that the amount at issue in the appeal met the criteria in section 352(2), while the respondent argued that the appeal was restricted to an amount below the threshold.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before proceeding to hear the appeal the Commission must determine whether the application for leave meets the requirements of section 352 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (‘the 1998 Act’), as follows:352Appeal against decision of Commission constituted by Arbitrator(1)A party to a dispute in connection with a claim for compensation may, with leave of the Commission constituted by a Presidential member, appeal to the Commission as so constituted against a decision in respect of the dispute by the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator.(2)The Commission is not to grant leave to appeal unless the amount of compensation at issue on the appeal is both:(a)at least $5,000 (or such other amount as may be prescribed by the regulations), and(b)at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against.(3)If the Commission refuses to grant leave to appeal, the Commission must state reasons for the refusal in writing to the parties.(4)An appeal can only be made within 28 days after the making of the decision appealed against.(5)An appeal under this section is to be by way of review of the decision appealed against.(6)Evidence that is fresh evidence or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against may not be given on an appeal to the Commission except with the leave of the Commission.(7)On appeal, the decision may be confirmed or may be revoked and a new decision made in its place.(8)In this section, decision includes an award, interim award, order, determination, ruling and direction. The Arbitrator’s decision was made on 19 June 2003 and the appeal was lodged on 11 July 2003. This is within 28 days of the Arbitrator’s decision, in accordance with section 352(4) of the 1998 Act and Rule 77 of the Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2003 (‘the Rules’, effective from 1 July 2003). Rule 77 (4) distinguishes between the ‘lodgement’ of an application for leave to appeal and the registration of that application by the Registrar. Rule 16 provides for the ‘Form of Documents’ in the Commission. The Registrar may refuse to ‘accept, file, seal or issue any document’ that is not in the required form and in compliance with relevant Practice Directions. On 28 July the Applicant’s written submissions were received in the Commission. There was a significant delay in the sealing and registration of the application, which occurred on 22 September 2003. This delay is inexplicable from a reading of the Commission’s file. The appeal was referred to me on 13 October 2003. The Appellant claims that the amount at issue in the appeal meets the criteria in section 352(2) in that the amount at issue is the whole of $3,750 with respect to 5% permanent impairment for the permanent loss of efficient use of the left leg at or above the knee, and $15,000 claimed for pain and suffering pursuant to section 67 of the 1987 Act. The Respondent claims that the appeal is restricted to an amount of $3,750 and therefore below the threshold in section 352(2).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court first considered the issue of whether the amount of compensation at issue met the criteria in section 352(2) of the 1998 Act. The amount in dispute was $3,750 for 5% permanent impairment and $15,000 for pain and suffering. The court found that the amount in dispute met the threshold of being at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against, thus satisfying the criteria in section 352(2) of the 1998 Act.

Next, the court examined the procedural requirements of the application for leave to appeal. The application was lodged within 28 days of the Arbitrator's decision, in accordance with section 352(4) of the 1998 Act and Rule 77 of the Rules. The court noted that there was a significant delay in the sealing and registration of the application, but found that this did not affect the compliance with the procedural requirements.

The court then addressed whether the decision of the Arbitrator should be revoked and, if so, what should be the consequential orders. The court found that the Arbitrator's decision was flawed, as the Arbitrator had not considered the whole of the applicant's permanent impairment in making the assessment. The court revoked the Arbitrator's decision and made a new decision, conclusively presuming the correctness of the medical assessment certificate of the Approved Medical Specialist, Dr Peter Isbister.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when an Arbitrator fails to consider the whole of a claimant's permanent impairment in making an assessment, the decision of the Arbitrator may be revoked, and a new decision may be made in its place. Furthermore, the court must consider the compliance with procedural requirements when determining whether to grant leave to appeal, even in the presence of procedural delays.