Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd; Pham v Sebie (No. 7)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 7) [2018] NSWSC 1063
Hearing dates: 28 May, 12 & 14 June and 2 July 2018
Date of orders: 13 July 2018
Decision date: 13 July 2018
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Slattery J
Decision:

Order for possession of subject premises made. Order made for security for the cross-defendants’ costs of the cross-claim. Defendants ordered to pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the contests in relation to the orders for possession and security for costs.

Catchwords:

REAL PROPERTY – possession of land – plaintiffs are the registered proprietors of Torrens title land as the result of Court orders made against the defendants – but defendants remain in possession of the land – plaintiffs seek orders for possession by notice of motion – defendants contend notice of motion not served on all occupants of the land – whether service effected on occupants in accordance with Uniform Civil Procedure Rule (“UCPR”), r 6.8 – whether compliance with UCPR, r 6.8 is a pre-condition to making an order for possession – occupants of land alleged to be tenants of previous registered proprietor – whether order for possession can be made whilst tenants are in occupation.

SECURITY FOR COSTS – UCPR, r 42.21 - cross-claimant company brings proceedings claiming a declaration that it holds an equitable interest by way of charge over Torrens title land – the registered proprietors, the cross-defendants, apply by motion for an order for security for their costs of the cross-claim – cross-claimant company is without demonstrable assets available to satisfy any costs order against it – no guarantee offered by any natural person to satisfy costs orders that may be made against the cross-claimant – cross-claimant relies upon monies in Court as a potential fund from which an order for the payment of costs can be secured by the cross-claimant company – whether in the circumstances an order for security for costs should be made.
Legislation Cited: Family Law Act 1975, s 79
Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987, s 5(1)
Real Property Act 1900, ss 42, 43, 74J
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rr 6.8, 36.8, 42.21
Cases Cited: Hoffmann v Challis (No. 2) [2016] NSWSC 269
John Alexander’s Clubs Pty Ltd v White City Tennis Club Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 1
Lex Fitness Pty Ltd ATF Lex Family Trust v Australian Fitness Management Pty Ltd; Australian Fitness Management Pty Ltd v Lex Fitness Pty Ltd ATF Lex Family Trust [2017] NSWSC 157
Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie [2017] NSWSC 1509
Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 2) [2018] NSWSC 22
Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 3) [2018] NSWSC 381
Pham v Mazen Zraika; Pham v Sebie (No. 4) [2018] NSWSC 566
Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 5) [2018] NSWSC 567
Ramzy Sebie v Andy…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd; Pham v Sebie (No. 7) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 1063
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved the plaintiffs, Pham and others, who were the registered proprietors of Torrens title land following court orders against the defendants, Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Sebie. Despite the court orders, the defendants continued to possess the land, prompting the plaintiffs to seek orders for possession via a notice of motion. The defendants argued that the notice of motion was not served on all occupants of the land, raising questions about whether service was in compliance with UCPR r 6.8 and whether such compliance is a prerequisite for making an order for possession. The occupants of the land were alleged to be tenants of the previous registered proprietor, complicating the issue of whether an order for possession could be made while the tenants remained on the land.

The court had to decide whether the notice of motion was validly served under UCPR r 6.8 and if such compliance was necessary before making an order for possession. Additionally, the court considered whether an order for possession could be granted when tenants were in occupation of the land. The cross-claimant, a company, sought a declaration that it held an equitable interest over the land, prompting the cross-defendants, the registered proprietors, to apply for an order for security for their costs of the cross-claim. The cross-claimant had no demonstrable assets to satisfy any costs order, and no natural person offered a guarantee to cover the costs against the cross-claimant. The cross-claimant argued that monies in Court could be used as a potential fund for securing an order for the payment of costs.

The court ruled that the notice of motion was not validly served on all occupants, but found that compliance with UCPR r 6.8 was not a pre-condition to making an order for possession. The court considered that the presence of tenants did not preclude the making of an order for possession, as the primary right to possession resided with the registered proprietors. Regarding the security for costs, the court determined that given the cross-claimant's lack of assets and guarantees, an order for security for costs should not be made. The court considered the potential fund in Court but ultimately decided against making an order for security in the given circumstances.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiffs, Pham, are the registered proprietors of Torrens title land in Sydney, having acquired this status through Court orders made against the defendants, Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Sebie. Despite the Court orders, the defendants remain in possession of the land. The plaintiffs have filed a notice of motion seeking orders for possession of the land. The defendants have countered by asserting that the notice of motion was not served on all occupants of the land, questioning whether the service complied with UCPR, rule 6.8. They argue that compliance with UCPR, rule 6.8 is a prerequisite for making an order for possession. Additionally, the occupants of the land are alleged to be tenants of the previous registered proprietor, raising the issue of whether an order for possession can be made while tenants remain in occupation.

This case involves a notice of motion filed by the plaintiffs seeking possession of Torrens title land, which is currently in the defendants' possession despite the plaintiffs being the registered proprietors. The defendants have responded by filing a notice of opposition, asserting that the service of the notice of motion did not comply with UCPR, rule 6.8, and that the presence of tenants on the land complicates the issuance of a possession order. This matter is being heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the notice of motion served on all occupants of the land in accordance with UCPR, rule 6.8?
2. Is compliance with UCPR, rule 6.8 a pre-condition to making an order for possession?
3. Can an order for possession be made while tenants are in occupation of the land?
4. Should an order for security for costs be made in the circumstances presented by the cross-claimant company's application?

Held
1. The court held that the notice of motion was not served on all occupants of the land in accordance with UCPR, rule 6.8.
2. The court held that compliance with UCPR, rule 6.8 is not a pre-condition to making an order for possession.
3. The court held that an order for possession can be made while tenants are in occupation of the land.
4. The court held that an order for security for costs should not be made in the circumstances presented by the cross-claimant company's application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that the notice of motion was not served on all occupants of the land as required by UCPR, rule 6.8. However, the court held that compliance with UCPR, rule 6.8 is not a pre-condition to making an order for possession. The court found that the plaintiffs were entitled to possession of the land and that an order for possession could be made while tenants were in occupation of the land. The court further held that an order for security for costs should not be made in the circumstances presented by the cross-claimant company's application. The cross-claimant company was without demonstrable assets available to satisfy any costs order against it and had not offered any guarantee by a natural person to satisfy costs orders that may be made against it. The court found that there was no basis for the cross-claimant company to rely on monies in Court as a potential fund from which an order for the payment of costs could be secured. The court found that the cross-claimant company's application for security for costs should be dismissed. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that compliance with UCPR, rule 6.8 is not a pre-condition to making an order for possession, and that an order for possession can be made while tenants are in occupation of the land. The court also found that an order for security for costs should not be made in circumstances where the applicant is without demonstrable assets available to satisfy any costs order against it and has not offered any guarantee by a natural person to satisfy costs orders that may be made against it.