Petchell v Du Pradal; Pia Du Pradal Pty Ltd v Petchell

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Petchell v Du Pradal; Pia Du Pradal Pty Ltd v Petchell [2015] QCA 132

PARTIES:

In Appeal No 11051 of 2014:

DAVID PETCHELL
(appellant)
v
JACQUES DU PRADAL
(respondent)

In Appeal No 11118 of 2014:

PIA DU PRADAL PTY LTD
ACN 067 906 450
(appellant)
v
DAVID PETCHELL
(respondent)

FILE NOS:

Appeal No 11051 of 2014
Appeal No 11118 of 2014
SC No 5581 of 2011

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeals

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2014] QSC 261

DELIVERED ON:

17 July 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 May 2015

JUDGES:

Gotterson JA and Atkinson and Martin JJ
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the order made

ORDER:

The appeals are dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE – WHERE ECONOMIC OR FINANCIAL LOSS – CARELESS ACTS OR OMISSIONS – where the defendant was found to have negligently caused injury to the first plaintiff – where the trial judge made an assessment of damages based on expert and other evidence given at trial – whether the trial judge erred in the assessment of damages for past and future economic loss – whether the trial judge erred in the assessment of damages for past and future care and assistance

PROCEDURE – SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – PROCEDURE UNDER UNIFORM CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES AND PREDECESSORS – PLEADING – GENERALLY – where the second plaintiff pleaded a cause of action and specified a measure of damages under that cause of action – where the High Court of Australia ruled, between the close of pleadings and the trial of the matter, that the measure of damages specified was incorrect – where evidence was raised at trial conforming to the correct measure of damages – where the second plaintiff at trial sought to argue the correct measure of damages – whether failure to plead the correct measure of damages, either originally or by amendment, was fatal to the second plaintiff’s claim for damages

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – OTHER PECUNIARY DAMAGE – where the first plaintiff was an employee of the second plaintiff – where the first plaintiff was injured outside his employment and was consequently unable to continue working in the second plaintiff’s business – where costs were incurred by the second plaintiff in paying for other persons to do work that would otherwise have been done by the first plaintiff – where the second plaintiff did not pay the first plaintiff any wages after his injury – where the sum expended by the second plaintiff to replace the first plaintiff’s services was less than the amount of the wages that would have been due to him – whether the second plaintiff was entitled to damages per quod servitium amisit

EMPLOYMENT LAW – RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES AS BETWEEN EMPLOYER AND THIRD PARTIES – RIGHTS OF…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Petchell v Du Pradal; Pia Du Pradal Pty Ltd v Petchell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QCA 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Petchell v Du Pradal; Pia Du Pradal Pty Ltd v Petchell involved the defendants, Mr Petchell and Pia Du Pradal Pty Ltd, being found to have negligently caused injury to Mr Du Pradal, the first plaintiff. The court was required to determine whether the trial judge erred in the assessment of damages for past and future economic loss and care and assistance, as well as whether the second plaintiff's failure to plead the correct measure of damages was fatal to their claim. The second plaintiff argued for damages per quod servitium amisit, given that the costs incurred to replace the first plaintiff's services were less than the wages that would have been due to him. The court's reasoning focused on the common ground that damages for past and future economic loss represent a diminution in earning capacity that results in financial loss. The trial judge's assessment of past economic loss, considering Mr Du Pradal's administrative role and the subsequent loss of capacity, was upheld. For future economic loss, the court found Mr Du Pradal's intention to continue working for another 10 years to be aspirational. The court dismissed the appeals, upholding the trial judge's assessment of damages for past economic loss and interest, as well as the measure of damages for care and assistance.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeals, meaning that the trial judge's assessment of damages for past economic loss and interest, as well as the measure of damages for care and assistance, were confirmed. This outcome ensures that the trial judge's findings on the diminution in earning capacity and the necessary care and assistance for Mr Du Pradal remain in place.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeals are dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pia Du Pradal Pty Ltd (the company) brought an action against Mr Petchell and the company's former employee, Mr Du Pradal, following injuries sustained by Mr Du Pradal in an accident. Mr Du Pradal was an employee of the company, performing administrative tasks and receiving a management fee. His role included handling accounts, paying bills, and managing deliveries. Mr Du Pradal was injured outside his employment and, as a result, was unable to continue working for the company. The company incurred costs in hiring other individuals to perform the tasks Mr Du Pradal could no longer do. Mr Du Pradal did not receive any salary or management fees from the company after his injury. The company sought damages for the loss of Mr Du Pradal's services, arguing it was entitled to damages per quod servitium amisit. The case also involved an assessment of damages for past and future economic loss and care and assistance.

The case was initially heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The trial judge assessed damages based on expert and other evidence presented at the trial. The decision was appealed, with the appellants arguing that the trial judge had erred in the assessment of damages for past and future economic loss and care and assistance. The appeal was heard and decided by the Supreme Court of Queensland.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge erred in the assessment of damages for past and future economic loss.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in the assessment of damages for past and future care and assistance.
3. Whether the failure to plead the correct measure of damages was fatal to the second plaintiff's claim for damages.

Held
1. The court concluded that the trial judge did not err in the assessment of damages for past and future economic loss. The assessment of past economic loss at $144,200 and future economic loss at $14,247 was upheld.
2. The court concluded that the trial judge did not err in the assessment of damages for past and future care and assistance. The allowance for domestic assistance and yard assistance was upheld.
3. The court concluded that the failure to plead the correct measure of damages was not fatal to the second plaintiff's claim for damages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to future care, Mr Petchell submitted that there should be no allowance for personal care; that there should be no allowance, or alternatively only one hour per week, for domestic assistance; and that future care should only be allowed for five years, i.e. until Mr Du Pradal turns 76, not for 16 years. No challenge was made to the one hour per week allowed for yard assistance.Consideration It was common ground before the learned trial judge that damages for past and future economic loss represent diminution in earning capacity that is productive of financial loss: Medlin v State Government Insurance Commission.[1][1](1995) 182 CLR 1 at 3 and 16. As the learned trial judge found, Mr Du Pradal performed an administrative role in the Du Pradal company’s business for which he received the relatively modest salary or “management fee” of $30,000 gross a year in each of the three years before his injury. These management fees were in addition to dividends which were received both before and after his injury (except for the 2009 year). Since he was injured, Mr Du Pradal has received no salary or management fees from the Du Pradal company. The Du Pradal company runs a business which designs, manufactures and sells limited runs of high-quality clothing, both made-to-measure and ready-to-wear. Mrs Du Pradal designs the clothes, chooses the fabric and works in the boutiques where the clothes are sold. Mr Du Pradal’s role in the company was to do all the book work, attend to all the accounts and pay the bills. At the time when he was injured, the Du Pradal company was in the process of buying a studio. Mr Du Pradal, a qualified and experienced architect, was to plan and organise the fit out. He had also done the negotiations with the banks. Mr Du Pradal was responsible for dealing with suppliers, running stock and other deliveries, that is, what was described as the “rational” rather than the creative side of the business, which was the domain of Mrs Du Pradal. Mr Du Pradal’s injuries meant that he was unable to perform any of his administrative tasks until 31 December 2010 when his injuries “somewhat stabilised”.[2] After that date, he was assessed as having lost about 80 per cent of his pre-accident capacity. It was therefore correct to assess his past economic loss at $500 net per week until 31 December 2010 and at $400 net per week from 1 January 2011 until the date of judgment. That amount is $144,200.[2]Du Pradal v Petchell [2014] QSC 261 at [118]. Mr Petchell did not dispute that the correct interest rate to apply was 1.56 per cent. For the six years and four months from injury to judgment, this represents interest payable of $14,247. The appeal against the award for past economic loss and interest on it cannot be successful. So far as future economic loss is concerned, the learned trial judge found that Mr Du Pradal’s expressed intention to have continued working for another 10 years, until June 2018, if he had not been injured, was “aspirational”.[3][3]At [119].