Peter Jeffs v Capiteq Pty Ltd & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

Peter Jeffs v Capiteq Pty Ltd & Ors [2006] NTSC 2

PARTIES:PETER JOHN JEFFS

v

CAPITEQ PTY LTD t/as AIRNORTH REGIONAL AIRLINES

and

MICHAEL JOHN BOURKE and ELIZABETH RAYNER t/as AIR MANYMAK

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:153/00  (20017216)

DELIVERED:  12 January 2006

HEARING DATES:  12-16 September 2005

JUDGMENT OF:  THOMAS J

CATCHWORDS:

DAMAGES -- GENERAL PRINCIPLES -- LIABILITY ADMITTED

Measure of Damages in Action for Tort.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:W Priestley

1st Defendant:  

2nd Defendant:  P Rose SC

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:Priestleys

1st Defendant:  

2nd Defendant:  Hunt & Hunt

Judgment category classification:        C

Judgment ID Number:  tho200602

Number of pages:  41

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Peter Jeffs v Capiteq Pty Ltd & Ors [2006] NTSC 2
No. 153/00 (20017216)

BETWEEN:

PETER JOHN JEFFS

Plaintiff

AND:

CAPITEQ PTY LTD t/as AIRNORTH REGIONAL AIRLINES

First Defendant

MICHAEL JOHN BOURKE and ELIZABETH RAYNER t/as AIR MANYMAK

Second Defendant

CORAM:     THOMAS J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 12 January 2006)

  1. This is a claim for damages arising from injuries suffered by Mr Peter Jeffs in an airline crash on 30 October 1998.

  2. With the consent of the parties a claim for damages by Mrs Elaine Jeffs, the wife of Peter Jeffs, proceeded as a joint hearing.  The evidence of all witnesses is evidence in both matters.  Mr Priestley appeared as counsel for the plaintiff.  Mr Rose SC appeared as counsel for the second defendant.

  3. By consent I made an order allowing the plaintiff to discontinue her claim against the first defendant.  I further ordered that costs of the proceedings against the first defendant be costs in the cause against the second defendant.

  4. The Court was advised that liability had been admitted by the second defendant and both matters were before the Court for an assessment of damages.

    The plane crash

  5. In the reasons for judgment relating to the claim by Mrs Elaine Jeffs, I have summarised her evidence as to the plane crash.  The only other witness to give evidence as to the plane crash was Mr Peter Jeffs who also suffered injuries, the subject of a claim for damages.

  6. Mr Jeffs gave evidence he was a passenger in an aircraft flying from Maningrida to Darwin.  The aircraft was a Cessna 210 carrying a pilot and five passengers.

  7. Mr Jeffs was seated in the rear left hand seat.  His wife Elaine was in the right front seat.  Mr Jeffs fell asleep shortly after boarding the plane.  His wife called out to him that they were going down.  He observed the plane come steeply in over the trees.  The aircraft hit the ground, bounced to a height of 15-20 metres, came down again, careered up over a mound of gravel and come to a stop approximately three metres from the trees.  Mr Jeffs felt a searing pain radiating mostly through his back but also through his shoulder.  He also felt pain…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peter Jeffs v Capiteq Pty Ltd & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NTSC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Peter Jeffs v Capiteq Pty Ltd & Ors dealt with a claim for damages arising from a plane crash that occurred on 30 October 1998. The plaintiff, Mr Jeffs, sought compensation for injuries sustained in the crash, which included a compressed fracture of the L1 vertebra, whiplash injuries, swelling around the stomach region, multiple soft tissue injuries, and post-traumatic stress and anxiety. The defendants admitted liability, leaving the court to determine the measure of damages.

The primary legal issue before the court was the quantification of the damages to be awarded to Mr Jeffs. This involved assessing the extent of his injuries and their impact on his life, including his physical condition, psychological well-being, and any ongoing medical treatment requirements. The court had to consider medical evidence and expert opinions to ascertain the appropriate compensation for the plaintiff's injuries.

The court carefully reviewed the evidence presented, including the medical reports and expert testimony. Dr Desmond Williams, an orthopaedic surgeon, provided detailed reports outlining the plaintiff's injuries and their persistence since the crash. The court acknowledged the severity of the injuries and the impact on the plaintiff's life. After considering all the evidence, the court determined the appropriate amount of damages to be awarded, taking into account the totality of the injuries and their long-term effects.

The court awarded damages to Mr Jeffs, reflecting the extent of his injuries and their impact on his life. The precise amount of the award was determined based on the evidence and expert opinions presented during the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Jeffs stated that he does have infrequent consultations with Dr Parry and is not receiving treatment for his injuries. He has not received any treatment since completion of the thirteen week period following the plane crash. He was taking medication for hypertension prior to the plane crash. He did have a heart problem prior to the plane crash and had a stent placed in one of the veins of his heart. He stated he was not receiving regular treatment from a psychologist and has not consulted a psychiatrist. He agreed that the Arnhemland Progress Association had provided them with a house and the value of this was $120 a week.The medical evidence As a consequence of the plane crash, Mr Jeffs claimed the following injuries: a compressed fracture of the L1 vertebra, whiplash injuries to neck and shoulders, swelling around the stomach region, multiple soft tissue injuries, post traumatic stress and anxiety.Medical witnesses called for the plaintiffDr Desmond Williams Dr Williams is an orthopaedic surgeon with over 30 years in practice. His main area of expertise is as an arthritis surgeon in upper and lower limb. Dr Williams had prepared four reports with respect to Mr Jeffs dated 5 May 2004, 13 December 2004, 20 June 2004 and 2 September 2005. These reports were tendered and marked Exhibit P11. In his report dated 5 May 2004, Dr Williams stated as follows at page 8:“4.This patient has significant persisting injuries related to the violent incident of the aircraft crash on 30th October 1998, and these include:1.Pain in the right shoulder and presence of an acromioclavicular joint and glenohumeral arthritic change, and with subacromial spurring and subacromial bursitis, and complete rupture of subscapularis and supraspinatus tendons and long headed biceps tendon presenting major right shoulder pathology.2.In the cervical spine where he has had a soft tissue neck injury, he has evidence of mid cervical degenerative change and segmental stiffness.3.In the thoracolumbar spine where he has evidence of the significant wedging of the L1 vertebral body at 50% of its height, he has multilevel degenerative change in the thoracic and lumbar area, so he has had soft tissue injury and fractures, and the symptoms related to underlying degenerative change.4.In his right and left hips he has early hip arthritis, shown in the right hip by the restriction in the internal rotation clinically, and defined in the x-rays, and there is mild disability here in the right hip at 5% and the left hip at 5% but I have no clear evidence that the accident played a direct role in the arthritis as it may simply be related to his aging.5.In his right knee where he has had constant pain persisting since the accident, he has pan-compartmental arthritis with most marked changes in the medial compartment, and here he has a significant disability related to traumatic progressive arthritis. He has the symptoms related to these areas discussed in the text of the report.5.The aircraft accident of October 1998 was a very forceful impact injury and he has had ongoing symptoms persistent since that time, so we see the pathologies and symptoms as related to that incident was discussed in the text of the report.6.His problems have stabilised such that he can move towards settlement.7.I have outlined that his right shoulder requires further assessment with an MRI study and the potential for surgical procedures to improve the function, such as an arthroscopic subacromial shaving has to be considered, and any final decision on surgical management will hinge on clarifying the pathology.In his right knee [he] has significant osteoarthritic change and there will be a progression that leads to a total knee replacement within a five-year period.His cervical and thoracolumbar spinal injuries require intensive swimming and exercise schedules in management.I further mention the psychological issues need appropriate assessment as I believe his withdrawal from care and coping with these severe difficulties with minimal supervision of management, reflect a significant ongoing psychological component to his reaction to the injuries.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.