PHARMACY BOARD OF AUSTRALIA and TEH

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: HEALTH PRACTITIONER REGULATION NATIONAL LAW (WA) ACT 2010 (WA)

CITATION:   PHARMACY BOARD OF AUSTRALIA and TEH [2025] WASAT 30

MEMBER:   PRESIDENT GLANCY

DR M EVANS-BONNER, SENIOR MEMBER

MS E PERRELLA, SESSIONAL MEMBER

HEARD:   11 OCTOBER 2024

DELIVERED          :   11 APRIL 2025

FILE NO/S:   VR 69 of 2023

BETWEEN:   PHARMACY BOARD OF AUSTRALIA

Applicant

AND

ZHI-REN TEH

Respondent


Catchwords:

Vocational regulation - Pharmacist - Disciplinary proceedings - Professional misconduct over a seven-year period - Pharmacist made false declarations about recency of practice when he renewed his registration - Whether Pharmacist made false declaration about having done a CPD plan because his plan was not written - No requirement for CPD plan to be in writing - Factors relevant to penalty - Disciplinary sanction imposed

Legislation:

Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (WA) Act 2010 (WA) (repealed), Sch
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009 (Qld)
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Application Act 2024 (WA), s 5(1), s 5(2), s 38, s 42, s 42(2), s 42(3)
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law, s 3(2)(a), s 3A(1), s 5, s 12(1), s 35(1)(c), s 38, s 38(1)(e), s 39, s 40(1), s 41, s 109(1), s 109(1)(a)(ii), s 109(1)(a)(iii), s 193(1)(a)(i), s 196(1)(b)(ii), s 196(1)(iii), s 196(2), s 196(3), s 196(4), s 207
Pharmacy Act 2010 (WA), s 4, s 46(1)(c)(i), s 46(2), s 46(3), s 53, s 54, s 54(1)(a), s 54(1)(c), s 54(2)

Result:

Practitioner reprimanded
Practitioner's registration as a pharmacist cancelled
Practitioner disqualified from applying for registration as a pharmacist for eighteen (18) months

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr EM Heenan SC & Mr T de Bes
Respondent : Ms R Young SC & Mr J Birch

Solicitors:

Applicant : Perth Legal Pty Ltd
Respondent : Meridian Lawyers (Perth)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Health Ombudsman v Park [2021] QCAT 309

Hegde v Pharmacy Board of Australia [2020] WASC 383

Hegde v Pharmacy Board of Australia [2023] WASAT 109

Hegde v Pharmacy Board of Australia [No 2] [2020] WASC 384

Medical Board of Australia and Lal [2017] WASAT 23

Medical Board of Australia and Singh [2017] WASAT 33 (S)

Medical Board of Australia v Putha [2014] QCAT 159

Medical Board of Australia v Win (Review and Regulation) (Amended) [2015] VCAT 1289

Medical Board of Western Australia and Bham [2006] WASAT 190

Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia v Joy Jones VR 1 of 2019

Nursing and Midwifery Board v Kindl (Review and Regulation) [2023] VCAT 981

Pharmacy Board of Australia and Hegde [2020] WASAT 89

Psychologists Registration Board of Victoria v Ferriere (2000) PRBD (Vic) 3

Psychology Board of Australia and Fawcett [2023] WASAT 86

Psychology Board of Australia v Elzo (Review and Regulation) [2020] VCAT 345

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. The Pharmacy Board of Australia (variously the Applicant or the Board) referred this matter to the Tribunal pursuant to s 193(1)(a)(i) of the now repealed Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (National Law) which was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PHARMACY BOARD OF AUSTRALIA and TEH and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] WASAT 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the Pharmacy Board of Australia taking disciplinary action against a pharmacist, TEH, for professional misconduct over a seven-year period. The Board alleged that TEH had made false declarations about the recency of his practice when he renewed his registration and had also falsely declared that he had completed a Continuing Professional Development (CPD) plan. The central issues for the court were whether TEH had indeed made false declarations and, if so, what penalty should be imposed considering the protection of the public and the maintenance of public confidence in the profession.

The court examined the evidence and determined that TEH had made seven false declarations about his recency of practice. Although TEH argued that he had other options, the court found that his actions were dishonest and breached the Code of Conduct. The court also clarified that there was no requirement for the CPD plan to be in written form. In deciding the penalty, the court emphasised that the primary goal was to protect the public and uphold the high standards of the pharmacy profession. Given the seriousness of the misconduct, the court concluded that a penalty involving the cancellation or suspension of TEH's registration was necessary to serve as a deterrent and reinforce professional standards.

The court imposed a penalty of suspension of TEH's registration for a period of two years. This decision was made with the aim of protecting the public while also considering the likelihood that TEH would not engage in similar dishonest conduct in the future. The court took into account the potential impact on TEH's financial position but found that it did not justify a lesser penalty. The court's ruling underscores the importance of maintaining integrity and trustworthiness within the pharmacy profession to ensure public safety and confidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Practitioner submits that where it was not certain that that would be the outcome, and where such an outcome will be so detrimental to his financial position, he was entitled to wait for the outcome of the Tribunal's decision and should not be required to 'prepare for a day of reckoning' that may, or may not, be coming. The Practitioner submits that we should treat the Chief Justice's comments in the Hegde Stay Decision with some caution because they were made in a different context, namely when assessing the balance of convenience in a stay application. In contrast, the test that the Tribunal must apply in this case is to determine the appropriate penalty having regard to the protection of the public and the maintenance of the public's confidence in the high standards of the profession.[89] [89] ts 99. It is of course true that the Practitioner (or rather the Company as trustee for the Unit Trust) was entitled to continue to own the pharmacies and to enter into whatever commercial arrangement he saw fit before the disciplinary proceedings are concluded. However, in our view, his choices cannot dictate the outcome of this proceeding. As we mentioned above, the fact is that if his registration is cancelled or suspended, the Pharmacy Act provisions will mean that the Practitioner will no longer be able to own the two pharmacies. That he may now have to sell them under some duress is a consequence of the choice which he has made not to take steps to offer them for sale at an earlier time. That said, it is not a matter that we find to be a mark against him which justifies a stronger penalty than would otherwise be required to be imposed. We do not consider that a penalty which involves the cancellation of the Practitioner's registration as a pharmacist, or suspension of that registration, is to be regarded as punitive simply because the consequence is that the Pharmacy Act will operate to prevent him (or entities he controls) from continuing to own the pharmacies. Nor do we consider the possible impact on the community, pharmacy staff or students would make suspension or cancellation disproportionate or punitive. The Practitioner submitted that he has already effectively served a period of suspension due to the immediate action which the Board took under the National Law. More specifically, on 3 December 2020, the Board took immediate action against the Practitioner by imposing conditions on his registration which provided that the Practitioner could only practise as a pharmacist under the supervision of another pharmacist approved by the Board.[90] Following that decision, there was correspondence between the Practitioner and the Board concerning the nomination and approval of supervisors, and it was not until 7 June 2021, some six months later, that the Practitioner's supervisors were approved by the Board, following which the Practitioner worked in another pharmacy under supervision for nine hours a week, for which he was not paid. On 3 August 2022, the Board decided to end the period of immediate action and to impose alternate conditions on the Practitioner's registration in the form of indirect supervision which required weekly consultation with his supervisors.[91] [90] Exhibit 2.21, RD page 328 - 342, HB pages 487 - 501.[91] Exhibit 2.37, RD page 565 - 578, HB pages 724 - 737.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Psychologists Registration Board of Victoria v Ferriere (2000) PRBD (Vic) 3, [23], the Board commented that the public is entitled to be concerned with whether a psychologist who has been prepared to be dishonest with their professional body is committed to or capable of being honest with them. That statement must, in our view, also be correct for pharmacists. Dishonesty by pharmacists in relation to recency of practice is particularly serious given that the requirement that a practitioner meet that requirement is in place to ensure, as far as possible, that a practitioner is sufficiently skilled to perform the functions of a pharmacist. That is, it is directly connected with ensuring the safety of the members of the public who use a pharmacist's services and rely upon their knowledge, professional expertise and judgment. Because dishonesty of the kind engaged in by the Practitioner is easy to engage in and difficult to detect, the penalty which is to be imposed upon him needs to serve as an example to others that this kind of dishonesty is regarded as being particularly serious, in order to deter other pharmacists who might consider behaving in the same way. That is, general deterrence is a large component of the penalty to be imposed in this case to ensure the protection of the public and the maintenance of the high standards expected of the members of the pharmacy profession. For similar reasons, there is a need to protect the public and maintain public confidence in the profession by reinforcing high professional standards and denouncing transgressions. The Practitioner lied about an important matter related to his registration for a period of seven years. He gave evidence that he did so because he did not believe that he had any other option.[19] It goes without saying that he had other options. While we are satisfied that the Practitioner is not likely to engage in similar dishonest conduct in the future, we consider that the public and fellow practitioners may have reservations about relying on his word in the future. In making the seven false declarations from 2011 through to 2019, the Practitioner breached the Code of Conduct made by the Board under s 39 of the National Law. There are two versions of the Code of Conduct that cover this period.[20] Both refer, in item 1.2, to the requirement for practitioners to be 'ethical and trustworthy'.[21] In knowingly making the seven false declarations, we find that the Practitioner did not behave in an ethical and trustworthy manner and breached the Code of Conduct. [20] Pharmacy Board of Australia, Code of Conduct for Registered Health Practitioners (1 July 2010) (2010 Code); and Pharmacy Board of Australia, For Pharmacists: Code of Conduct (17 March 2014) (2014 Code). [21] 2010 Code, page 2, AD page 28, HB page 53; and 2014 Code page 6, AD page 47, HB page 72. As we outlined above, pursuant to s 109(1) of the National Law, a pharmacist seeking to renew their registration must declare that they have met the recency of practice requirements, as required by the approved registration standard: s 109(1)(a)(ii) National Law. Both versions of the Recency Standards specify minimum requirements for recency of practice for pharmacists to be able to demonstrate to the Board that they can safely and competently provide services to the public. In summary, those requirements include that the pharmacist has practised pharmacy for more than 450 hours in the past three years. The 2015 Recency Standard specifies an alternative to the 450-hour requirement, which is that the practitioner must have practised for a minimum of 150 hours in the 12-month period prior to applying for their registration.