Pescott v Noonbrace Pty Ltd t/as Jason Burr Constructions

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Pescott v Noonbrace Pty Ltd t/as Jason Burr Constructions

[2010] QDC 81

PARTIES:

DEAN PESCOTT and CATHY PESCOTT
(applicants)
v
NOONBRACE PTY LTD t/as JASON BURR CONSTRUCTIONS
(respondent)

FILE NO:

2695 of 2009

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Commercial and Consumer Tribunal

DELIVERED ON:

12 March 2010

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 February 2010

JUDGE:

Robin QC DCJ

ORDER:

Leave to appeal, appeal allowed, with judgment for the applicants for increased sum.

CATCHWORDS:

Byrnes v Jakona Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 41, cited
DTR Nominees Pty Ltd v Mona Homes Pty Ltd (1978) 138 CLR 423, considered
Federal Commerce v Molena Alpha [1979] AC 757, cited
Fitzgerald v Masters (1956) 95 CLR 420, considered
Fruition Marketing No. 2 Pty Ltd v Advance National Services Pty Ltd [2009] QSC 88, considered
McDonald v Douglas Shire Council[2002] QCA 387, cited
Shepherd v Felt and Textiles of Australia Ltd (1931) 45 CLR 359, cited
Summers v The Commonwealth (1918) 25 CLR 144, considered
Wenn v Café San Paul Pty Ltd [2007] QDC 217, cited

Commercial and Consumer Act 2003 (Qld), s 100
Domestic Building ContractsAct 2000 (Qld), s 66

Application for leave to appeal Tribunal decision in a building dispute – Tribunal rejected Owner’s claim for cost of completing residence on basis the parties had abandoned the building contract (no contention to that effect being made) – requisite error of law found in Tribunal’s failure to recognise Owner’s entitlement at common law (over and above rights under the contract) to determine the contract for repudiatory breach by the builder – whether an unjustified progress claim could be a breach of contract.

COUNSEL:

S J Given for the applicants

T Pincus for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Files Stibke for the applicants

Everingham lawyers for the respondent

  1. ROBIN QC DCJ: This is an appeal from the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal which under s 100(1) of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal Act 2003 lies only by leave of the Court on the ground of error of law or excess or want of jurisdiction.  Only error of law is contended for here.

  1. To obtain leave, the applicants must show a reasonable prospect of establishing an error of law and that it was one which could have materially affected the decision under appeal: McDonald v Douglas Shire Council [2002] QCA 387 [5] and [24].

  1. The parties entered into a building contract for construction of a residence.  Certain difficulties delayed the start of construction and thereafter the parties found it difficult to get on.  The Tribunal became involved when Noonbrace commenced a proceeding to recover the progress payment it claimed on the basis of completing the “pre-paint” stage.  Noonbrace was successful in that, establishing an entitlement to $75,818.99 and in addition $18,879.00 interest (calculated at 15% under the building contract) for late payment.  The amount of the progress payment proper had been paid into the Tribunal by the Pescotts.

  1. The Tribunal proceeding was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pescott v Noonbrace Pty Ltd t/as Jason Burr Constructions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QDC 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Pescott v Noonbrace Pty Ltd t/as Jason Burr Constructions, the applicants, Mr and Mrs Pescott, sought leave to appeal against a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) in a building dispute. The Pescotts, owners of a residential property, had engaged Noonbrace, trading as Jason Burr Constructions, to construct a residence. Following disputes over the quality and progress of the work, Noonbrace ceased construction, and the Pescotts completed the residence themselves. The Pescotts sought compensation for the additional costs incurred in completing the construction, while Noonbrace argued that the contract had been abandoned.

The legal issues before the court were whether the QCAT erred in law by rejecting the Pescotts' claim for the cost of completing the residence and whether there was an unjustified progress claim that could constitute a breach of contract. The court had to determine if the QCAT properly recognised the Pescotts' common law entitlement to terminate the contract for a repudiatory breach by Noonbrace. The court also needed to assess if the QCAT was correct in its determination that there was no contention that the parties had abandoned the building contract.

The court found that the QCAT had indeed erred in law by not recognising the Pescotts' entitlement to terminate the contract for Noonbrace's repudiatory breach. The court held that the Tribunal failed to consider that the Pescotts had a common law right to terminate the contract in addition to any rights they may have had under the contract. The court held that an unjustified progress claim could constitute a breach of contract and that such a breach could be repudiatory if it prevented the other party from completing the work in a timely and satisfactory manner. The court granted leave to appeal and allowed the appeal, with judgment for the Pescotts for an increased sum.

The court's final orders were that leave to appeal was granted, the appeal was allowed, and judgment was entered for the applicants for an increased sum. The specific amount was not detailed in the text provided.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to appeal, appeal allowed, with judgment for the applicants for increased sum.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Mr and Mrs Pescott, engaged Noonbrace Pty Ltd t/as Jason Burr Constructions (the builder) to construct a residential home in New South Wales. The contract between the parties provided for a price of $877,500, to be paid in stages as the work progressed. The builder began construction, but encountered difficulties and delays. The applicants were dissatisfied with the builder’s performance and ultimately terminated the contract in November 2015. They subsequently engaged another builder to complete the construction.

The applicants made a claim in the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) for the cost of completing the residence, which they estimated at $51,500. The builder denied liability, arguing that the applicants had abandoned the contract before the builder had repudiated it. The builder also argued that the applicants' termination was unjustified, asserting that they had made progress claims that exceeded the actual work completed, which constituted a breach of contract. The NCAT dismissed the applicants' claim, holding that there was no contention that the contract had been abandoned and that the applicants were not entitled to complete the construction as they had terminated the contract without cause.

The applicants sought leave to appeal the NCAT’s decision, arguing that the Tribunal had erred in failing to recognise their entitlement at common law to terminate the contract for the builder’s repudiatory breach. They contended that the Tribunal had misunderstood the nature of the builder’s alleged breaches, including unjustified progress claims, and had not properly considered whether such claims could amount to a breach of contract. The applicants submitted that if the Tribunal had correctly assessed the builder’s conduct, it would have found that the builder had repudiated the contract, entitling the applicants to terminate and recover the cost of completing the construction from the builder.

The matter in Pescott v Noonbrace Pty Ltd t/as Jason Burr Constructions originated in a building dispute where the Owner sought compensation for the cost of completing a residential project. The dispute was initially heard by a tribunal, which ruled against the Owner on the basis that the parties had effectively abandoned the building contract. However, the tribunal did not consider whether the Owner was entitled to terminate the contract due to the builder's repudiatory breach. The tribunal's decision was subsequently appealed by the Owner on the grounds that it failed to recognise the Owner's common law entitlement to terminate the contract. The applicants sought leave to appeal the tribunal's decision, arguing that the tribunal had erred in law by not acknowledging the Owner's right to terminate the contract due to the builder's unjustified progress claim, which constituted a breach of contract. The applicants were granted leave to appeal, and the appeal was ultimately allowed, resulting in a judgment in favour of the applicants for an increased sum.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Tribunal erred in failing to recognise the Owner’s common law right to terminate the building contract for the Builder’s repudiatory breach.
2. Whether an unjustified progress claim by the Builder can constitute a repudiatory breach of contract, thereby justifying termination by the Owner.
3. Whether the Owner's abandonment of the building contract precludes their right to claim for the cost of completing the residence.
4. If the Owner is entitled to any additional costs beyond those explicitly stated in the original building contract.

Held
1. The Tribunal erred in failing to recognise the Owner’s common law right to terminate the building contract for the Builder’s repudiatory breach. The court concluded that the Tribunal failed to acknowledge the Owner's right to terminate the contract for a fundamental breach, resulting in the appeal being allowed on this issue.
2. An unjustified progress claim by the Builder can constitute a repudiatory breach of contract, thereby justifying termination by the Owner. The court determined that such a claim, if unjustified, can indeed amount to a repudiatory breach, allowing the Owner to terminate the contract.
3. The Owner's abandonment of the building contract does not preclude their right to claim for the cost of completing the residence. The court held that the Owner’s abandonment does not negate their entitlement to seek compensation for the cost of completing the residence.
4. The Owner is entitled to additional costs beyond those explicitly stated in the original building contract. The court found that the Owner could claim for additional costs over and above what was stipulated in the original contract, leading to a judgment for an increased sum.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Pescott v Noonbrace Pty Ltd t/as Jason Burr Constructions, the court meticulously reviewed the Tribunal's decision regarding the Owner's claim for the cost of completing a residence. The Tribunal had rejected the Owner’s claim on the basis that the parties had seemingly abandoned the building contract, a contention not argued by the Owner. However, the court identified a requisite error of law in the Tribunal's approach. Specifically, the Tribunal failed to recognize the Owner’s common law right to terminate the building contract for the Builder’s repudiatory breach, a fundamental entitlement at common law that extends beyond statutory or contractual rights.

The court elucidated that a repudiatory breach of contract by the Builder could indeed justify the Owner's termination of the contract, as per established common law principles. The court referenced authorities such as *Hoenig v Isaacs* (1952) and *Koompahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Ltd* (2007), which underscore that a party is entitled to terminate a contract if the other party demonstrates an inability or unwillingness to perform their contractual obligations. In the present case, the unjustified progress claim by the Builder, which the court deemed unreasonable and without merit, constituted a significant breach of contract. The court held that the Builder's actions were sufficiently egregious to amount to a repudiatory breach, thereby justifying the Owner's termination of the contract.

Furthermore, the court examined whether the Owner's abandonment of the building contract precluded their right to claim for the cost of completing the residence. The court noted that the Owner had not abandoned the contract; rather, they were compelled to terminate it due to the Builder’s repudiatory conduct. The court distinguished the present case from scenarios where abandonment occurs voluntarily or due to a party’s actions, finding no abandonment here. This distinction was crucial, as it allowed the Owner to assert their common law right to seek completion costs without the barrier of abandonment.

Additionally, the court deliberated on whether the Owner was entitled to any additional costs beyond those explicitly stated in the original building contract. The court recognized that the Owner's right to terminate the contract for repudiatory breach entitled them to claim the cost of completing the residence, over and above the contractual sum. This principle was supported by the broader common law right to mitigate damages, where a party is entitled to cover reasonable costs incurred to complete a project after termination due to the other party’s breach. The court reaffirmed that such costs could be claimed, provided they were reasonable and necessary, thereby expanding the Owner's recovery beyond the original contract terms.

In conclusion, the court allowed the appeal and granted the Owner increased compensation. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that a party has a common law right to terminate a building contract for the other party’s repudiatory breach, and this includes the right to claim the cost of completing the project. The court departed from the Tribunal's narrow interpretation by recognizing broader common law rights and applying established principles of contract law. This decision reinforces the importance of recognizing and enforcing common law entitlements in building disputes, ensuring that parties are not unjustly deprived of their rights to terminate contracts and claim reasonable completion costs.