Perry and Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Perry and Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2023] AATA 4214 (20 December 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2022/8396      

Re:David Perry

APPLICANT

Go Marine Group Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member R Bellamy

Date:20 December 2023

Place:Brisbane

The reviewable decision is affirmed.

.............................[SGD]...............................

Senior Member R Bellamy

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – aggravation of pre-existing degenerative condition –– whether temporary or ongoing aggravation – material degree test – whether employer liable for preinjury sustained in other employment – pre-existing condition – decision affirmed

Legislation

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

R v Perry [2011] QCA 236

Woodhouse v Comcare (2021) 285 FCR 14

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member R Bellamy

20 December 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr David Perry is 57 years old. He was educated to year eight and spent his entire working life on ships. He also worked as a union official between 1998 and 2007. This application concerns an injury to Mr Perry’s right knee that occurred in 2010. His right knee was first injured at work in 1995. After two operations and a period of rest, he returned to his duties, however he developed osteoarthritis in that knee. In 2010, while working for the Respondent employer, Mr Perry again injured his right knee at work. I will refer to this injury as “the 2010 injury”. There was also an injury to his left knee in 2010 but that is not relevant to this application. The contentious issue in this application is whether the 2010 injury caused only a temporary aggravation of the underlying osteoarthritis, as the Respondent contends, or whether it had an ongoing impact as Mr Perry contends.  

  2. The Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (“the Act”) provides for rehabilitation and workers’ compensation for seafarers and certain other persons.  Subsection 26(1) relevantly provides that if an employee suffers an injury that results in incapacity for work or impairment, compensation is payable for that injury. “Injury” is broadly defined but it must arise out of, or in the course of, employment.

  3. Section 8 of the Act provides that an incapacity for work is an incapacity suffered by an employee as a result of an injury, being:

    (a)  an incapacity to engage in any work; or

    (b)  an incapacity to engage in work as an employee at the same rank or level at which he or she was engaged immediately before the injury happened.

  4. Section 28 provides for, among other things, compensation for the cost of medical treatment for an injury.

  5. Section 31 of the Act effectively provides that where an employee is incapacitated for work as a result of an injury, compensation is payable to for the period of incapacity. For the first 45 weeks, compensation is payable in an amount equal to the employee’s normal weekly earnings (minus earnings in suitable employment) and thereafter, compensation is payable in an amount equal to a prescribed portion of their normal weekly earnings.

  6. Mr Perry made…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perry and Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 4214
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a claim for compensation by Mr Perry against Go Marine Group Pty Ltd. Mr Perry sought compensation for an injury to his right knee, alleging that his employment had caused or materially contributed to his ongoing incapacity. The dispute centred on whether a 2010 workplace incident constituted an injury that caused ongoing incapacity or aggravated a pre-existing condition to a material degree, thereby entitling him to compensation. The decision was made by Senior Member R Bellamy.

The legal issues before the court were whether Mr Perry's right knee condition constituted an "injury" as defined by the relevant legislation, and specifically, whether the 2010 incident caused ongoing incapacity or materially aggravated a pre-existing degenerative condition. The court was required to determine if the employment contributed to the ailment in a material degree and whether that contribution continued to be a factor in Mr Perry's ongoing condition.

Senior Member Bellamy considered the medical evidence, including reports from orthopaedic surgeons Dr Greg Gillett and Dr Cameron Cooke, and Professor Steadman. The court noted that Mr Perry had a pre-existing degenerative condition in his right knee, which had been surgically treated following an incident in 1995. The 2010 incident involved soft tissue damage. The court applied the definition of "injury" under the Act, which includes an aggravation of a physical injury that arose out of, or in the course of, employment, and that an aggravation of a pre-existing condition could be considered a "disease" if contributed to in a material degree by employment. Drawing on the principles from *Woodhouse v Comcare*, the court emphasised that for liability to continue, the ailment must remain an "injury" and owe its existence to the material contribution of employment, not merely factors unconnected to it.

Ultimately, the court was not satisfied that the 2010 injury materially contributed to Mr Perry's ongoing right knee condition in June 2012 or thereafter. While acknowledging that the 2010 incident caused temporary soft tissue damage, the court found that it did not accelerate the progression of the underlying degenerative condition. Consequently, the reviewable decision was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, references in these reasons to an injury arising from, or in the course of, or that was materially contributed to by, Mr Perry’s employment are references to his employment with the Respondent, and not to any previous employment. THE MEDICAL EVIDENCE From around 1986 Mr Perry was employed as an Integrated Rating in the marine industry, which was essentially a labouring job. There is no evidence that he had any problem with his right knee before an incident on 8 March 1995 where he slipped on a wet surface and his right knee twisted and gave way. At the time, he was employed by ASP Ship Management. Mr Perry was examined by Dr Greg Gillett, Orthopaedic Surgeon. Dr Gillet performed a medial meniscectomy for a displaced bucket handle tear. He wrote a report on the day of the operation, 11 April 1995, to Mr Perry’s treating General Practitioner.[10] In that report, he said: “I have arthroscoped David’s knee today. The findings were that he had a displaced bucket handled tear of his medial meniscus. The medial collateral ligament is stable. The anterior cruciate ligament clinically reveals one plus drawer and a negative pivot shift but it is ruptured on the arthroscopic examination. The lateral side is normal and the patello-femoral joint is normal.The displaced bucket handle has been arthroscopically excised.He will now undertake a rehabilitation programme and in the longer term may require a cruciate ligament reconstruction but I would be optimistic that he won’t and he will do well with an exercise programme.”[10] Exhibit T1: Section 37 T-Documents T5. A few months after the medial meniscectomy, Mr Perry had an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. According to Mr Perry, he had nine months off work before returning as a full-time Integrated Rating. There is some evidence of ongoing symptoms in his right knee. On 12 February 2010, nine months before the injury, Mr Perry was examined and assessed for permanent impairment by Dr Cameron Cooke, Orthopaedic Surgeon. Mr Perry said that was for the purpose of getting mortgage insurance, although he could not explain why the report was addressed to the “Registrar of the Supreme Court/District Court”. Dr Cooke’s report[11] contained the following:[11] Exhibit T1: Section 37 T-Documents T7.“Mr Perry reports that since the injury and subsequent surgery, he has been unable to fully extend his knee. He describes start up pain within the knee joint particularly on the medial side. He states that if he is working on a ship when the sea is rough, he will experience pain in his knee the following day. He finds that uneven ground also causes medial pain. He has not experienced any locking. He has not experienced any ongoing instability within the knee.Current TreatmentsMr Perry takes Panadol Osteo for his leg symptoms.…Work Activity LimitationsMr Perry reports that he is unable to crawl into small spaces when at work. He has difficulty walking sideways. He reports knee discomfort when the sea is rough.Daily Living and Recreational limitationsMr Perry reports that stairs cause him discomfort and he has trouble negotiating these in a regular manner. He finds that mowing the lawn and using the whipper snipper causes discomfort.Physical Examination…He mobilised with a normal gait. There was a flexed attitude to the right knee…There was a fixed flexion deformity of 5°. Active flexion was to 120°. Diagnostic InvestigationsPlain radiographs performed on 15/06/2009 show mild tricompartmental osteoarthritis with a degree of narrowing of the medial fibiofemoral articulation.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the evidence does not all fit neatly together to fully explain what happened with respect to Mr Perry’s knee, on balance, I am inclined to accept that the 2010 injury caused soft tissue damage over the top of the underlying degenerative condition, but it did not accelerate the progression of that condition. It is impossible to know when the soft tissue damage healed because Mr Perry’s right knee was not assessed between March 2011 and December 2012. Dr Cooke hoped it would resolve in a matter of months. Professor Steadman thought it should have resolved within six weeks. However, Dr Cooke physically examined Mr Perry shortly following the injury and he had an X-ray and MRI to assist him, so I prefer his opinion. I am satisfied that the effects of the 2010 injury lasted several months. I do not, however think the medical evidence goes as far as establishing, on balance, that the effects lasted to June 2012 and beyond. CONCLUSION I am not satisfied that in June 2012 or any time after that, the 2010 injury was a factor that materially contributed to Mr Perry’s ongoing right knee condition. The reviewable decision is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

According to Mr Perry, he has not been employed since the injury because he is no longer fit to work at sea and he had not been able to secure alternative employment. He said that prior to the injury his right knee was in manageable shape and he could work. He described the injury as a watershed moment where his knee took a turn for the worse, he has not been able to work since, and his knee has never been the same since. He was unwilling to accept that he was overweight and that his weight could be a contributing factor to the condition of his right knee. At times, he accepted that his current condition was a consequence of the 1995 incident. CONSIDERATION As stated above, Mr Perry’s entitlement to lost wages for any period after 1 June 2012 depends on him being unable to work in that period due to an injury arising out of, or in the course of, his employment. Under section 3 of the act “Injury” is defined to mean:(a) a disease; or(b) an injury; or (c) an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee being an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment. To find in Mr Perry’s favour, I would have to find that the 2010 injury itself caused ongoing incapacity or that the 2010 injury aggravated the pre-existing osteoarthritis. An aggravation of the pre-existing condition would suffice because the definition of “disease” includes an “ailment or an aggravation that was contributed to in a material degree by the employee's employment”. “Ailment” is defined to mean “any physical or mental ailment, disorder, defect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development)”. The pre-existing condition, as it is described by Professor Steadman, meets the definition of “ailment” and an aggravation of it meets the definition of “disease”. The case of Woodhouse v Comcare (2021) 285 FCR 14 concerned liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“SRC Act”). In that case, the Full Court of the Federal Court said, in relation to the equivalent section in the SRC Act: “Section 14 only imposes liability on Comcare where, amongst other things, the ailment in respect of which the claim is made remains an “injury”. In the case of an ailment said to constitute an “injury” on the basis that it is a “disease”, the ailment must be one which continues to owe its existence to the contribution to, in a material degree, the employee’s employment. (For the avoidance of doubt, this does not require causation in the sense of a “but for” test: Comcare v Canute [2005] FCAFC 262; (2005) 148 FCR 232 [67]). In those unusual cases, such as the present, where the disease persists but only by reason of factors unconnected to the contribution of the employment, Comcare’s liability will have ceased. Conversely, the applicant’s preferred construction should be rejected. Comcare has no liability under s 14 in relation to an ailment, the continued existence of which can no longer be said to have the necessary causal connection to the employee’s employment. The mere fact that the ailment suffered may once have had the necessary connection is irrelevant. Even where the ailment continues unabated, if it ceases to have the characteristic of being one which was relevantly contributed to by the employee’s employment, Comcare’s liability ceases.[20] (Underlining added)[20] [89]-[90].