Peter Damien McSherry and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

[2014] AATA 119 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2013/4183

Re

Peter Damien McSherry

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President K Bean
Professor P Reilly AO, Member

Date 6 March 2014
Place Adelaide

The respondent’s decision of 6 August 2013 is set aside and in substitution for that decision it is decided that Mr McSherry is entitled to the issue of class 1 and class 2 medical certificates, without conditions.

............ [ Sgd ] ...................

Deputy President K Bean

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION - Conditions imposed on class 1 medical certificate issued to applicant - Whether applicant meets medical standard 1 - Whether deep vein thrombosis and risk of bleeding as a side effect of Warfarin are safety-relevant conditions - Negligible risk of an adverse event having safety consequences occurring - Conditions not likely to reduce applicant's ability to perform as a commercial helicopter pilot - Decision under review set aside.

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Act 1988, ss 9A and 20AB

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998, regs 11.056, 67.015, 65.150, 67.155 and 67.180

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988, reg 5.04

CASES

Re Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority (1999) 56 ALD 316

Re Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President K Bean
Professor P Reilly AO, Member

6 March 2014

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mr McSherry, is a qualified helicopter pilot.  Until early 2013, he operated a business, currently known as South Coast Helicopters Pty Ltd, offering charter flights to paying customers.  However, on 20 December 2012, the respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), made a decision to impose certain conditions on Mr McSherry’s class 1 medical certificate which is a necessary accompaniment to the use of a commercial helicopter pilot licence.  The conditions imposed on Mr McSherry’s class 1 medical certificate had the consequence that Mr McSherry could no longer operate his charter flight business.

  2. Mr McSherry made a subsequent application for renewal of his  medical certificates in 2013, and on 6 August 2013 CASA made a further decision in identical terms to the decision of 20 December 2012, imposing the same conditions on his class 1 medical certificate.

  3. There is no dispute that it is the later decision, that of 6 August 2013, which is the operative decision for our purposes and it is that decision which is the subject of the current proceedings and our decision.[1]  For completeness, we note that Mr McSherry’s earlier application (2013/2154) for review of CASA’s decision of 20 December 2012, was dismissed with the consent of both parties on 8 November 2013.

    [1] Mr McSherry lodged an application seeking review of that decision on 22 August 2013, giving rise to application number 2013/4183.

  4. In broad terms therefore, the main issues before us are whether Mr McSherry should be granted a medical certificate allowing him to fly helicopters commercially, and whether it is necessary to impose any conditions on that certificate.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  5. The factual background to the matter is not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peter Damien McSherry and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Peter Damien McSherry and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority, the dispute revolves around Mr McSherry's eligibility for a medical certificate that would permit him to fly helicopters commercially. The case was heard in the court, which was tasked with determining whether Mr McSherry should be granted such a certificate and if any conditions should be imposed on it. Mr McSherry, who holds both private and commercial helicopter pilot licences, has been unable to fly commercially since December 2012 due to the conditions imposed on his class 1 medical certificate. The court needed to assess the medical standards and the risks associated with Mr McSherry's condition, specifically his use of Warfarin, to make a decision.

The legal issues before the court included whether Mr McSherry met the medical standards set forth in the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations (CASR) and whether any conditions could be imposed on his medical certificates. The court examined the evidence provided by three medical experts, who agreed that the risk of catastrophic clotting or bleeding events was negligible, but differed on the risk of an incompletely incapacitating bleed. The court also considered the endorsements on the medical certificate, the special requirements referred to by CASA, and the 12-month validity condition. Ultimately, the court concluded that Mr McSherry met the medical standards and that no conditions should be imposed on his certificates.

In its reasoning, the court found that all medical experts agreed that the risk of catastrophic events was negligible, and the risk of an incapacitating but not catastrophic bleed was also low. The court accepted that the statistical likelihood of an incompletely incapacitating bleed occurring while Mr McSherry was flying was approximately 0.03%. Given this, the court decided that Mr McSherry was entitled to the issue of class 1 and class 2 medical certificates without conditions. The decision set aside the previous decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority and substituted it with the new decision in favor of Mr McSherry.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In broad terms therefore, the main issues before us are whether Mr McSherry should be granted a medical certificate allowing him to fly helicopters commercially, and whether it is necessary to impose any conditions on that certificate.FACTUAL BACKGROUND The factual background to the matter is not in issue and is summarised below. Mr McSherry was first granted a private helicopter pilot licence on 16 August 2004 and was granted a commercial helicopter pilot licence on 2 November 2005. He subsequently held both private and commercial helicopter pilot licences, together with unrestricted medical certificates allowing him to use those licences, until 20 December 2012, when the decision referred to above was made. Although Mr McSherry continues to hold both private and commercial helicopter pilot licences, since December 2012 he has been unable to fly commercially as a result of the conditions imposed on his class 1 medical certificate. On the material before us, it appears that Mr McSherry and his wife established their helicopter charter business during 2006, and purchased helicopters at significant expense in April 2004 and October 2006. In September 2006, Mr McSherry and his wife travelled overseas to study a number of helicopter charter businesses and investigate several aircraft for sale “with a view to expanding the business”.[2] For at least three hours during their flight from Ireland to Singapore, Mr McSherry says that his wife slept with her legs lying “over the top and inner part (sic) my upper right thigh”. On disembarking in Singapore, Mr McSherry “felt one very sharp and excruciating stab of pain in my right calf muscle which lasted less than a second”,[3] but had no further symptoms at that time. However, on 5 November 2006, Mr McSherry flew one of his helicopters from Strathalbyn in South Australia to Moorabbin Airport in Victoria for scheduled maintenance. He says that toward the end of the return flight, on 7 November, he “noticed a heavy feeling in my right calf muscle”.[4] After he had landed and left the helicopter, he noticed that his “right leg was painful to stand on and my right calf muscle was swollen and hot to touch”.[5] A short time later, he was diagnosed as suffering from a right leg deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and also pulmonary emboli. On 8 November 2006, he was admitted to Flinders Medical Centre for anti-coagulant treatment.[6] Mr McSherry says that as a result of the DVT, he immediately ceased all flying and promptly advised CASA of what had occurred. He was discharged from hospital after five days.[2] Exhibit 3, [9].[3] Exhibit 3, [9].[4] Exhibit 3, [13].[5] Exhibit 3, [13].[6] Exhibit 3, [14]. CASA subsequently sought further information from Mr McSherry about his condition and its management, which Mr McSherry supplied, and between 21 March 2007 and 20 December 2012, Mr McSherry continued to hold unrestricted class 1 and class 2 medical certificates issued by CASA on an annual basis, which, in conjunction with his licences, allowed him to continue to fly as a commercial helicopter pilot, as well as privately. It appears that these certificates were issued following review by CASA of medical examination reports relating to Mr McSherry, reports from his treating specialist, Dr McRae, and reports on his blood clotting susceptibility, as measured by what are known as “INR” or International Normalised Ratio levels.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For completeness, we should also add that we sought further submissions from the parties after the hearing as to the significance for our decision of the endorsements on the relevant medical certificate issued to Mr McSherry,[45] the “special requirements” referred to in CASA’s letter of 6 August 2013, and the “condition” that Mr McSherry’s certificates remain valid only for 12 months. In the event, essentially for the reasons set out in the submissions filed by Mr Abbott SC on behalf of Mr McSherry, dated 18 February 2014, we are satisfied that none of these matters constituted “conditions” within the meaning of CASR reg 11.056. We are further satisfied that, in light of our conclusion that Mr McSherry meets medical standards 1 and 2, he is entitled to the issue of class 1 and class 2 medical certificates, pursuant to CASR reg 67.180. In these circumstances, there is no power to impose conditions on his certificates pursuant to CASR reg 11.056, and we do not propose to do so.[45] Exhibit 2, T11/50.DECISION The respondent’s decision of 6 August 2013 is set aside and in substitution for that decision it is decided that Mr McSherry is entitled to the issue of class 1 and class 2 medical certificates, without conditions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Associate Professor Navathe also conceded that in Mr McSherry’s case he had shown good compliance with his medication and had been stable for many years with no bleeding events, which further reduced the risk in his case.[44][44] Transcript, 31 October 2013, page 90, lines 12-14.Consideration In the event therefore, all of the doctors who have given evidence in this matter agree that the risk of Mr McSherry suffering a catastrophic clotting or bleeding event is negligible and, in effect, not such as to pose a real risk in the context of him flying a helicopter privately or commercially. All three doctors further agree that the risk of an incompletely incapacitating clot is not such as to pose a real risk associated with Mr McSherry flying commercially. However, whilst the other two doctors also regard the risk of an incapacitating but not catastrophic bleed in Mr McSherry’s case as being negligible and unlikely to pose a safety risk, Associate Professor Navathe maintained that the risk of an incompletely incapacitating bleed in Mr McSherry’s case was such that he did not meet the medical standard. Whilst he maintained that view however, Associate Professor Navathe also conceded that the statistical bleeding risk was reduced in Mr McSherry’s case for a number of reasons. Those included the following:·Mr McSherry had been taking Warfarin for approximately seven years and had never experienced a bleed associated with Warfarin;·He was otherwise in good health;·There was a possibility that Mr McSherry would suffer symptoms in advance of any such event which would allow him to either not fly or take some other evasive action;·There was a possibility that any incompletely incapacitating event would not coincide with a high cognitive workload, which reduced the risk of an adverse event;·There was a real possibility that Mr McSherry would be able to land his helicopter in the event of an incompletely incapacitating event, which further reduced the risk;·When he has flown commercially, Mr McSherry has flown for between 200 and 300 hours per year, with 300 hours being in the order of 3% of a year; and·Thus in statistical terms, the likelihood of an incompletely incapacitating bleed coinciding with a time during the year when Mr McSherry was flying was in the order of 0.03%. Accordingly, we understood the effect of Associate Professor Navathe’s evidence to be that the only risk which he considered to be real related to an incompletely incapacitating bleed related to Mr McSherry’s use of Warfarin. However, he also conceded that the risk of an incompletely incapacitating bleed occurring and having adverse consequences in terms of safety was significantly below 1%, noting that the statistical likelihood of an incompletely incapacitating bleed occurring whilst Mr McSherry was flying was in the order of 0.03%. Whilst Associate Professor Navathe resiled during his oral evidence from a number of the opinions and conclusions expressed in his written statement, he maintained his view that Mr McSherry suffered from a safety-relevant condition, because of the risk of him suffering from an incompletely incapacitating bleed.