Phelan v South Australian Housing Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Leave to Appeal to the Full Court)

PHELAN v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING TRUST

[2019] SASC 30

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

7 March 2019

LANDLORD AND TENANT - TERMINATION OF THE TENANCY - GENERALLY

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

Application for permission to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court against orders made in the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal).

On 19 December 2019, Mr Stevens, an Acting Deputy President of the Tribunal, upheld a decision made by the Tribunal, which ordered the termination of the tenancy agreement between the applicant and the respondent, and evicted the applicant from the premises.

The applicant has appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court on various grounds.

Held, dismissing the application:

1.  The applicant has not identified any error in the internal review conducted by the Acting Deputy President of the Tribunal.

2.  Permission to appeal is refused.

South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) s 16, s 71, s 89A; South Australian Housing Trust Act 1995 (SA); Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA) s 5, s 24, s 110, Pt 3, referred to.
Jackson v Lepp Investments Pty Ltd (2016) SASR 1; Pix v South Australian Housing Trust (2016) 125 SASR 10, discussed.

PHELAN v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING TRUST
[2019] SASC 30

Permission to appeal to the Full Court

NICHOLSON J.

Introduction

  1. The applicant in this matter seeks permission to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court from a decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT). The appeal lies pursuant to section 71 of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA). Until recently, the applicant had been a very long term tenant of the South Australian Housing Trust (SAHT or the respondent). However, on 6 December 2018 Tribunal Member Bakas allowed the respondent’s application for orders that the tenancy be terminated and that the applicant vacate the premises by midday on 17 December 2018. The order for termination of the tenancy was made on the basis of the applicant’s failure to maintain the property in good and proper tenantable condition. It was further directed that the order giving vacant possession was to be enforced, if necessary, by the SACAT bailiff. The applicant did not vacate the property as ordered and, on 19 February 2019, the order was enforced by the bailiff.[1]

    [1] Appointed pursuant to subsection 89A(1) of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA).

  2. On 10 December 2018, the applicant applied to SACAT for an internal review of the decision and made an urgent application for a stay of the operation of the orders.  On 14 December 2018, the President of SACAT refused an order for a stay and on 19 December 2018 Acting Deputy President Stevens affirmed the decision under review.

  3. The applicant now applies for leave to appeal against the decision of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Phelan v South Australian Housing Trust and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Phelan v South Australian Housing Trust involved a dispute between the tenant, Mr. Phelan, and the landlord, the South Australian Housing Trust. The crux of the dispute was the condition of the property, with the landlord seeking to terminate the tenancy due to the tenant's failure to maintain the premises in a reasonable and tenantable condition. The matter was heard and determined by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT), which has exclusive jurisdiction over tenancy disputes under the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA).

The central legal issues revolved around the powers of SACAT to make orders concerning the maintenance and condition of the premises, and whether such orders were within the scope of the statutory provisions governing tenancy disputes. Specifically, the court had to determine if SACAT had the authority to compel a tenant to clean and repair the premises as a condition of continuing the tenancy. Additionally, the court needed to consider whether the Tribunal's orders were justified under the statutory provisions and whether they were necessary to resolve the tenancy dispute.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the broad powers conferred upon SACAT by the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA). The court found that SACAT had the authority to make orders that are necessary or desirable to resolve tenancy disputes, which included compelling a tenant to address issues that affected the condition of the premises. The court emphasised that the orders were made in the context of preserving the subject matter of the appeal and ensuring that the property was maintained in a tenantable condition. The court concluded that the orders were both within the statutory powers of SACAT and necessary to address the significant disrepair of the premises.

The final orders of the court required the tenant to undertake specific actions to remedy the condition of the property, such as cleaning and repairing the premises, within specified timeframes. Failure to comply with these orders would result in the landlord being able to apply for an urgent hearing to terminate the tenancy and evict the tenant. This decision underscored the importance of maintaining residential premises in a tenantable condition and the powers of SACAT to enforce such obligations.

Background

Background to the litigation

The orders made in this case by the Tribunal member at first instance were made pursuant to subsection 110(1) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 and, in particular, pursuant to paragraphs (e), (j) and (m) thereof.(1)The Tribunal may, on application by a party to a tenancy dispute—(a) restrain an action in breach of this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement, or an agreement collateral to a residential tenancy agreement or a rooming house agreement; or(b) require a person to comply with an obligation under this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement or an agreement collateral to a residential tenancy agreement or a rooming house agreement; or(c) order a person to make a payment (which may include compensation) under this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement or a collateral agreement or for breach of this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement, or a collateral agreement; or(d) relieve a party to a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement or a collateral agreement from the obligation to comply with a provision of the agreement; or(e) terminate a residential tenancy or rooming house agreement or declare that a residential tenancy or rooming house agreement has, or has not, been validly terminated; or(f) reinstate rights under a residential tenancy agreement or rooming house agreement that have been forfeited or have otherwise terminated; or(g) require payment of rent into the Fund until conditions stipulated by the Tribunal have been complied with; or(h) require that rent paid into the Fund be paid out and applied as directed by the Tribunal; or(i) require that a bond (including a bond under Part 7) paid into the Fund be paid out and applied as directed by the Tribunal; or(j) require a tenant or a rooming house resident to give up the possession of premises to the landlord or rooming house proprietor; or(k) make orders to give effect to rights and liabilities arising from the assignment of a residential tenancy agreement; or(l) exercise any other power conferred on the Tribunal under this Act; or(m) do anything else necessary or desirable to resolve a tenancy dispute.Further general background The respondent had for some time been attempting to have the applicant clear out excessive quantities of rubbish, materials, disused furniture, boxes and other collections of possessions and the like from both inside the premises and outside the premises in order to bring the premises into a state of good and proper tenantable repair. The respondent has from time to time provided some assistance to the tenant in this respect. It eventually came to a point where the respondent brought an application for termination and vacant possession on 1 February 2018. The matter came on for hearing on 21 February 2018 before the Tribunal. The Tribunal was provided with photographs taken on 13 February 2018 which demonstrated that the property was in considerable need of attention. Tribunal Member Alvino made orders permitting the applicant to remain in the property on the condition that by designated dates: she arrange to have the backyard slashed; she remove all items stored around the perimeter of the house and in the garage; she allow the respondent to attend to the removal of the eaves which contained asbestos; and she clear and clean the interior of the house and return it to a reasonable, clean and tenantable condition. Member Alvino also ordered that if the timetable for works was not complied with, the respondent could apply to the Tribunal for an urgent hearing to terminate the tenancy and evict the applicant from the premises.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
Counsel for the respondent politely queried whether a permission Judge in my circumstances had statutory power to make such an order. I indicated that in the event that there were to be no express statutory power available, but without deciding that question, I proposed to exercise the inherent jurisdiction available to a Supreme Court Judge in circumstances where, in my view, such an order was necessary to preserve the subject matter of the appeal. Legislative basis for the decisions made for the decision below Notwithstanding that tenancies with the SAHT are governed by the South Australian Housing Trust Act 1995 (SA), it is provided by subsection 5(2) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA) that a number of provisions of that Act will also apply, including provisions dealing with matters such as quiet enjoyment of the premises, security of the premises, conduct by the tenant and termination and vacant possession. Part 3 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 confers exclusive jurisdiction upon SACAT to hear and determine tenancy disputes.[4][4] Subsection 24(1) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA). The orders made in this case by the Tribunal member at first instance were made pursuant to subsection 110(1) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 and, in particular, pursuant to paragraphs (e), (j) and (m) thereof.(1)The Tribunal may, on application by a party to a tenancy dispute—(a) restrain an action in breach of this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement, or an agreement collateral to a residential tenancy agreement or a rooming house agreement; or(b) require a person to comply with an obligation under this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement or an agreement collateral to a residential tenancy agreement or a rooming house agreement; or(c) order a person to make a payment (which may include compensation) under this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement or a collateral agreement or for breach of this Act, a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement, or a collateral agreement; or(d) relieve a party to a residential tenancy agreement, a rooming house agreement or a collateral agreement from the obligation to comply with a provision of the agreement; or(e) terminate a residential tenancy or rooming house agreement or declare that a residential tenancy or rooming house agreement has, or has not, been validly terminated; or(f) reinstate rights under a residential tenancy agreement or rooming house agreement that have been forfeited or have otherwise terminated; or(g) require payment of rent into the Fund until conditions stipulated by the Tribunal have been complied with; or(h) require that rent paid into the Fund be paid out and applied as directed by the Tribunal; or(i) require that a bond (including a bond under Part 7) paid into the Fund be paid out and applied as directed by the Tribunal; or(j) require a tenant or a rooming house resident to give up the possession of premises to the landlord or rooming house proprietor; or(k) make orders to give effect to rights and liabilities arising from the assignment of a residential tenancy agreement; or(l) exercise any other power conferred on the Tribunal under this Act; or(m) do anything else necessary or desirable to resolve a tenancy dispute.Further general background

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

The court began by addressing the primary issue of whether the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) has the statutory power to make orders that require a tenant to undertake specific actions to remedy breaches of a residential tenancy agreement. The court found that the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA) confers broad powers on SACAT to resolve tenancy disputes, including the power to order tenants to undertake specific actions necessary to remedy breaches of the agreement. This conclusion was based on the language of the Act, which allows SACAT to "do anything else necessary or desirable to resolve a tenancy dispute." The court further noted that this provision was intended to provide SACAT with the flexibility to address a wide range of issues that might arise in tenancy disputes, and that it included the power to order tenants to take specific remedial actions.

The court then considered whether the specific orders made by the Tribunal were within the scope of its powers under the Act. The Tribunal had ordered the applicant to arrange for the backyard to be slashed, to remove items stored around the perimeter of the house and in the garage, to allow the respondent to remove asbestos-containing eaves, and to clear and clean the interior of the house. The court found that these orders were within the scope of the Tribunal's powers, as they were necessary to remedy the breaches of the tenancy agreement and to ensure that the premises were in a reasonable, clean, and tenantable condition.

The court also addressed the issue of whether the Tribunal had the authority to order the applicant to allow the respondent to remove the asbestos-containing eaves. The court found that the Tribunal did have the power to make this order, as it was necessary to remedy the breach of the tenancy agreement and to ensure that the premises were safe and habitable. The court noted that the respondent had a duty to ensure that the premises were safe and habitable, and that this duty included the power to remove hazardous materials such as asbestos.

The court then considered whether the Tribunal had the authority to require the applicant to clear and clean the interior of the house and return it to a reasonable, clean, and tenantable condition. The court found that the Tribunal did have the power to make this order, as it was necessary to remedy the breach of the tenancy agreement and to ensure that the premises were safe and habitable. The court noted that the applicant had a duty to keep the premises in a reasonable, clean, and tenantable condition, and that this duty included the power to remove clutter and debris.

The court also addressed the issue of whether the Tribunal had the power to order that if the timetable for works was not complied with, the respondent could apply for an urgent hearing to terminate the tenancy and evict the applicant from the premises. The court found that the Tribunal did have the power to make this order, as it was necessary to ensure that the applicant complied with the terms of the tenancy agreement and to enforce the Tribunal's orders.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether the Supreme Court Judge had inherent jurisdiction to make an order to preserve the subject matter of the appeal in the absence of express statutory power. The court found that the Supreme Court Judge did have inherent jurisdiction to make such an order, as it was necessary to preserve the subject matter of the appeal and to ensure that the applicant complied with the terms of the tenancy agreement.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that SACAT has broad powers to resolve tenancy disputes, including the power to order tenants to take specific remedial actions to remedy breaches of the tenancy agreement and to ensure that the premises are safe and habitable. The court also found that the Supreme Court Judge has inherent jurisdiction to make orders to preserve the subject matter of an appeal in the absence of express statutory power. These principles are significant because they provide guidance to SACAT and the Supreme Court in resolving tenancy disputes and ensuring that the rights of landlords and tenants are protected. The court followed prior authority in finding that SACAT has broad powers to resolve tenancy disputes, and that the Supreme Court Judge has inherent jurisdiction to make orders to preserve the subject matter of an appeal. However, the court departed from prior authority in finding that SACAT has the power to order tenants to take specific remedial actions to remedy breaches of the tenancy agreement and to ensure that the premises are safe and habitable.