Perry and Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

Perry and Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2021] AATA 830 (9 April 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/4042, 2020/2940

Re:David Perry

APPLICANT

Go Marine Group Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J Sosso

Date:9 April 2021

Place:Brisbane

The reviewable decisions are affirmed.

..............................[SGD]...............................

Deputy President J Sosso

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – osteoarthritis – aggravation of osteoarthritis – condition contributed to by employment – material degree test – pre-existing condition – obesity – decision affirmed

Legislation

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth)

Cases

Bailey v Broadsword Marine Contractors Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 219; (2017) 257 FCR 549

Comcare v Sahu-Khan [2007] FCA 15

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J Sosso

9 April 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr David Perry (the Applicant) seeks a review of two reviewable decisions of Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (the Respondent) made pursuant to the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (the Act) concerning the Applicant’s left knee.  Those reviewable decisions are:

    (a)a reviewable decision of 8 April 2020 (2020/2940) affirming a deemed determination made on or about 20 January 2020 – Exhibit 2 T5 p. 15, which disallowed a claim for incapacity for work, medical and related expenses in relation to aggravation of arthritis of the left knee.  The decision was made in relation to an incident which occurred in November/December 2010, and will be referred to as “the paint tins incident”; and

    (b)a reviewable decision of 31 May 2019 (2019/4042) affirming a deemed determination made on or about December 2017 – Exhibit 1 T44 p. 128, which disallowed the Applicant’s claim for incapacity for work, medical and related expenses in relation to arthritis of the left knee.  This decision was made in relation to an incident which occurred in May 2010, and will be referred to as “the grate incident”.

  2. The Applicant was born in 1965 and at the time of the Hearing was aged 55 years – Exhibit 1 T7 p. 18. From approximately 1986 the Applicant was employed as an integrated rating in the marine industry, which was essentially a labouring job – Exhibit 1 T27 p. 53, T28 p. 67. The Applicant left high school at 14 years of age and subsequently worked in various jobs involving manual labour – Exhibit 1 T28 p. 67.

  3. From the evidence before the Tribunal, it would appear that the Applicant was in the employ of the Respondent from 1 July 2008 until 7 December 2010 – Exhibit 5 R3 p. 20 para 3.2.

  4. In 1995 the Applicant was employed by ASP Ship Management and was working on the boat “CSL Innovator” which transported sugar from Australia to Indonesia. On 8 March 1995, whilst working on the ship, the Applicant slipped on a wet surface and injured his right knee – Exhibit 5 R5 p. 59.

  5. The Applicant was examined and subsequently operated on by Dr Greg Gillett, Orthopaedic Surgeon.  In his report of 11 April 1995 (the day of the operation), Dr Gillett wrote to the Applicant’s treating General…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perry and Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 830
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the applicant, Perry, against a decision of the Tribunal which affirmed earlier decisions that his employment had not materially contributed to his current left knee condition. The respondent was Go Marine Group Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on whether the applicant's employment had caused or aggravated a pre-existing condition to a material degree, thereby entitling him to compensation.

The primary legal issue before Deputy J Sosso P was to determine whether the applicant's employment contributed in a "material degree" to his current left knee condition, specifically osteoarthritis. This required the court to assess the causal link between the applicant's work activities and the aggravation of his pre-existing knee pathology, considering factors such as a previous injury and obesity.

The court's reasoning was heavily influenced by the medical evidence presented by both parties, particularly the reports of Dr Steadman and Dr Dane Andersen. Deputy J Sosso P applied the interpretation of "material degree" as an "evaluative threshold" requiring a substantial or considerable contribution, rather than a de minimis one. The court found that the weight of the medical evidence did not establish that the applicant's employment had materially contributed to his current left knee condition, despite acknowledging the applicant's submissions regarding a workplace injury in May 2010 and subsequent aggravation in November 2010.

Ultimately, the court concluded that the applicant's employment had not materially contributed to his current left knee condition. Accordingly, the reviewable decisions were affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In his Outline of Applicants Submissions (OAS), the Applicant makes the following submissions:“FACTUAL EVIDENCE35. The applicant was injured in the workplace and had surgery performed on his left knee with unrepairable injuries.36. The applicant has been disabled from this accidentCONCLUSION37. The trauma to the left knee caused by ‘the grate accident of May 2010’ has changed the pathology of the left knee which makes it compensatable [sic] under the SCR ACT38. The heavy lifting in November 2010 re-aggravated the May 2010 injury39. All these occurred before obesity was diagnosed or existent40. On any reasonable assessment the evidence establishes a material link between the accident and the injury the applicant suffers”. The Respondent relies, primarily, but not exclusively, on the diagnoses of Dr Steadman whilst the Applicant relies on the medical report of Dr Dane Andersen of the Princess Alexandra Hospital, Orthopaedic Unit which is dated 30 December 2019 – Exhibit 4. The diagnoses of both Doctors are dealt with below.Medical evidence: Dr Steadman As previously noted, the Applicant was examined and assessed by Dr Steadman in December 2012. Dr Steadman’s report, dated 18 December 2012, has been addressed above. The Applicant was further examined by Dr Steadman on 22 April 2020 and the Tribunal has been provided with his detailed report which is dated 1 May 2020 – Exhibit 5 R2 pp. 5 – 18. Dr Steadman first set out the Applicant’s injury history, which he was provided with– Exhibit 5 R2 p. 7:“He said he fell down a hole in 2010 and sustained an injury to his left knee but says the right knee was also injured around that time. He says the left knee was arthroscoped by Dr Cameron Cooke and Marine Care paid for the operation which was to manage arthritis. Dr Cooke told him that he had arthritis and he said that he returned to work. The left knee was further aggravated when he was dealing with a paint order on a boat and there were 16 litre paint drums. He was pulling them out of a special storage cupboard and passing them forward when his left knee and groin started hurting. He said that pulling them out caused pain. He did not recall any other substantial injury. He said he never really got better and the operation that Dr Cooke did never really resolved the left knee problem. He persisted with use of OxyContin.” Next, Dr Steadman carried out a file review, and made the following observations – Exhibit 5 R2 pp. 8- 9:“In my medical report dated 18.12.2012, I conclude in a summary table that he had left knee arthritis related to a previous injury in 1995. I note in retrospect that this is a typographical error as the report refers to the right knee and should not be considered to be relevant.I do however note in that report that I examined his left knee and he had a gunshot wound scar over the suprapatellar area…In a pain drawing provided on the date of that examination 11.12.2012, he indicates no discomfort in the left knee. The right knee has drawings over it in both an anterior and posterior bodily direction. His BMI at that time was noted to be 45.29…In his arthroscopy report of 03.08.2010 Dr Cook indicates changes much as the MRI with an ulcer drawn over the lateral condyle that indicates grade 3 along with a drawing on an arrow towards the medial meniscus. No patella commentary is present until he does his written operative report on the same date and indicates that there were grade 3 chondral changes over the femoral condyle and over the central aspect of the patella. He indicates a chondroplasty was performed and that synovitis in the knee was also debrided. He makes no comment regarding any meniscal pathology that was treated and but was reported on the MRI and the operative drawing does not indicate that there is any partial meniscectomy.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, the Tribunal does not accept that the Applicant’s employment has materially contributed to his current left knee condition, and this conclusion flows inexorably from the sheer weight of the medical evidence presented.CONCLUSION The reviewable decisions are affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The term “material degree” was helpfully explained by the Finn J in Comcare v Sahu-Khan [2007] FCA 15 as follows:“13. The modern approach to statutory interpretation, as is now well accepted, attributes a greater significance to context and legislative purpose than previously was the case: see CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1997) 187 CLR 384, at 408. That approach, in my respectful view, was adopted unexceptionably by French and Stone JJ in Canute in their treatment of the legislative history of the definition of "disease" in the SRC Act. I agree with what their Honours have said and, in particular, in their conclusion that the inclusion of the word "material" imposes an "evaluative threshold" below which a causal connection may be disregarded.14. What is problematic is identifying where that threshold lies. Treloar’s case set its own threshold of sorts for satisfying the 1971 Act’s "contributing factor" requirement. It would, for example, exclude a de minimis contribution or one which did not influence the course of events. But once an employment was found to be a contributing factor to the condition in question, it did not matter whether the contribution was of any particular size or degree: Treloar, at 329. It has not been uncommon for courts, in dealing with statutes requiring such a contribution to be found, to describe that contribution as "material": see eg Repatriation Commission v Bendy [1989] FCA 170; (1989) 10 AAR 323 at 325. That usage is not how the term "material" in the phrase "in a material degree" is used in the SRC Act. The legislative history of this definition makes this plain. 15. There are, in my view, obvious hazards in allowing finely nuanced differences in dictionary definitions to contrive the answer to this question, given as I have noted, that the word "material" in this context had its legislative meaning set in part by the qualification it imposed on the nature of the contribution required to be demonstrated before the provisions of the SRC Act were engaged. This said I consider that one of the meanings of the word "materially" in the Shorter Oxford English Dictionary probably captures the essence of what the legislature was conveying. That meaning is – "4. In a material degree; substantially, considerably."An example given of this usage is that of contributing "materially to the funds required" for a purpose. This usage probably comes closer to what Davies J in Bendy described (at 325) as the "loose sense" of the definition of "material" in the Macquarie dictionary "namely, ‘of substantial import or much consequence’ [rather than the] legal sense of ‘pertinent’ or ‘likely to influence’".16. Bearing in mind that the course of statutory construction is often not aided by substituting for the word used in an enactment, another word which is not so used, probably the best that can ultimately be said is that the s 4 definition: (i) requires a stronger causal relationship between the employment and the ailment, etc suffered than that exacted by the 1971 Act;(ii) "in a material degree" requires an evaluation of all relevant contributing factors for the purpose of asking whether the employee’s employment did or did not contribute materially to the suffering of the ailment, etc, in question ("the threshold evaluation");(iii) whether this will be so in a given case will be a matter of fact and degree.”CONSIDERATIONContentions of the Parties