Pexbury Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PEXBURY PTY LTD v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2020] FCCA 3074
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Application for Sponsorship Nomination – failure by applicant to meet applicable training expenditure benchmarks from time to time – failure by applicant to establish that its business was financially viable enough to employ another person for at least a two (2) year period – failure by Tribunal to exercise its discretion to disregard applicant’s failure to meet training expenditure obligations was not unreasonable – no jurisdictional error established – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.359AA

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), rr.2.59, 2.87B(2), 5.19(3)(d), 5.19(3)(f),

IMMI 12/062, IMMI13/30, IMMI17/075

Cases cited:

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Jayshree Enterprises Pty Ltd

[2017] FCA 264

Rodchompoo v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA

965

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Pandey (2014) 143 ALD 640

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI (2009) 259 ALR 429

Applicant: PEXBURY PTY LTD
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: BRG 991 of 2019
Judgment of: Judge Egan
Hearing dates: 1 June 2020, 10 November 2020
Date of Last Submission: 10 November 2020
Delivered at: Brisbane
Delivered on: 13 November 2020

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A See
Solicitors for the Applicant: Arshad and Chand Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr J Brynes
Solicitors for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. The Further Amended Application for Review filed on 6 April 2020 be dismissed.

  2. The Applicant is to pay the First Respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application for review fixed in the amount of $7,467.00.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT BRISBANE

BRG 991 of 2019

PEXBURY PTY LTD

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. On 19 November 2019, the applicant filed an originating application for review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) made on 17 October 2019. The Tribunal had affirmed a decision of the delegate to refuse the applicant’s sponsorship nomination application.

  2. At the time of the hearing before the Court, the applicant relied upon the grounds for review as set out in a Further Amended Application for Review filed on 6 April 2020. Those grounds were as follows:

    “Amended Grounds of Application

    (i) The Second Respondent committed jurisdictional error, by taking into account irrelevant considerations and not taking into account relevant considerations, when making its finding at Paragraph [35] of the decision, that the requirements in regulation 5 .19(3 )( d) of the Migration Regulations 1994, were not met.

    (ii) The Second Respondent committed an error of law, when it found that the Applicant did not satisfy the requirements of regulation 5.19 (3)(f)(i) of the Migration Regulations 1994.

    (iii) The Second Respondent committed jurisdictional error when it failed to exercise its discretion under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pexbury Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 3074
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pexbury Pty Ltd (the Applicant) sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) which affirmed a delegate of the Minister's refusal to approve the Applicant's nomination of Ms Kaur for the position of "Real Estate Representative". The Applicant, a real estate agency, had applied for approval of the nomination on 5 July 2017. The delegate refused the application on 2 December 2017, finding that the Applicant had failed to demonstrate a commitment to training benchmarks for the period 22 March 2013 to 21 March 2016, and therefore did not meet the requirements of regulations 5.19(3)(d)(i) and 5.19(3)(f)(i) of the Migration Regulations 1994. The Tribunal subsequently affirmed this decision on 17 October 2019.

The Applicant argued that the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error in several respects. Firstly, it contended that the Tribunal misconstrued regulation 5.19(3)(d)(i) by requiring the Applicant to establish its financial capacity to employ Ms Kaur for at least two years, rather than simply identifying the need for such employment. Secondly, the Applicant argued that the Tribunal erred in its assessment of compliance with regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i), asserting that the Tribunal failed to distinguish between different legislative instruments and regulatory provisions applicable at various times, and incorrectly applied regulation 2.87B. Finally, the Applicant submitted that the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error by failing to exercise its discretion to disregard the failure to meet training expenditure obligations under regulation 5.19(3)(f)(ii), rendering its decision manifestly unreasonable.

The Court considered the Applicant's arguments regarding the interpretation of regulation 5.19(3)(d)(i) and the financial capacity to employ Ms Kaur. It also examined the Applicant's contentions concerning the application of regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i), including the interplay between different legislative instruments and the correct period for assessing training expenditure. The Court then addressed the Applicant's claim that the Tribunal failed to properly exercise its discretion under regulation 5.19(3)(f)(ii). The Court's reasoning focused on whether the Tribunal had correctly understood and applied the relevant legislative provisions and whether its findings were open to it on the evidence.

The Court found no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's decision. It concluded that the Tribunal had not misconstrued its task in assessing the Applicant's financial capacity to employ Ms Kaur, nor had it erred in its application of the training benchmark requirements under regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i). Furthermore, the Court held that the Tribunal's exercise of discretion under regulation 5.19(3)(f)(ii) was not unreasonable. Accordingly, the application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 22 June 2020, an “Agreed Statement of Facts and Issues” was helpfully filed by the parties. That Statement, in its entirety, provided as follows:“A. STATEMENT OF FACTS Background[1] The Applicant is the owner and operator of a real estate agency, Rivercity Real Estate (which it has owned and operated for 35 years). Mr Galbraith, the owner and director of the Applicant, had been ill for some time.[2] Ms Kaur had worked in the business from 2013 or 2014 on a full-time basis until going on maternity leave. On her return from maternity leave, she worked part time from January to April 2017. Since April 2017, Ms Kaur had been on extended leave due to her husband’s chronic health condition and since the end of FY2017, there had been no expenditure for Ms Kaur’s salary.[3] On 5 July 2017, the Applicant applied for approval of the nomination. The Applicant was the nominator and Ms Kaur was the nominee, for the position of “Real Estate Representative”.[4] On 2 December 2017, a delegate of the Minister refused the application. In short, the delegate was not satisfied that regulations 5.19(3)(f)(i) and (ii) had been met because there was a failure to demonstrate a commitment to training benchmarks for the period from 22 March 2013 to 21 March 2016.[5] On 22 December 2017, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal held a hearing on 24 September 2019.[6] On 17 October 2019, the Tribunal decided to affirm the delegate’s decision to refuse the nomination.[7] The Tribunal was not satisfied that the Applicant met the requirements of regulation 5.19(3) of the Regulations, specifically for the purposes of:-·Regulation 5.19(3)(d)(i); and·Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i).THE LAW[8] At the time when the Applicant had been approved as a standard business sponsor on 22 March 2013, the 2013 Regulations were in force.[9] The 2013 Regulations relevantly provided:a. at regulation 5.19(3)(f) – that the nominator has met the training requirements that the nominator was required to meet under paragraph 2.59(d) or (e) for the purpose of approval as a standard business sponsor;b. at regulation 2.59(d) (which would have been the applicable regulation) –i. “(d) if the applicant is lawfully operating a business in Australia, and has traded in Australia for 12 months or more — the applicant meets the benchmarks for the training of Australian citizens and Australian permanent residents specified in an instrument in writing made for this paragraph …” (emphasis added).c. there was no regulation 2.87B.[10] A copy of the above is attached and marked Annexure “A”.[11] The applicable benchmark at the time of the 2013 Regulations was IMMI 12/062, which commenced on 1 July 2012. This relevantly provided a training benchmark as follows:i. “Recent expenditure, by the business, to the equivalent of at least 1% of the payroll of the business, in the provision of training to employees of the business, and a commitment, by the business, to maintain expenditure in each fiscal year, to that level, for the term of approval as a sponsor.”[12] As below, this instrument was revoked by IMMI 13/30 (which was dated 28 June 2013 and commenced on 1 July 2013).[13] Regulation 2.87B was introduced with effect on 1 July 2013 by the Migration Legislation Amendment Regulation 2013 (No 3) (Cth) (F2013L01229). At that time, regulation 5.19(3)(f) was repealed and replaced. The terms of regulations 2.87B and 5.19(3) in effect from 1 July 2013 are attached at Annexure “B”.[14] Also on 1 July 2013, IMMI 13/030 commenced. This relevantly contained a training benchmark for an established business as follows (at B):ii. “Recent expenditure, by the business, to the equivalent of at least 1% of the payroll of the business, in the provision of training to employees of the business.”[15] On 1 July 2017, IMMI 13/030 was repealed (by clause 5 and Schedule 1 to IMMI 17/075).[16] On 1 July 2017, IMMI 17/045 commenced and provided that it was made under paragraphs 2.59(d) and 2.68(e), subregulations 2.87B(2) and (3) of the Regulations (at section 3). It provided that it applied to nominations or standard business approvals lodged on or after its commencement (at section 7). This provided the following in relation to Training Benchmark B (at Schedule 1):iii. “Recent expenditure, by the business, to the equivalent of at least 1% of the payroll of the business, in the provision of training of employees of the business who are Australian citizens and Australian permanent residents.iv. The business is also required to show that the provision of training is related to the purpose of the business.v. Recent expenditure for Training Benchmark B is defined as expenditure made in the previous financial year or the previous 12 months, as evidenced by a receipt for the payment(s) or a contract for employment of the relevant individual for whom salary payments are being included within expenditure that can count towards the benchmark.”[17] At the time of the Applicant’s application to be a business nominator (i.e. 5 July 2017), regulation 5.19(3) and regulation 2.87B were in the terms as attached at Annexure “C”. As can be seen by a comparison between Annexures “B” and “C”:a. the terms of regulation 5.19(3) did not change between 1 July 2013 and 5 July 2017 (apart from the addition of regulation 5.19(3)(i) (which is irrelevant to this proceeding)); andb. the terms of regulation 2.87B did not change between the time of its commencement (1 July 2013) and 5 July 2017.[18] Regulation 5.19(3) was annexed to the Decision Record and this was the same as the regulation contained in Annexure “C” (being the regulation as at 5 July 2017). Parts of regulation 2.87B were quoted in the Decision Record[19] On 18 March 2018, regulation 2.59(d) was repealed.16 Further, at that time, regulation 5.19 was repealed and replaced with substantially different text.[20] On 12 August 2018, regulation 2.87B of the Regulations was repealed.ISSUES TO BE RESOLVED[21] The following issues need to be resolved by this Honourable Court:(1) Did the Tribunal commit jurisdictional error when it determined that the “requirement in r5.19(3)(d) is not met” [see paragraph 35 of the decision].(2) Did the Tribunal commit jurisdictional error when it determined that the Applicant had not satisfied the requirements of Regulation 5.19(3)(f) [see paragraph 47 of the decision]; and(3) Should the Tribunal have disregarded subparagraph (i) of Regulation 5.19(3)(f), for the purposes of Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(ii) [see paragraph 46 of the decision].[22] The following contains a high-level overview of the competing contentions of the parties in respect of each issue identified (which will be developed in consolidated submissions by each party).Issue #1 - Regulation 5.19(3)(d)(i)[23] The Applicant contends that:(i) The Tribunal has misconstrued the legislation when it reached its conclusion, as it stepped outside of jurisdiction, to undertake its task.(ii) What the Regulation asks the Tribunal to do is to identify that there was a need for the nominator to employ a person as a paid employee to work in the position under the nominator’s direct control on a full time basis in the position for at least two years. [Refer Regulation 5.19(3)].(iii) Instead, the Tribunal determined that the Applicant “must be able to financially employ and pay the person” (refer Paragraph 26 of the Decision) and then developed its own methodology for assessing how and when such capacity to pay should be evaluated [Refer Paragraph 30 of the Decision].(iv) The Tribunal has exceeded its jurisdiction, by reading into the language of Regulation 5.19(3)(d)(i) a requirement that the Applicant should establish its capacity to meet those wages costs, at the time of hearing.(v) Alternatively, in reaching its decision within jurisdiction, the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error by failing to take into account the revenue that arises where the Applicant was to employ a visa holder in its business.[20] The Respondent contends that:(i) the Tribunal did not misconstrue its task;(ii) the Tribunal was mindful of the appropriate test under regulation 5.19(3)(d)(i) (as per [8], [26] and [34] and the attachment to the Decision Record);(iii) there was nothing preventing the Tribunal from considering the Applicant’s financial ability to employ Ms Kaur. The Tribunal was seeking to determine what would happen in the next two years and it was open to the Tribunal to have regard to the financial position of the Applicant in determining this. Indeed, the financial position of the Applicant clearly bore on this issue;(iv) the Tribunal’s reasons should not be read with an eye keenly attuned to the perception of error in this respect and it should not readily be inferred that the Tribunal misconstrued its task; and(v) as to the alternative argument:a. the Tribunal was not obliged to take into account the apparent increased revenue from Ms Kaur’s employment;b. it should not readily be inferred that the Tribunal did not take Ms Kaur’s contribution into account. The Tribunal was mindful that Ms Kaur was said to be an “asset to the business” and that she made a “valuable contribution” (see [16] and [17] of the Decision Record). It would be unsurprising if the Tribunal placed no weight on Ms Kaur’s apparent contribution because it was speculative, not quantified (and appears unquantifiable) and the preference for solid evidence (as contained in the Applicant’s financial records) (as per [29] of the Decision Record); andc. the Applicant has not shown how any such error would be material, in that: Ms Kaur’s apparent contribution is speculative and not quantified; and the Applicant failed to meet regulation 5.13(3)(f)(i) (as below).Issue #2 - Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)[21] The Applicant contends that the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error in reaching a determination that the Applicant had failed to maintain their (sic) commitment to the ongoing training in all three of the sponsorship years (refer Paragraph 45 of the Decision), for the following reasons:(i) For failing to draw the distinction between commitments the nominator made relating to meeting the training requirements during the period of the nominator’s most recent approval as a standard business sponsor [see IMMI 12/062 and Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(A)] and the applicable obligations under Division 2.19 [see Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(B)].(ii) By relying on Regulation 2.87B for the purposes of evaluating compliance under Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i), when in fact that Regulation could not have applied in these circumstances.(iii) By failing to correctly identify the commitments made by the nominator, when it:a. Did not recognise that the Applicant’s commitment given at the time of approval as a standard business sponsor were made under Regulation 2.59 of the Migration Regulations 1994 as in force at 22 March 2013 and not Regulation 2.87B of the Migration Regulations 1994, that were not in force until 1 July 2013.b Did not recognise that the Applicant’s commitment within the Migration Instrument at the time of the standard business sponsorship approval was IMMI 12/062 and not IMMI 13/030.c. Did not recognise that the assessment of compliance for the purposes of Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i) required an examination of the training expenditure in accordance with subsubsubsub Paragraph(A) and not subsubsubsub Paragraph(B) of that Regulation.d. Did not differentiate nor recognise that the Applicant’s commitments to training expenditure were based on a fiscal year reporting period and not that of business sponsorship approval date.e. Disallowed one training expenditure amount of $660.00 (see Paragraph 39 of the Decision), on the basis that it did not apply the correct legislation and thereby failed to draw the distinction within Paragraph B of the Training Benchmarks set out in Schedule A to IMMI 12/062 between evidence of recent expenditure of at least 1% of the payroll of the business at the time of the business approval, as opposed to evidence of training expenditure provided for as part of the training commitment.[22] The Respondent contends that:(i) the Tribunal did not err in the application of regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i);(ii) the Tribunal correctly had regard to regulation 2.87B and applied the relevant timeframes because:a. regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(B) concerned historic compliance with ongoing obligations under Division 2.19;b. regulation 2.87B came into effect from 1 July 2013 and, therefore, was applicable in respect of the ongoing obligations under Division 2.19 from 1 July 2013. The applicable instrument from 1 July 2013 to 1 July 2017 was IMMI 13/030 (IMMI 12/062 had been revoked); andc. it does not matter that the Applicant’s sponsorship commenced on 22 March 2013 (prior to regulation 2.87B being in force) because regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(B) and Division 2.19 were concerned with compliance with ongoing training requirements (which could change during the time of the sponsorship) rather than the initial claimed commitment to training;(iii) the Tribunal was mindful of the test under regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i) (including (A) and (B)). It ought not readily be inferred that it failed to consider regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(A). The Tribunal was not obliged to set out in its reasons its consideration of regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(A), particularly where it correctly made adverse findings on regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(B) that answered the question posed by regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i); and(iv) any error (if found, which is denied) was not material. That is because the Applicant failed to meet regulation 5.19(3)(d) (as above). Further, if an error is established in respect of regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(A), the Applicant failed to meet regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i)(B) and those requirements both had to be met to satisfy regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i).Issue #3 - Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(ii)[23] The Applicant contends:(i) That the Tribunal committed jurisdictional error by failing to have regard to the relevant various facts and factors, by not exercising its discretion and disregarding Regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i).(ii) That the decision was manifestly unreasonable having regard to all of the relevant issues before the Second Respondent.[24] The Respondent contends that:(i) the Tribunal’s exercise of discretion was not legally unreasonable and the Tribunal did not disregard regulation 5.19(3)(f)(i); and(ii) any error (if found, which is denied) was not material because the Applicant failed to meet regulation 5.19(3)(d).” (See Annexures to Statement of Agreed Facts at the end of this judgment).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.