Perth v Halle

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read
13 CLR 393

THE MAYOR, COUNCILLORS AND

APPELLANTS;

CITIZENS OF PERTH

DEFENDANTS, HALLE Right to the flow of subterranean water-Removal of sand and water-Subsidence -

Statutory authority--Nuisance-Municipalities Act 1906 (W.A.), (No. 32 of 1906), secs. 221, 235.

In February 1899 the appellants, the Municipality of Perth, acting under statutory authority, put down a stormwater drain in a public street. Some years after the completion of the drain the respondent erected two houses which fronted the street in which the drain was laid, one house being built in 1904 and the other in 1905. Shortly afterwards the walls of both houses began to crack-one in 1906 and the other in 1907. The drain was badly con- structed, large quantities of sand and water, carried away from the adjoining land, finding their way into it.

Held, affirming the judgment of McMillan J., that the appellants were liable for the loss of support caused by the removal of sand, and that the legal consequences would have been the same if the damage had resulted merely from the withdrawal of water, the appellants not being owners of the soil of the street so as to bring themselves within the doctrine of Chasemore V. Richards, 7 H.L.C., 349, and Popplewell v. Hodkinson, L. .R. 4 Ex., 248, and having exceeded the authority of the Statute from which they derived their

Per Griffith C.J.-The rights of the appellants with respect to the land in the streets of Perth are only such as are authorized by the Statute and if and so far as they exceed their authority they are in no better position than a mere wrongdoer creating a public nuisance in the street.

Judgment of the Supreme Court varied and affirmed as varied.

13 CLR 394

APPEAL from a judgment of McMillan J. sitting without a jury.

Halle brought an action against the Perth City Council for the negligent construction and maintenance of a drain in Royal Street, Perth, alleging that large quantities of water and sand had thereby been carried away, causing a subsidence in the sur- rounding soil and damaging his houses. McMillan favour of Halle both on the facts and the law, leaving the dam- ages, by agreement of both parties, to be assessed by a jury.

From this decision the defendants now appealed to the High Court.

Pilkington K.C. (with him Robinson), for the appellants. The respondent's theory was that, as the water came in from the holes in the drain, sand followed it for a great distance on both sides of the drain from 50 to 100 yards, causing a subsidence of the street. The respondent attempted to prove the subsidence by taking levels. As a matter of fact it was not subsidence but wear and tear that caused the differences in the levels. McMillan J. did not give sufficient weight to the evidence given to rebut the respondent's theory. The cracks in the footpath, relied upon by the respondent, were not due to subsidence at all. The evidence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perth v Halle and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1911] HCA 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Perth v Halle* involved an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a judgment of the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The respondent, Halle, had sued the appellants, the Municipality of Perth, alleging that the negligent construction and maintenance of a stormwater drain in Royal Street had caused large quantities of sand and water to be removed from the subsoil, resulting in subsidence and damage to his houses.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the Municipality was liable for the damage caused by the removal of sand and, alternatively, for damage caused by the withdrawal of subterranean water. The Municipality contended that they were not liable for the mere abstraction of water, relying on the principles established in cases such as *Chasemore v. Richards* and *Popplewell v. Hodkinson*, which generally protect landowners from liability for draining percolating water from their own land. They also argued that any damage was due to faulty construction of the houses or the inherent marshy nature of the land.

The High Court, affirming the judgment of the Supreme Court, held that the Municipality was liable for the loss of support caused by the removal of sand due to the negligent construction and maintenance of the drain. The Court reasoned that while the Municipality had statutory authority to construct drains, this authority did not extend to negligent execution or maintenance. Furthermore, the Court found that the Municipality did not possess the full proprietary rights of a landowner in the soil of the street, which would have been necessary to invoke the full protection of the *Chasemore v. Richards* doctrine. Griffith C.J. stated that the Municipality's rights were limited by statute, and exceeding those powers placed them in the position of a wrongdoer. The Court also indicated that even if the damage had resulted solely from the withdrawal of water, the Municipality would likely still be liable because they were not owners of the soil in a manner that would grant them immunity, and their actions exceeded the scope of their statutory authority.

The High Court varied the judgment of the Supreme Court by limiting the recoverable damages to those caused by the Municipality's negligence, excluding any damage that would have occurred even if the drain had been constructed and maintained without negligence. The appeal was otherwise affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.