Pham v Sommerville Retail Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

[2016] FWC 2267

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Hoa Thi Pham
v
Somerville Retail Services Pty Ltd
(U2015/12461)
COMMISSIONER LEE MELBOURNE, 12 MAY 2016

Application for relief from unfair dismissal - whether valid reason for dismissal - whether

dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable - Fair Work Act 2009 ss.387, 394.

[1] This matter involves an application made pursuant to section 394 of the Fair Work Act

2009 (Cth) (the Act) for unfair dismissal remedy. Ms Hoa Thi Pham (the Applicant) claims

that she was unfairly dismissed from her employment with Somerville Retail Services Pty Ltd

(the Respondent).

[2]        The matter was listed for hearing before me on 3 and 4 February 2016. The Applicant

was represented by Ms Kennett of the Australasian Meat Industry Employees Union

(AMIEU). The Applicant gave evidence on her own behalf and an interpreter of the

Vietnamese language was provided to assist the Applicant for whom English is a second

language.

[3]        The Respondent was represented by Mr McNab of Counsel. I granted permission to

Mr McNab to appear as I was satisfied that there was sufficient complexity in the matter such

that granting permission would enable the matter to be dealt with more efficiently. Mr

D’Intinosante the Senior Shift Supervisor, Mr Younger the Production Operations Manager,

Ms Soccio the Human Resources Manager and Mr Pike the Shift Supervisor gave evidence on

behalf of the Respondent.

[4]        The application was made within the required statutory time period. It is apparent and

not in dispute that the Applicant is a person protected from unfair dismissal within the

meaning of the Act.

THE EVIDENCE

Background

[5] The Applicant was employed by the Respondent as a meat processing worker. The

Applicant commenced employment with the Respondent in 2005.
[2016] FWC 2267

i

[6] The Applicant was terminated on 13 October 2015. The letter of termination refers to

the various reasons for the termination. In summary, the reasons provided were as follows:

 That the Applicant had made inappropriate and unwelcome personal and sexual

references to a number of co-workers in August 2015 and was given a written

warning in respect to this conduct on 11 August 2015.

 On 10 October 2015, the Applicant refused to carry out a lawful instruction to work

in the cutting room on two occasions and that this refusal to follow instructions was

not an isolated event.

 At a meeting convened on 13 October 2015 (the first meeting) to discuss the

Applicant’s alleged refusal to carry out the instruction to move to the cutting room

that the Applicant spoke over the supervisors telling them they were not telling the

truth and was also argumentative. The Applicant’s conduct was described as

“aggressive.”

 At a second meeting convened on 13 October 2015, that the Applicant denied her

alleged behaviour in the first meeting. As this view was not shared by her

supervisors and owing to on-going complaints of unprofessional and unacceptable

conduct by supervisors, it was decided the situation had become…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pham v Sommerville Retail Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FWC 2267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hoa Thi Pham brought a claim for unfair dismissal against Somerville Retail Services Pty Ltd. The Applicant alleged that she was dismissed without a valid reason and that the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The Applicant was employed as a meat processing worker since 2005. The Respondent gave reasons for dismissal including refusal to carry out a lawful instruction, conduct in a meeting and unprofessional conduct. The Applicant was paid four weeks in lieu of notice of termination. The Applicant was represented by Ms Kennett of the AMIEU and the Respondent was represented by Mr McNab. The Commissioner found that the dismissal was harsh and unreasonable. The Respondent did not follow its own disciplinary policy and there was no satisfactory opportunity for the Applicant to respond. The Commissioner did not find the dismissal to be unjust as the Applicant was notified of the reason for dismissal and a support person was present at the second meeting. The Commissioner found that the dismissal was based on a valid reason. The Commissioner ordered that the Respondent pay the Applicant compensation of $3,711.61 plus 9.5% superannuation less tax. The Commissioner found that the Applicant’s misconduct warranted a 15% reduction in the amount of compensation.