Perth Airport Pty Ltd v Airservices Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Perth Airport Pty Ltd v Airservices Australia [2025] FCA 351

File number: WAD 181 of 2022
Judgment of: FEUTRILL J
Date of judgment: 11 April 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to further amend statement of claim – introduction of new issue – whether amendments would render pleading evasive or ambiguous or likely to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay in proceeding – fair notice of case to be met
Legislation:

Airports Act 1996 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 54A

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 16.02, 16.21

Cases cited: Altrad Australia Pty Ltd v Dropulich [2025] FCA 342
Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 37
Date of hearing: 3 April 2025
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms JK Taylor SC with Mr P Walker
Solicitor for the Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms PE Cahill SC with Ms M Georgiou
Solicitor for the Respondent: Maddocks Lawyers

ORDERS

WAD 181 of 2022
BETWEEN:

PERTH AIRPORT PTY LTD ACN 077 153 130

Applicant

AND:

AIRSERVICES AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

FEUTRILL J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 APRIL 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant have leave to amend its statement of claim in terms of the minute of proposed further amended statement of claim that is annexure “A” to the interlocutory application filed 4 November 2024.

2.By 4.30pm (AWST) on 17 April 2025 the applicant file and serve the further amended statement of claim.

3.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs thrown away consequent on the amendment.

4.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

5.Paragraphs 5 – 8 of the orders made on 21 November 2024 be set aside.

6.By 4.30pm (AWST) on 24 April 2025 the respondent:

(a)file and serve an amended defence; or

(b)serve on the applicant a minute of proposed amended defence with proposed amendments that are not merely responsive to the amendments made in the further amended statement of claim.

7.By 4.30pm (AWST) on 1 May 2025 the applicant serve on the respondent a notice indicating whether it consents to any minute served in accordance with paragraph 6(b) of these orders.

8.By 4.30pm (AWST) on 8 May 2025 the respondent:

(a)file any minute of proposed consent orders; or

(b)file and serve any application,

for leave to amend its defence in terms of any minute served in accordance with paragraph 6(b) of the orders.

9.By 4.30pm (AWST) on 15 May 2025:

(a)the applicant file and serve a minute of proposed consent orders concerning the future conduct of the proceeding and a position paper in support of the proposed orders; or

(b)the parties file and serve competing minutes of proposed orders concerning the future conduct of the proceeding and position papers in support of the proposed orders.

10.The minute(s) filed and served in accordance with paragraph 9 of these orders are to address the following matters and such other matters as either…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perth Airport Pty Ltd v Airservices Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 351
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Perth Airport Pty Ltd sought leave to further amend its statement of claim against Airservices Australia. The applicant sought to introduce the concept of potentially toxic substances into its pleaded case, which had previously alleged that the introduction of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) was actually toxic to the environment and humans. Airservices opposed the application, contending that the proposed amendment would introduce a new and alternative case that would prejudice its ability to defend the proceeding. The court was required to decide whether the proposed amendment would render the pleading evasive, ambiguous or inconsistent, or whether it would introduce an alternative case likely to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay in the proceeding. In deciding the application, the court found that the introduction of the concept of potentially toxic substances did not render the pleading ambiguous or inconsistent, nor did it introduce an alternative case that would cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay in the proceeding. The court held that the proposed amendment provided fair notice of the case to be met and would not prejudice the respondent's ability to defend the proceeding. Accordingly, the court granted the applicant leave to further amend its statement of claim in the terms set out in the minute of proposed further amended statement of claim annexed to the applicant's interlocutory application. The court also made orders concerning the exchange of submissions, the listing of the application, the setting aside of certain previous orders and the future conduct of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant have leave to amend its statement of claim in terms of the minute of proposed further amended statement of claim that is annexure “A” to the interlocutory application filed 4 November 2024.

2. By 4.30pm (AWST) on 17 April 2025 the applicant file and serve the further amended statement of claim.

3. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs thrown away consequent on the amendment.

4. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

5. Paragraphs 5 – 8 of the orders made on 21 November 2024 be set aside.

6. By 4.30pm (AWST) on 24 April 2025 the respondent:

(a) file and serve an amended defence; or

(b) serve on the applicant a minute of proposed amended defence with proposed amendments that are not merely responsive to the amendments made in the further amended statement of claim.

7. By 4.30pm (AWST) on 1 May 2025 the applicant serve on the respondent a notice indicating whether it consents to any minute served in accordance with paragraph 6(b) of these orders.

8. By 4.30pm (AWST) on 8 May 2025 the respondent:

(a) file any minute of proposed consent orders; or

(b) file and serve any application,

for leave to amend its defence in terms of any minute served in accordance with paragraph 6(b) of the orders.

9. By 4.30pm (AWST) on 15 May 2025:

(a) the applicant file and serve a minute of proposed consent orders concerning the future conduct of the proceeding and a position paper in support of the proposed orders; or

(b) the parties file and serve competing minutes of proposed orders concerning the future conduct of the proceeding and position papers in support of the proposed orders.

10. The minute(s) filed and served in accordance with paragraph 9 of these orders are to address the following matters and such other matters as either party may consider relevant and appropriate:

(a) any proposed change(s) to the referee proposal the subject of paragraph 4 of the orders made on 21 November 2024;

(b) any proposed extensions of time for completion of referee reports;

(c) any proposed further or additional steps necessary for completion of referee reports;

(d) proposed orders relating to adoption or a hearing concerning adoption of referee reports;

(e) proposed orders relating to mediation; and

(f) proposed orders for completion of all remaining interlocutory steps and determination of all issues in the proceeding.

11. The position paper(s) filed and served in accordance with paragraph 9 of these orders is (are) to as briefly as the issue or matter permits:

(a) irrespective of whether or not any change to the referee proposal is proposed, identify the issues in the proceedings, by reference to the applicable paragraphs of the pleadings, to which each question (or proposed new or amended question) in the referee proposal relates;

(b) set out the grounds or reasons for any proposed change to the referee proposal;

(c) explain the present state of preparation of referee reports, estimated time for completion and any steps that are required before completion;

(d) explain the present state of discovery and inspection in the proceeding; and

(e) to the extent that they are not self-explanatory, set out the grounds or reasons in support of the proposed orders.

12. The proceeding be listed for a case management hearing at 10.15am (AWST) on 21 May 2025 for 2 hours.

13. The parties have liberty to apply on 48 hours’ written notice for orders setting aside or varying paragraphs 9 – 12 of these orders and, otherwise, to relist the case management hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

A central feature of the applicant’s amended statement of claim is that: ‘at certain levels, [PFAS] is toxic to organisms in the environment including to humans’; the Perth airport land has had, and continues to have ‘concentrations of PFAS which are above acceptable levels (in that they pose a material risk to the environment or to humans)’ (described in the pleading as PFAS Contamination); and, as a result of the actions of the Civil Aviation Authority and Airservices, damage was caused and is continuing to be caused to certain parts of the Perth airport land (described in the pleading as Contaminated Sites).Relevant procedural background The applicant filed an originating process and statement of claim on 29 August 2022 and Airservices filed a notice of appointment of lawyer on 9 September 2022. The proceeding was initially allocated to another docket judge who made orders in October 2022 requiring the parties to confer with a view to identifying all the matters likely to be in dispute relating to the use of PFAS, the extent of contamination, the past cost associated with addressing PFAS contamination and costs of remediation with a view to identifying questions for inquiry and report by suitably experienced referees. On 28 November 2022 the docket judge granted the applicant leave to file an amended originating application. On 29 November 2022 the applicant filed an amended originating application and an amended statement of claim. The central features of the statement of claim were unaffected by the amendment. On 3 February 2023 Airservices filed its defence and on 3 March 2023 the applicant filed its reply. In the meantime, pursuant to orders made on 28 November 2022, the parties were directed to continue conferral for the purposes of identifying and referring questions to referees for report. That process continued under the supervision of the docket judge and culminated in orders made on 24 November 2023 by which an order was made under s 54A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) for the appointment of referees to answer certain questions in accordance with a procedure set out in a referee proposal annexed to the orders. The proceeding was re-allocated to my docket in July 2024. At a case management hearing on 14 August 2024 I made orders, by agreement between the parties, that amended the referee proposal. On 3 October 2024 Airservices filed an interlocutory application by which it sought orders, in effect, setting aside the orders made on 14 August 2024 to amend the referee proposal and for the referee proposal to be amended in terms of a document annexed to that application. On 4 November 2024 the applicant made the present application to further amend its statement of claim. On 21 November 2024 I made orders, by consent, in effect setting aside the order to amend the referee proposal and for the referee proposal to be amended in the form annexed to those orders. Although amendments were made to the questions for the toxicology referee, question 1 of the original proposal and amended proposal were both addressed to the question of whether specific PFAS are actually toxic or potentially toxic to organisms in the environment including humans. Certain other orders were made addressing potential amendments to the defence and referee proposal should the application for leave to further amend the statement of claim be granted and otherwise dismissing the respondent’s interlocutory application filed on 3 October 2024. Orders were also made to facilitate the exchange of submissions and listing of the application for leave to further amend the statement of claim.Existing issues

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Last, in substance, Airservices submits that the applicant should not be permitted to use a vague and ambiguous pleading as the foundation to instruct referees in the hope that the referees reports will identify a case that can be made to fit within the pleading. It submits that the referees must be asked to address questions that arise from the pleaded case and, therefore, the respondent would be prejudiced in the referee referral process if the amendment were permitted.Consideration The question of whether the proposed further amended statement of claim is evasive, ambiguous or contains inconsistencies is not to be answered by reference to an understanding of the existing pleading, but by reference to an understanding of the proposed pleading, read as a whole, and with a view to genuinely attempting to understand the case that the applicant wants to prosecute. With that orientation, I do not consider that the introduction of the concept of ‘potentially toxic’ creates any real ambiguity or confusion in the applicant’s proposed pleaded case. However, for the reasons already given, I accept that the proposed amendment involves the introduction of a new alternative case. The word ‘potentially’ has an ordinary meaning. I do not consider much is to be gained from analysing dictionary meanings of the word to construe the proposed pleading. The effect of para 22 and para 26 of the proposed pleading is sufficiently clear. The meaning is as I have expressed it earlier in these reasons. The relevant concept is risk and the materiality of the risk posed by PFAS. The nature of the risk may be greater and more material if PFAS are actually toxic, but if PFAS are only potentially toxic there may nonetheless be a material risk of harm. That is so whether potentially is used in the sense of possibility or in the sense of capability or latency. For similar reasons, the introduction of the concept of potential toxicity is not inconsistent with the balance of the pleading. The applicant does not plead a case in negligence that is founded on pure economic loss. As is manifestly clear from paras 22, 26, 32 and 36 of the statement of claim set out earlier in these reasons, the applicant alleges that contamination of the land with PFAS has caused physical damage to the property. To the extent that economic loss is claimed, that is consequential upon the alleged property damage. That claim is unaffected by the introduction of the potential toxicity concept. I do not accept, at least for the purposes of raising a reasonably arguable cause of action, that it is untenable that the introduction of a substance onto land that is potentially (or possibly) and not actually toxic is capable of causing physical damage to that land. It is reasonably arguable that in either case the physical state of the land is altered by the introduction of the substance onto the land. A substance that is actually toxic may require removal from the land or may result in devaluation of the land. Equally, a substance that is potentially (or possibly) toxic may require removal from the land or may result in devaluation of the land. Put another way, introduction of a substance that is potentially toxic onto land may alter the physical state of the land in a manner that is arguably not ‘harmless’.