PFJV Pty Limited v Bartter Enterprises Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  PFJV Pty Limited v Bartter Enterprises Pty Limited [2024]
QSC 12
PARTIES:  PFJV PTY LIMITED ACN 614 586 444 AS TRUSTEE
FOR THE DONNYBROOK RAINBOW UNIT TRUST
AND FOR THE DONNYBROOK KUIKENS UNIT
TRUST
(plaintiff)
v
BARTTER ENTERPRISES PTY LIMITED
ACN 000 451 374
(defendant)
FILE NO:  3716 of 2019
DIVISION:  Trial Division
PROCEEDING:  Application
ORIGINATING  Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane
COURT: 
DELIVERED ON:  5 February 2024
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  1 February 2024
JUDGE:  Applegarth J
ORDER:  Terms of Order as to further disclosure to be settled at a
review at 2:30 pm on 6 February 2024.

CATCHWORDS: 

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES – DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS – DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS – UNDERTAKINGS AND USE OF DOCUMENTS – where the plaintiff applies for further disclosure close to the trial –

where the defendant opposes the application because of its timing; its disruption of the existing agreed disclosure regime; the burden the requested orders would place upon it in reviewing many commercially-sensitive documents and redacting large parts of them; and because the documents requested are unlikely to contain information that is directly

relevant to the issues in dispute – where previous orders have been made for a disclosure regime that included the plaintiff’s

lawyers accessing for a limited period commercially sensitive

documents – whether an order should be made for the plaintiff’s expert to review the same documents in case he

forms a different review about their direct relevance to the
issues – whether further orders should be made for limited
disclosure in response to requested categories in the plaintiff’s
amended application
Ex parte Fielder Gillespie Limited (1984) Qd R 339, cited
Westgate Finance v May [2012] NSWSC 806, cited
Grace v Grace (No 8) [2014] NSWSC 419, cited
COUNSEL:  G A Thompson KC & A G Psaltis for the plaintiff
A G Rae & A Smorchevsky for the defendant
SOLICITORS:  Colin Biggers & Paisley for the plaintiff
Prandium Legal for the defendant
  1. The plaintiff applies for further disclosure close to the trial of the proceeding that is set to start before the Chief Justice on 25 March.

  2. The defendant opposes the application because of its timing; its disruption of the existing agreed disclosure regime; the burden the requested orders would place upon it in reviewing many commercially-sensitive documents and redacting large parts of them; and because the documents requested are unlikely to contain information that is directly relevant to the issues in dispute. They may contain large amounts of

    information about the defendant’s operations and financial performance, but that does

    not make them directly relevant to a plan or proposal in 2015 or 2016 to close the

    defendant’s Queensland plant.

  3. The plaintiff responds that the orders are suitably targeted to disclose documents that

    are directly relevant to any such proposal and the knowledge of the defendant’s

directors and its Queensland Manager of the possibility or probability that the
Queensland plant…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PFJV Pty Limited v Bartter Enterprises Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of PFJV Pty Limited v Bartter Enterprises Pty Limited concerns a dispute over the purchase of a chicken farm and business at Donnybrook in 2016. The plaintiff, PFJV Pty Limited, is suing Bartter Enterprises Pty Limited for various claims related to the purchase and the subsequent operation of the business, which included a growing agreement with Bartter Enterprises. Central to the plaintiff’s case is the allegation that the defendant had knowledge of the probable closure of the Ipswich plant, which would have significantly impacted the value of the business. The plaintiff seeks further disclosure of documents, particularly those that refer to or mention "Project Joshua," to substantiate its claims. The case was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, where the plaintiff applied for further disclosure of documents close to the trial date.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff should be granted further disclosure of documents to support its case. This involved balancing the need for the plaintiff to have access to relevant documents against the confidentiality and other concerns of the defendant. The court had to determine if the plaintiff's request for further disclosure was justified and, if so, how it could be balanced with the defendant's rights to protect confidential information. The court also had to consider the timing of the application, which was made very close to the trial date.

The court found that while the plaintiff’s application for further disclosure was made late, it was not without merit. The court acknowledged the importance of the documents in question, particularly those referring to "Project Joshua," in proving the plaintiff’s case. The court emphasised the need for a fair balance between the parties' interests. It directed the parties to confer and agree on the terms of the further disclosure, including the process for electronic searches and redaction of confidential information. The court also set a review for 2:30 pm on 6 February 2024 to ensure the terms of the order were settled promptly.

The court's orders included a direction for the parties to agree on the terms of further disclosure to be provided to the plaintiff. This involved a specific process for electronic searches and redaction of confidential information. The plaintiff’s application was adjourned to a date to be fixed, with a review set for 2:30 pm on 6 February 2024. The court directed the parties to avoid protracted discussions and debates about the terms of specific draft orders, and if necessary, the matter would be resolved at the review with sworn oral evidence from the solicitors.

Orders

Orders of the court

Terms of Order as to further disclosure to be settled at a

review at 2:30 pm on 6 February 2024.

Background

Background to the litigation

In general terms, however, each part of the application raises a simple question. What is a fair balance between the confidentiality and other concerns of the defendant and the need of the plaintiff to have access to relevant documents (suitably redacted) to prove its case? Background The plaintiff sues over the purchase in 2016 of a chicken farm and business at Donnybrook. At the time of the purchase, the business had a growing agreement with the defendant. The business grew broiler chickens that were processed at the defendant’s plant near Ipswich. At the time the plaintiff conducted its due diligence in 2016, the grower agreement had an initial five-year term and a further term of another five years. The grower agreement reflected a substantial part of the value of the business that was purchased by the plaintiff. As part of its due diligence before purchasing the farm and business and obtaining an assignment of the agreement, the plaintiff’s director, Mr Vorster, had a conversation with the defendant’s Queensland Operations General Manager, Mr Rapa, about This conversation is said to have occurred on or about 20 August 2016. A critical part of the plaintiff’s case is that by 20 August 2016: The plaintiff’s case also is that the possible or probable closure of the Ipswich plant was part of an “Expansion and Consolidation Process” that the defendant had been undertaking for some years, which aimed to concentrate its activities in the Griffith and Tamworth regions of New South Wales. By consolidating or partially consolidating the group’s national operations so that it operated principally from New South Wales, it would gain certain advantages and facilitate the closure of certain live poultry processing plants operated by the defendant, including the Ipswich plant. The plaintiff alleges that closure of the Ipswich plant had been the subject of submissions to meetings of the Advisory Board, and the defendant knew it was probable that in or about 2017 the defendant would cease live processing at Ipswich. This allegation is based upon the fact of the expansion and consolidation process and a number of disclosed documents, including reports by the defendant’s managing director and CEO, the fact that the Ipswich plant was not included in facilities that were to be the subject of significant future capital investment, and from statements to the effect that the defendant and the Baiada Group were concerned that the costs of the Ipswich plant were too high and in excess of budgeted cost amounts. The plaintiff also relies upon the contents of minutes of a meeting of the Advisory Board held on 6 August 2015 that record its CEO advising of the scheduled closure of a plant at Laverton for March 2016 and “potentially the SEQ plant in 2017”. The “expected synergies” were reported to be about $30 million per annum in savings. Increased capacity at a New South Wales plant after October 2016 would allow the closures. The minutes record: “These closures will generate better scale on our sites.” It also reported that “SEQ is our highest cost plant”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Camilleri’s affidavit will assist in determining what further orders, if any, should be made in relation to documents which refer to or use the term “Project Joshua”. Conclusion These reasons have been prepared in some haste and as an efficient alternative to delivering time-consuming oral reasons. I will direct the parties to confer and agree a suitable form of order that will give effect to these reasons. In the case of each matter about which I have indicated there should be further disclosure, the terms of each order and a specific process by which limited further disclosure is to be provided, should be agreed. This may entail suitable electronic searches and agreement about redaction in relation to confidential or commercially- sensitive information, and the possible application of the existing confidentiality regime or a similar process. I direct the parties to avoid protracted discussions, correspondence and debates about the terms of specific draft orders. If counsel and solicitors cannot resolve the terms of order quickly, then I will resolve the matter at a review at 2:30 pm tomorrow and the solicitors can give sworn oral evidence before me. Because some parts of my order, such as the “Project Joshua” direction, may require future additional orders, it is appropriate that, in addition to specific directions and orders, the plaintiff’s application is otherwise adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.