Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd Trading as Perth Landscaping Experts v Mark Mason

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
[2025] FWC 1429

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.120—Redundancy pay

Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd Trading AS Perth Landscaping Experts

v

Mark Mason

(C2025/1918)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT BINET

PERTH, 2 JULY 2025

Variation of redundancy pay

  1. Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd trading as Perth Landscaping Experts (Applicant) has applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) for an order pursuant to section 120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act), that the amount of redundancy pay due to Mr Mark Mason (Mr Mason) be reduced from 7 weeks of Mr Mason’s base rate of pay for his ordinary hours of work to zero (Order), on the grounds that Perth Landscaping Experts does not have the capacity to pay Mr Mason his redundancy entitlements (Application).

  1. The Application asserts that the ACN of Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd is 604 734 698 and that the ABN is 44 604 734 698.   The contact person nominated for the Applicant in the Application is Mr Thibaut Holl (Mr Holl) who is identified in correspondence to Chambers as the owner of ‘Perth Landscaping Group’.

  1. Mr Mason objects to the FWC making the Order sought by Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd.

  1. Directions were first issued to the parties (Directions) on 27 March 2025.

  1. In accordance with the Directions, the parties filed an Agreed Statement of Facts which the parties were advised would be admitted into evidence and considered not in dispute.

  1. The Directions contained an invitation for either party to make a request to be heard orally in relation to the Application. The parties were advised that, should neither party wish to make oral submissions, and subject to my review of the materials filed in accordance with the Directions, a conclusion about the Application may be made on the written materials filed.

  1. No request to be heard orally was received from either party.

Evidence

  1. The Directions directed Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd to file in the FWC and serve on Mr Mason an outline of submissions in support of the Application, any witness statements, authorities and copies of documents upon which it sought to rely for the Application.

  1. In particular, the Directions required Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd to file:

a.   Audited balance sheet for the financial year ended 30 June 2024.

b.   Audited profit and loss report for the financial year ended 30 June 2024.

c.   A profit and loss report for the current financial year.

d.   A balance sheet for the current financial year.

e.   A cash flow statement for the 12 months to the date of the Application.

f.    A statement detailing Perth Landscaping’s current cash reserves as at the date of the Application.

g.   A list of employees as at the date of the Application.

  1. The Directions also required Mr Mason to file in the FWC and serve on the Applicant an outline of submissions in response to the Application, any witness statements,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd Trading as Perth Landscapi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FWC 1429
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd Trading as Perth Landscaping Experts, represented by Thibaut Holl, applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) under section 120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) for a reduction in the redundancy pay owed to Mark Mason, from seven weeks of his base rate of pay for ordinary hours of work to zero. The FWC was asked to make this order on the grounds that Perth Landscaping Experts did not have the capacity to pay Mr Mason his redundancy entitlements. Mark Mason opposed the application. The legal issues before the FWC were whether Perth Landscaping Experts had the standing to make the application and, if so, whether the FWC should exercise its discretion to reduce the amount of redundancy pay owed to Mr Mason.

The FWC found that Perth Landscaping Experts did not have the standing to make the application as it was not Mr Mason's employer. The parties agreed that Mr Mason's employer was in fact Perth Landscaping and Gardening Pty Ltd. The FWC also found that, even if Perth Landscaping Experts had the standing to make the application, it was not appropriate to reduce the amount of redundancy pay owed to Mr Mason. The application had not been supported by any substantive submissions. The initial materials filed in support of the application were for a differently named legal entity than the applicant and were unaudited and unsupported by witness evidence attesting to their accuracy or explaining their content. Subsequent materials filed unaccompanied by any substantive submissions did not adequately demonstrate a clear inability to pay. The use of the same trading name by multiple related entities made the analysis of the true financial state of Mr Mason's employer difficult to accurately ascertain. The financial interrelationship between the related entities was consistent with Mr Mason's evidence that work and the labour of employees were shared among the related entities. No effort was made by the applicant to explain the nature of these transactions or to provide any substantive submissions about the financial position of Mr Mason's employer or the related entities. Given the extent of the financial, ownership, and operational interrelationships between the related entities, it was appropriate to take into account the financial capacity of the other entities to assist Perth Landscaping and Gardening Pty Ltd to pay Mr Mason his entitlements. These entities appeared to be experiencing strong sales. In all the circumstances, the FWC was not satisfied it was appropriate to make the order sought.

The FWC therefore dismissed the application. An order to this effect will issue with this decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd, trading as Perth Landscaping Experts, has applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) for an order to reduce the redundancy pay due to Mr Mark Mason from 7 weeks of his base rate of pay to zero, on the grounds that the company does not have the capacity to pay Mr Mason's redundancy entitlements. The company asserts that it does not have the necessary funds to make the payment and has no reasonable source of funds. Mr Mason objects to the FWC making the order sought by Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd. Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd is not the legal entity that employed Mr Mason. The parties agree that Mr Mason’s employer was Perth Landscaping & Gardening Pty Ltd (PL&G). The evidence suggests a complex interrelationship between PL&G and other related entities, with financial transactions and shared employees. Despite this complexity, the financial records indicate that the related entities are trading strongly.

The matter came before the Fair Work Commission (FWC) as an application under section 120 of the Fair Work Act 2009. Directions were issued to the parties on 27 March 2025, which required both parties to file an Agreed Statement of Facts and specific financial documents. Neither party requested to be heard orally, and the decision was made on the written materials filed. Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd initially filed unaudited financial documents and a letter from its accountant. Further directions were issued for additional financial records, tax returns, and statements from the accountant. Mr Mason filed submissions and a witness statement from his accountant, raising questions about the identity of the legal entity that employed Mr Mason and the financial interrelationship between the related businesses. Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd filed further financial documents and statements, but did not provide substantive written submissions in support of the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd have standing to make the application on behalf of Mr Mark Mason?
2. Is it appropriate to exercise the discretion to reduce the amount of redundancy payments payable to Mr Mark Mason?
3. To what extent should the financial interrelationship between the related entities be considered in assessing the capacity to pay redundancy entitlements?

Held
1. The court held that Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd does not have standing to make the application on behalf of Mr Mark Mason. The court found that Mr Mason's employer was Perth Landscaping & Gardening Pty Ltd, not Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd.
2. The court held that it is not appropriate to exercise its discretion to reduce the amount of redundancy payments payable to Mr Mark Mason. The court found that the applicant did not adequately demonstrate a clear inability to pay the redundancy payments.
3. The court held that the financial interrelationship between the related entities should be considered in assessing the capacity to pay redundancy entitlements. The court noted that the related entities appeared to be trading strongly and could potentially assist Perth Landscaping & Gardening Pty Ltd in paying Mr Mason his entitlements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Fair Work Commission assessed the application to reduce the redundancy pay for Mr Mark Mason based on the evidence and submissions presented by both parties. The Commission first considered the issue of standing, determining that Perth Landscaping Experts Pty Ltd, the entity named in the application, was not Mr Mason's employer. The employer was identified as Perth Landscaping & Gardening Pty Ltd, and since the application was not made by the correct entity, the application lacked standing.

In examining the discretion to reduce redundancy payments, the Commission applied the principles set out in Mildren Automotive Pty Ltd, focusing on whether the applicant could demonstrate an inability to pay. The Commission found that the applicant did not meet this burden, as the submissions were insufficient and the financial records provided were unaudited and unsupported. Furthermore, the use of the same business names by different legal entities complicated the analysis of the financial state of Mr Mason's employer.

The Commission also considered the financial interrelationship between the related entities, finding that these entities shared work and employees in practice. Given this interrelationship, the financial capacity of the other entities was relevant in assessing whether Perth Landscaping & Gardening Pty Ltd could pay the redundancy. Despite Perth Landscaping & Gardening Pty Ltd showing a balance sheet loss, the related entities appeared to be experiencing strong sales, indicating potential financial support. However, the applicant did not provide any substantive submissions to support a claim of financial incapacity, leading the Commission to conclude that it was not appropriate to reduce the redundancy payments in this case.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that in assessing an application to reduce redundancy pay due to incapacity to pay, the Fair Work Commission will consider not only the financial capacity of the employer named in the application but also the financial interrelationships with related entities. The applicant bears the onus of demonstrating a clear inability to pay, and the Commission will exercise its discretion based on the evidence provided.