Perpetual Trustee Company (Limited) v Tindal

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read
63 CLR 232

THE PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY

TINDAL AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS. DEFENDANTS,

THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE AND ANOTHER

DEFENDANTS,

THE PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY

(LIMITED) AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS.

PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANTS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES.

OF A. Insurance-Life-Policy - effected by husband on his life-Expressed to be for benefit

of named wife-Gift over to named son in event of wife predeceasing husband- Wife and son predeceasing husband-Son' absolute interest-Failure of trusts- Power of appointment reserved by assured-Non-exercise of power-Proceeds of April 5, 8;

policy-DistributionLife, Fire and Marine Insurance Act 1902 (N.S.W.) (No. 49 of 1902), secs. 8-10. High Court-AppealDivision - of opinion-Majority for allowing appeal but not for

any particular order-Judiciary Act 1903-1939 (No. 6 of 1903-No. 43 of 1939), sec. 23 (2).

Secs. 8-10 of the Life, Fire and Marine Insurance Act 1902 (N.S.W.) do not contain anything which makes survival of the assured a condition attaching to any interest given to a wife, or husband, or children by a policy effected under the legislation.

63 CLR 233

A life-assurance policy described the persons to whom the policy moneys were payable as "the wife of the person assured if she shall survive the person assured-if she shall predecease the person assured-his son, B." The wife predeceased the assured. The son predeceased both the wife and the assured

Held that the interest of B in the policy moneys was not contingent on his surviving his father or his mother and became absolute on the death of his mother: therefore the policy moneys were payable to the personal repre-

Cousins v. Sun Life Assurance Society, (1933) Ch. 126, followed. Decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Nicholas C.J. in Eq.), on this point, affirmed.

A policy of assurance effected by a husband on his life provided that

subject to the provisions of the Life, Fire and Marine Insurance Act 1902 (N.S.W.), and shall be payable as follows, namely :-(a) to the beneficiary A (wife of the assured should she become his widow absolutely

(b) failing which to B son of the assured (if he survive and attain the age of twenty-one) or to such other children of the assured as the assured may by way of substitution appoint." Four the children of the marriage, B, C, D and E, were alive at the date of the policy. The wife and all the children except E predeceased the assured. B attained the age of twenty-one years but predeceased the wife and the assured, who did not appoint any of his other children in substitution for B.

63 CLR 234

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

On 3rd May 1916 Charles Frederick Tindal of " Bona Vista," Armidale, grazier, effected a life policy on his own life with the Co. (LTD.)

National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Ltd. for the sum of five thousand pounds payable at death. The policy provided, inter alia, that if the annual premiums were duly paid the associa-…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trustee Company (Limited) v Tindal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1940] HCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Perpetual Trustee Company (Limited) v Tindal* concerned the distribution of proceeds from two life insurance policies effected by Charles Frederick Tindal. The primary dispute involved determining the entitlement to these proceeds, particularly when the named beneficiaries, including the assured's wife and a son, predeceased him. The matter came before the High Court of Australia on appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The legal issues before the court were twofold. Firstly, it had to determine whether the interest of a named beneficiary in a life insurance policy, under the *Life, Fire and Marine Insurance Act 1902* (NSW), was contingent on surviving the assured, even if the policy wording did not explicitly state this. Secondly, the court was required to interpret the specific terms of the second policy, which included a provision for a son "if he survive and attain the age of twenty-one" or for "such other children of the assured as the assured may by way of substitution appoint," and to ascertain the entitlement to the proceeds in light of the assured's wife and son predeceasing him, and the non-exercise of the power of appointment.

The High Court, in a majority decision, affirmed the Supreme Court's finding regarding the first policy, holding that the interest of the son, Charles Henry Tindal, was not contingent on surviving the assured. The court applied the principle established in *Cousins v. Sun Life Assurance Society*, which held that under similar legislation, a named beneficiary's interest vests upon the occurrence of the specified event (in this case, the wife predeceasing the assured), and does not require survival of the assured unless expressly stipulated. Regarding the second policy, the court found that the condition "if he survive and attain the age of twenty-one" for Charles Henry Tindal meant surviving the event that prevented the primary beneficiary (the wife) from taking. As Charles Henry Tindal had predeceased the assured, he did not fulfil this condition. Consequently, the power of substitution for "other children" was considered, and in the absence of its exercise, the court determined that the proceeds were to be distributed amongst the children who were alive at the time of the policy's inception, subject to the terms of the Act.

The High Court ultimately allowed the appeal in part. For the first policy, the proceeds were held to be payable to the estate of the predeceased son, Charles Henry Tindal. However, for the second policy, the court found that Charles Henry Tindal had not satisfied the survivorship condition. The court then considered the power of appointment for "other children," which had not been exercised. Applying section 10 of the *Life, Fire and Marine Insurance Act 1902* (NSW), which provides for equal shares to children in default of appointment, the court determined that the proceeds of the second policy were to be divided equally amongst all the children of the assured who were alive at the time the policy was effected, including the surviving son, Arthur Willoughby Tindal, and the estates of the predeceased sons.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.