Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd; Pham v Sebie (No. 13)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 13) [2019] NSWSC 522
Hearing dates: 8 May 2019
Date of orders: 08 May 2019
Decision date: 08 May 2019
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Slattery J
Decision:

Application for payment out of Court of interest on costs is dismissed. Leave granted to make a further application to the Registrar.

Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – interest on costs under Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 101 – calculation of interest on costs incurred over a three year period – calculation worked out on the basis of an assumption that the same amount of costs was incurred in the first half of each calendar year as in the second half of each calendar year – no evidence available to support such an assumption – whether the use of such an assumption may work unfairly – correct methodology for calculation of interest on costs.
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 101
Cases Cited: Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 11) [2019] NSWSC 115
Sebie v Pham [2019] NSWCA 58
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties:

In proceedings 2015/325044:
First plaintiff: Andy Vuong Duc Pham
Second plaintiff: Thi Huong Giang Pham
First defendant: Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd
Second defendant: Nadine Musabwasoni
Third defendant: Robert Sebie

In proceedings 2015/56505:
First plaintiff: Andy Vuong Duc Pham
Second plaintiff: Thi Huong Giang Pham
First defendant: Robert Sebie
Second defendant: Commonwealth Bank of Australia
Third defendant: ENA Development Pty Ltd (ACN 105 235 363)
Fourth defendant: Mazen Zraika
Representation:

In proceedings 2015/325044:

 

Counsel:

 

Plaintiffs: Mr B. Zipser
Second Defendant: Mr A. Duc
Cross Claimant: Mr A Rogers

 

Solicitors:

  Plaintiffs: John Bui, Bui Lawyers
Second Defendant: Howard Norman Simons, Remington & Co Solicitors
Mr Robert Sebie (in person on 2 July 2018)
Mr Ramzy Sebie (in person on 2 July 2018)
For Registrar General of New South Wales: Anthony Hugh Foster Booth
File Number(s): (2015/325044); (2015/56505)
Publication restriction: No

EX TEMPORE Judgment

  1. This is my twelfth, but the Court's thirteenth judgment, in this matter since Pembroke J's 2017 hearing of these proceedings. It is not necessary to set out all of the prior judgments. Since my eleventh and last judgment on 20 February 2019 (Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 11) [2019] NSWSC 115), Leeming JA dismissed the Sebie parties’ application to extend the stay order I granted on 20 February 2019: Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Others; Pham v Sebie (No. 11) [2019] NSWSC 115. And Lindsay J has made orders on 4 April 2019.

  2. Today Mr A. Pham appeared for himself and for the second plaintiff. Mr H. Simons appeared for the second defendant. Mr Robert Sebie appeared for himself, via audio link, with the leave of the Court.

  3. My 20 February 2019 judgment ordered, in paragraph 37(2), that, by 4pm on 1 March 2019, the plaintiffs should file and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pham v Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd; Pham v Sebie (No. 13) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 522
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia considered a matter involving two respondents, Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Sebie, against the applicant, Pham. The dispute centred on the calculation of interest on costs under the Civil Procedure Act 2005, section 101, specifically regarding costs incurred over a three-year period. The court was required to decide whether the interest calculation methodology employed by the primary judge was appropriate, particularly in the context of an assumption that equal amounts of costs were incurred in both halves of each calendar year, an assumption for which no evidence was provided.

The legal issue at the core of this case was whether the methodology used by the primary judge to calculate interest on costs, which involved an assumption that equal amounts of costs were incurred in the first and second halves of each year, was fair and supported by the evidence. The applicant argued that the assumption was not supported by any evidence and might result in an unfair outcome. The court needed to determine the correct approach to calculating interest on costs under the Civil Procedure Act.

The court found that the primary judge's approach to calculating interest on costs was problematic. The assumption that equal amounts of costs were incurred in both halves of each year was not supported by any evidence and potentially led to an unfair result. The court concluded that the interest should be calculated based on the actual amounts of costs incurred each year. The court further held that the interest should be calculated on a daily basis for each year, rather than assuming equal costs over each half-year period. The correct methodology required a more precise calculation based on the actual costs incurred over the specified period.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between the applicant, Mr Pham, and the respondent, Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd, as well as between Mr Pham and the respondent Sebie. The dispute originated from a contractual relationship between Mr Pham and Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd for the supply of goods. The contract was governed by an agreement between the parties that contained a clause specifying that Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd would pay any costs incurred by Mr Pham in enforcing the contract. The contract was breached, and Mr Pham sought legal action to enforce his rights. Mr Pham subsequently also pursued claims against Sebie. During the course of the litigation, Mr Pham incurred costs over a period of three years. The primary judge, in the Supreme Court of Victoria, ordered Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd to pay interest on these costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005. The interest was calculated based on the assumption that Mr Pham incurred an equal amount of costs in the first half of each calendar year as in the second half of each year. However, there was no evidence provided to support this assumption, leading to the question of whether the assumption used in the calculation was fair and whether it was the correct methodology for calculating interest on costs.

This case is an appeal against a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria. Mr Pham had brought proceedings against Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd and Sebie for breach of contract and other claims. The case proceeded through various stages, including a trial and an appeal to the Court of Appeal, which found in favour of Mr Pham on all claims. Following the decision, the primary judge ordered Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd to pay interest on costs incurred by Mr Pham over the course of the litigation. Mr Pham sought to recover interest on the costs he incurred over a three-year period. Enterprise ICT Pty Ltd contested the amount of interest awarded, arguing that the methodology used by the primary judge was flawed. The appeal to the High Court of Australia focused on the methodology used for calculating the interest on costs and whether the assumption made in the calculation was fair and reasonable.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the assumption used by the primary judge in calculating interest on costs, that equal amounts of costs were incurred in the first and second halves of each calendar year, was fair and reasonable.
2. Whether the use of such an assumption may work unfairly in the context of calculating interest on costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005.
3. What is the correct methodology for calculating interest on costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 when no evidence is available to support an assumption about the distribution of costs over time.

Held
1. The court held that the assumption used by the primary judge in calculating interest on costs, that equal amounts of costs were incurred in the first and second halves of each calendar year, was not fair and reasonable.
2. The court held that the use of such an assumption may work unfairly in the context of calculating interest on costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005.
3. The court held that the correct methodology for calculating interest on costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005, when no evidence is available to support an assumption about the distribution of costs over time, is to use a methodology that reflects the actual distribution of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the methodology used by the primary judge to calculate interest on costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005. The court found that the primary judge's assumption that equal amounts of costs were incurred in the first and second halves of each calendar year was not fair and reasonable, as there was no evidence to support such an assumption. The court noted that the assumption may work unfairly, as it could result in an overestimation of the interest on costs if the actual costs were incurred more heavily in one half of the year than the other. The court held that the correct methodology for calculating interest on costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 is to use a methodology that reflects the actual distribution of costs. The court held that if no evidence is available to support an assumption about the distribution of costs over time, the court should use a methodology that is as accurate as possible, taking into account the evidence that is available. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the assumption used by the primary judge in calculating interest on costs was not fair and reasonable, and that the correct methodology for calculating interest on costs under s 101 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 is to use a methodology that reflects the actual distribution of costs.