Philip Morris Limited and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Philip Morris Limited and Comptroller-General of Customs [2022] AATA 548 (23 March 2022)

Division: TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION      

File Number(s):      2020/6663          

Re:Philip Morris Limited  

APPLICANT

Comptroller-General of Customs And  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

Date:23 March 2022

Place:Melbourne

The decision under review is affirmed.

.............................. [SGD]............................

CATCHWORDS

ELIGIBILITY FOR DRAWBACK OF IMPORT DUTY PAYABLE IN RESPECT OF GOODS DESPATCHED FROM AUSTRALIAN WAREHOUSES FOR EXPORT IN JULY AND AUGUST 2019 – whereas the applicant made an application for drawback of import duty payable – whether the applicant gave notice in writing as required under Regulation 37 – whether there is a discretion to pay the drawback notwithstanding non-compliance with Regulation 37 – applicant was ineligible for drawback payments because the applicant did not comply with the requirement to give notice – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Customs Act 1901 (Cth)

Customs Amendment (Collecting Tobacco Duties at the Border) Act 2018
Customs (International Obligations) Regulation 2015

CASES

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenues (2009) 239 CLR 27

Comptroller General of Customs v Zappia [2018] HCA 54
DFS Australia Pty Ltd v Comptroller-General of Customs [2017] FCA 547
Prudential Assurance Co Ltd v Health Minders Pty Ltd (1987) 9 NSWLR 673
R v Lyon [1906] HCA 17; (1906) 3 CLR 770
Secretary, Department of Family and Community Services v Rogers (2000) 104 FCR 272; [2000] FCA 1447
Williams v Nicoski [2003] WASC 131

REASONS FOR DECISION

23 March 2022

  1. The applicant is part of a multi-national group that manufactures and supplies tobacco products. The applicant imports product into this country which is manufactured elsewhere. That inevitably means the applicant must engage with the provisions of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) and subordinate legislation that impose swingeing duties on tobacco products. These proceedings arise out of a misunderstanding about the administrative procedures required following an amendment to that regime. The misunderstanding about the required paperwork is potentially costly. In excess of $29 million in drawback claims are at stake.

  2. Prior to 1 July 2019, the applicant landed all the tobacco products it imported into Australia (including the goods destined for re-export or for sale in duty-free outlets) and delivered them to secure warehouses for storage. The applicant would complete a warehouse declaration when the goods were landed so the Australian Border Force (the ABF) knew the disposition of the goods. The applicant would not be required to pay the import duties levied on tobacco products until it entered the goods for home consumption. That occurred when the applicant readied the goods for domestic distribution and completed the relevant customs declaration pursuant to s 68 of the Customs Act. But the stocks destined for re-export or for duty free outlets could be held back from the Australian market. Those goods (about 5% of the total that was landed in Australia) could be retained in a bonded warehouse without attracting duty. The goods reserved for export could be despatched in fulfilment of an overseas order without…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Philip Morris Limited and Comptroller-General of Customs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 548
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Philip Morris Limited (the applicant) sought drawback of import duty payable in respect of goods exported from Australian warehouses in July and August 2019. The Comptroller-General of Customs (the respondent) refused the application, and the applicant sought review of this decision before Deputy President Bernard J McCabe of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant had complied with the requirement to give written notice under Regulation 37 of the relevant customs regulations, and if not, whether there was a discretion to pay the drawback notwithstanding such non-compliance.

The Tribunal determined that strict compliance with the written notice requirement of Regulation 37 was mandatory. The plain language of the regulation indicated that drawback of duty was not payable in the event of non-compliance, and there was no discretion vested in the respondent to permit payment in such circumstances. While acknowledging the potentially harsh outcome for the applicant, particularly given apparent confusion within the Australian Border Force regarding required forms following regulatory amendments, the Tribunal concluded that its review was confined to the explicit requirements of the regulations. The Tribunal noted that any claim for compensation due to defective administration would be a separate process.

Background

Background to the litigation

Philip Morris Limited applied for drawback of import duty payable in respect of goods that were despatched from Australian warehouses for export during July and August 2019. The Comptroller-General of Customs, through the Australian Border Force (ABF), denied the applicant's application on the basis that the applicant had failed to comply with Regulation 37, which requires that written notice be given to the Comptroller-General before drawback is paid. The regulation explicitly states that drawback is not payable in the event of non-compliance, leaving no discretion for the Comptroller-General to pay drawback if the written notice requirement is not met. This denial of drawback arose despite the fact that the ABF showed little interest in inspecting the applicant's exported goods and there was some confusion within the ABF regarding the necessary forms following recent amendments to the regulations.

The applicant argued that the denial of drawback was unjust given the ABF's lack of engagement and the confusion over the necessary paperwork. The applicant suggested that this might constitute maladministration on the part of the ABF, potentially warranting compensation under the Scheme for Compensation for Detriment caused by Defective Administration. However, the Tribunal clarified that this was a separate process from the review of the decision to deny drawback. The Tribunal's role was to determine whether the Comptroller-General's decision to deny drawback was in accordance with the law, not to address issues of maladministration or compensation. The Tribunal confirmed that the applicant's failure to comply with the strict requirement of giving written notice under Regulation 37 was a valid reason for denying the drawback application. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Comptroller-General.

The case before the court concerns an application for the drawback of import duty by Philip Morris Limited in relation to goods exported from Australian warehouses in July and August 2019. The applicant, Philip Morris Limited, sought a review of a decision by the Comptroller-General of Customs that deemed the applicant ineligible for drawback payments due to non-compliance with the requirement to provide written notice as stipulated in Regulation 37. The matter came before the court as an application for judicial review, challenging the administrative decision made by the Comptroller-General of Customs. The primary focus of the review was on whether the Comptroller-General correctly interpreted and applied the regulatory requirements concerning the notice for drawback eligibility.

Prior to the judicial review, the Comptroller-General had determined that the applicant was ineligible for drawback payments because it had not provided the requisite written notice as mandated by Regulation 37. The applicant argued that despite the oversight, the Comptroller-General had discretion to pay the drawback. Throughout the review process, key procedural steps included the submission of the application for judicial review, the examination of the relevant regulations and administrative decisions, and the consideration of whether the Comptroller-General's interpretation of the regulation was correct. The court's review affirmed the initial decision, concluding that the applicant was indeed required to strictly adhere to the regulatory requirement for written notice, and that non-compliance precluded eligibility for drawback payments.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant had to comply strictly with the requirement to give notice. The plain language of the text of the regulation means that drawback of duty is not payable in the event of non-compliance. There is no discretion to pay drawback in the circumstances. That is a hard result for the applicant in circumstances where the ABF showed little interest in inspecting goods that the applicant was exporting, and where at least some within the ABF were confused about the forms that were required following the amendments. To the extent there is a suggestion of maladministration within the ABF contributing to the error, there might be an argument for compensation under the Scheme for Compensation for Detriment caused by Defective Administration. That is a separate process to the Tribunal’s review. The Tribunal’s review confirms the applicant was required to strictly comply with a requirement that was explicit in the regulations before it could receive a drawback payment. CONCLUSION The reviewable decision is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether the applicant strictly complied with the requirement to give notice in writing under Regulation 37 for the drawback of import duty, the court first examined the express terms of the regulation. The regulation was clear and unambiguous, requiring that any application for drawback must be accompanied by written notice. The court found that the applicant had not given the required notice in writing, and thus did not strictly comply with the regulation. This finding was made irrespective of the applicant's good faith efforts or the administrative confusion within the Australian Border Force (ABF).

The court further addressed the question of whether there is a discretion for the court to pay the drawback of import duty despite the non-compliance with Regulation 37. The court considered whether the regulation provided any scope for the court to exercise discretion in this regard. It found that the regulation was unequivocal and did not provide for any discretion in the matter. The court relied on several precedents where strict compliance with statutory requirements was mandated, emphasizing that administrative errors or confusion do not relieve the applicant of the strict compliance obligations under the regulation.

The court then examined whether the applicant was ineligible for drawback payments due to the failure to comply with the requirement to give notice in writing under Regulation 37. Given the plain language of the regulation and the lack of any discretionary power, the court concluded that the applicant was indeed ineligible for the drawback payments. This decision was based on the principle that regulations must be followed as written, and any deviation from the prescribed requirements disqualifies the applicant from the benefits provided under the regulation.

In considering whether the plain language of the text of the regulation indicated that drawback of duty was not payable in the event of non-compliance with the notice requirement, the court reiterated its interpretation of the regulation. The court found that the regulation's wording left no room for interpretation and explicitly stated that written notice was a prerequisite for any drawback application. Therefore, non-compliance with this requirement resulted in the applicant being ineligible for the drawback payments, as the regulation clearly stipulated that drawback was not payable without the written notice.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of whether maladministration within the ABF could contribute to an argument for compensation under the Scheme for Compensation for Detriment caused by Defective Administration. The court acknowledged that there was some evidence of confusion and lack of interest in inspecting the applicant's goods within the ABF, which could be seen as maladministration. However, the court emphasized that this was a separate matter from the Tribunal's review of the eligibility for drawback payments. Any argument for compensation would need to be pursued under the compensation scheme, which is distinct from the Tribunal’s review of compliance with the regulation. The court confirmed that while the maladministration might be a factor in a separate compensation claim, it did not affect the Tribunal’s decision on the eligibility for drawback payments based on the strict compliance requirement of the regulation.

In summary, the court's reasoning was firmly grounded in the strict interpretation of the regulation, the absence of any discretionary power, and the clear language of the statutory requirements. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that strict compliance with regulatory requirements is mandatory, and any deviation from these requirements results in ineligibility for the benefits provided under the regulation. The court did not depart from prior authority on these points, but rather affirmed the strict compliance principle, emphasizing that maladministration issues, while acknowledged, are not grounds for overriding the clear regulatory requirements in this context.