Perren v Nambour Bowls Club Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Perren v Nambour Bowls Club Inc [2018] QSC 148

PARTIES:

ROBYN DENISE PERREN

(applicant)

v
NAMBOUR BOWLS CLUB INC IA13109

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 3360 of 2018

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

26 June 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 April 2018

JUDGE:

Brown J

ORDER:

The Court declares that:

1. The decision made by the respondent on 23 February 2017 to terminate the applicant’s membership was unauthorised by the respondent’s Constitution and was void.

2.   Further, that in determining that it should terminate the applicant’s membership on 23 February 2017 the respondent denied the applicant natural justice.

And the Court orders that:

3.   The first to fourth decisions of the respondent be set aside.

4.   The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

CATCHWORDS:

ASSOCIATIONS AND CLUBS – GENERAL MATTERS – CONSTITUTION – where the applicant applies for declaratory relief pursuant to s 73 of the Associations Incorporation Act 1981 (Qld) – where the applicant was a member of the respondent Club – where the respondent decided: to terminate the applicant as a member; to refuse the applicant’s request for membership; to refuse the applicant’s appeal from respondent’s decision to deny her membership through a general meeting – where the respondent further decided to prohibit the applicant access to the respondent’s premises as visitor from another Club – where the applicant contends that the decision to terminate the applicant’s membership was in breach of the respondent’s Constitution – where the applicant contends the respondent failed to accord her natural justice – whether the decisions of the respondent are void – whether orders should be made

Associations Incorporation Act 1981 (Qld) s 71, s 72(2), s 73

Gould v Isis Club Incorporated [2015] QSC 253

Petersen v Proserpine Golf Club Inc [2018] QSC 71

COUNSEL:

P Hackett for the applicant

G Barr for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Beckhaus Legal for the applicant

Butler McDermott for the respondent

  1. The applicant, Mrs Perren, was a member of the respondent, the Nambour Bowls Club (the Club), since August 2013.  Her husband is and has been a member of the club for 20 years.  Mrs Perren held various positions with the Club including on its governing body, the Management Committee, up until December 2016.  On 23 February 2017, she was advised by the Club that the Board did not recognise either Mrs Perren or her husband as members as they had not paid annual fees said to be due on 31 December 2016 (sic) (the first decision).  Mrs Perren and her husband then re-applied for membership of the Club.  Mrs Perren was refused membership on 2 March 2017 (the second decision).  An appeal against that decision made to the general meeting of the Club failed on 7 April 2017 (the third decision).  Mrs Perren and her husband subsequently became members of the Maroochy Bowls Club, which shares reciprocal rights with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perren v Nambour Bowls Club Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Perren v Nambour Bowls Club Inc involved the applicant, Mrs Perren, who sought declaratory relief against the respondent, Nambour Bowls Club Inc, under section 73 of the Associations Incorporation Act 1981 (Qld). Mrs Perren, a former member of the Club, was contesting several decisions made by the Club, including the termination of her membership, the refusal of her request for membership, the refusal of her appeal against the denial of membership, and the prohibition of her access to the Club’s premises as a visitor from another club. Mrs Perren argued that the Club’s decisions were in breach of the Club’s Constitution and that the Club failed to accord her natural justice. The central legal issues before the court were whether the Club’s decisions were void due to their incompatibility with the Club’s Constitution and whether the Club's actions denied Mrs Perren natural justice.

The court examined the Club’s Constitution and found that the decision to terminate Mrs Perren’s membership was not authorised by the Constitution. Additionally, the court found that the Club’s process in terminating Mrs Perren’s membership failed to provide her with procedural fairness, thus denying her natural justice. The court held that the Club's failure to follow its own Constitution and to provide natural justice rendered the decisions void. Consequently, the court set aside the first to fourth decisions of the Club and ordered that the Club pay Mrs Perren’s costs of the application. This decision underscored the importance of adherence to a club’s Constitution and the necessity of providing natural justice in disciplinary proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Court declares that:

1. The decision made by the respondent on 23 February 2017 to terminate the applicant’s membership was unauthorised by the respondent’s Constitution and was void.

2. Further, that in determining that it should terminate the applicant’s membership on 23 February 2017 the respondent denied the applicant natural justice.

And the Court orders that:

3. The first to fourth decisions of the respondent be set aside.

4. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The powers of the Supreme Court upon hearing such an application to grant relief as appropriate in circumstances are outlined in s 73 of the Act. Circumstances leading to first decision Relevantly, on 23 December 2016, Mrs Perren received an email from the Club with the subject “Membership Payments for 2017”. No invoice was attached. What was described as membership payment advice for 2017 was in the following terms: “Subscription Notice to all Members. Please note that payment for all dues can be made by Direct Credit to our bank account at Heritage using the following information: …The full fees are $85.00 for the year. … You may also pay by Cheque, cash or use Eftpos at the Club. … If you have already paid, please disregard this message. As the earlier message stated, we must know your intentions before the end of the year, so this can be sent to Bowls Queensland for their records. …” The notice was attributed to Ray Capper, Secretary, Nambour Bowls Club. There is no evidence of any earlier email or message having been sent to Mrs Perren and she denies having received an earlier email. I accept that to be the case. On 8 February 2017, Mrs Perren sent an email to the Club which was addressed to the Board stating, inter alia, that after having made contact with a number of the men from the Club when her husband was playing bowls at Coolum: “…It made us both think that we need renew (sic) those friendships and get back into playing bowls in the open pairs on Wednesday afternoon. It will be necessary to pay our memberships fees for 2017 - $170 for both of us. I have done a direct deposit into the club’s bank account for the following: ·Refer to my email that I sent into the Club on 10 November (see below) where I advised that the Club owed us $74 for green fees that we had paid for bowls on Scorpio Day ($50) and then on Wednesday 9 November 2 bowl triples ($24). On both of these days we had arrived at the Club not registered to play but due to numbers being down and players not turning up we played in both these events. You will see in my previous email (10 November) I raised this with the then Chairman – Brian Flux that as the precedent had previously been set by the Club, members had been exempt from paying green fees when they filled in at short notice. Therefore I can see no reason why we cannot be afforded the same and requested that we be reimbursed our $74. I did point out that both Wayne Doran and Robert Combes should also be reimbursed $25 each as they also filled in at short notice on Scorpio Day. Extract from my email 10 November – After receiving such criticism today, my understanding is that it appears to be Club policy that when you fill in at short notice to make up teams there is no necessity to pay green fees. Therefore I would like to receive money from the Club $50 for Scorpio Day and $24 for yesterday Wed Triples. Also Robert Combes and Wayne Doran will also need to receive $25 each. As this precedent was set on one of the Mixed Pairs days when Ralph, Marty and Ron Abraham filled in and paid no green fees, I see no reason why we cannot be afforded the same. To this date I have received no response or reimbursement for these green fees. Therefore you will see that the membership fees that I am paying is $170 less $74, that is $96 is being paid as a direct deposit into the Club’s bank account. I should also point out that after we played on Scorpio Day, Macca (Peter McNaughton) had commented that we weren’t required to pay our green fees for the event. However at the time no one refunded us any money. Written confirmation to this email would be appreciated.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established