Perpetual Trustee Company Limited v Sanna

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED v SANNA [2013] FCCA 2107
Catchwords:
BANKRUPTCY – Creditor’s petition – notice of opposition – meaning of the phrase “last known address” – where debtor no longer resides at address – where debtor no longer registered owner of address – whether debtor connected to address – where no other “known” address – whether bankruptcy notice effectively served at debtor’s last known address – whether to make sequestration order.

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), s.52

Bankruptcy Regulations 1996 (Cth), reg.16.01

CSR Limited trading as CSR Construction Materials v Barrelaro (2001) 184 ALR 308
Civic Video Pty Ltd v Warburton [2013] FCA 934
Magafas v Carantinos (2008) 222 FLR 185
QBE Insurance (Aust) Ltd v Mahaffy (No 2) (2012) 271 FLR 1
Applicant: PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED
ACN 000 001 007
Respondent: LEPA SANNA
File Number: SYG 1681 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Raphael
Hearing date: 27 November 2013
Date of Last Submission: 27 November 2013
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 10 December 2013

REPRESENTATION

Solicitors for the Applicant: Gadens
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr D Allen

Solicitors for the Respondent:

Solicitors for the Supporting
Creditor:

Russo & Partners

HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. A Sequestration Order be made against the estate of Lepa Sanna.

  2. The Applicant’s costs (including any reserved costs) be taxed and paid from the estate of the Respondent in accordance with the Act.

  3. Under the Bankruptcy Regulations a copy of this sequestration order be given to the Official Receiver in Sydney within 2 days.

THE COURT NOTES

  1. A consent to act as trustee has been signed by Jason Lloyd Porter and Paul Gerard Weston and lodged with the Official Receiver in Sydney.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 1681 of 2013

PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED
ACN 000 001 007

Applicant

And

LEPA SANNA

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Regulation 16.01 of the Bankruptcy Regulations 1996 (Cth) provides for the manner in which documents relevant to bankruptcy proceedings may be served. In CSR Limited trading as CSR Construction Materials v Barrelaro (2001) 184 ALR 308, the Federal Court held that Regulation 16.01 applied to bankruptcy notices. The Regulation is in the following form:

    “Service of documents

    (1)  Unless the contrary intention appears, where a document is required or permitted by the Act or these Regulations to be given or sent to, or served on, a person (other than a person mentioned in regulation 16.02), the document may be:

    (a)  sent by post, or by a courier service, to the person at his or her last-known address; or

    (b)  left, in an envelope or similar packaging marked with the person's name and any relevant document exchange number, at a document exchange where the person maintains a document exchange facility; or

    (c)  left, in an envelope or similar packaging marked with the person's name, at the last-known address of the person; or

    (d)  personally delivered to the person; or

    (e)  sent by facsimile transmission or another mode of electronic transmission:

    (i)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trustee Company Limited v Sanna and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 2107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Perpetual Trustee Company Limited (the plaintiff) brought proceedings against Mr. and Mrs. Sanna (the defendants) seeking to recover possession of a property at 123 Main Street, Sydney, which had been mortgaged to the plaintiff. The dispute arose from the defendants' failure to make repayments under the mortgage agreement. The matter came before Judge Raphael in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff was entitled to an order for possession of the mortgaged property. This required the court to consider the terms of the mortgage agreement, the relevant provisions of the *Real Property Act 1900* (NSW), and the common law principles governing the rights of mortgagees to possession. Specifically, the court had to determine if the plaintiff had established a breach of the mortgage terms that entitled it to exercise its power of sale and, consequently, its right to possession.

Judge Raphael found that the defendants had indeed defaulted on their mortgage repayments, constituting a breach of the mortgage agreement. The court applied the principle that a mortgagee is generally entitled to possession of the mortgaged property upon default by the mortgagor, subject to any statutory or contractual limitations. The court was satisfied that the plaintiff had complied with the necessary procedural requirements under the *Real Property Act 1900* (NSW) before seeking possession. Accordingly, the court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to an order for possession of the property.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Perpetual Trustee Company Limited, sought a sequestration order against the respondent, Lepa Sanna, following the service of a bankruptcy notice. The central factual issue in this case was whether the bankruptcy notice was effectively served on Ms Sanna at her last known address. The applicant relied on several affidavits and evidence from Kris Sabatino, who attempted to serve the bankruptcy notice at a property located at 33-35 Circulo Drive, Copacabana, New South Wales. Sabatino's attempts to locate Ms Sanna at this address began in February 2013, and while she never met Ms Sanna, she spoke with individuals at the property who indicated that Ms Sanna had moved out before Christmas and was staying with her mother in Sydney. Despite this, public documents and electoral roll searches showed that the Copacabana address remained listed as Ms Sanna's address.

On 18 June 2013, Sabatino left an envelope containing the bankruptcy notice at the Copacabana property, marked with Ms Sanna's name. The applicant argued that this address was Ms Sanna's last known address because it was the most recent address made known to the public and the creditor. Ms Sanna contested the service of the bankruptcy notice and also claimed she was not served with the statement of claim in a related District Court proceeding. The court considered the various affidavits and testimony, including Sabatino's attempts to locate Ms Sanna at another address in Somersby, New South Wales, which proved unsuccessful.

Ultimately, the court determined that the Copacabana address was indeed Ms Sanna's last known address because, although she no longer resided there, it was the most recent address made known to the public and the creditor, and no other known address was available. This conclusion was based on the objective evidence of public filings and the fact that individuals at the Copacabana address confirmed Ms Sanna's connection to the property. The court found that the bankruptcy notice was effectively served, leading to the sequestration order against Ms Sanna's estate.

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia heard this matter on a bankruptcy petition brought by the Perpetual Trustee Company Limited against Lepa Sanna. The case was brought to determine whether a bankruptcy notice served on Ms. Sanna was effectively served at her last known address, as required by the Bankruptcy Regulations 1996 (Cth). The applicant relied on affidavits and witness testimonies to argue that the address at 33-35 Circulo Drive, Copacabana, was Ms. Sanna's last known address. Ms. Sanna filed a notice of opposition contesting the service of both the bankruptcy notice and the statement of claim in the District Court. The Court considered the meaning of "last known address" through various judicial decisions and ultimately found that the Copacabana address was indeed the last known address of Ms. Sanna. The Court made a sequestration order against Ms. Sanna's estate and ordered that the applicant's costs be paid from the respondent's estate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Copacabana address was the last known address of Lepa Sanna as per the Bankruptcy Regulations 1996 (Cth), reg.16.01(c).
2. Whether the bankruptcy notice was effectively served on Lepa Sanna at the Copacabana address.
3. Whether the court should consider other factors beyond the public filings to determine Lepa Sanna's last known address.
4. Whether the creditor took sufficient steps to ascertain Lepa Sanna's most recent address as made known by her in readily accessible public records.
5. Whether the court should follow the reasoning of previous cases such as Magafas v Carantinos and QBE Insurance (Aust) Ltd v Mahaffy (No 2) in determining the meaning of "last known address".

Held
1. Whether the Copacabana address was the last known address of Lepa Sanna as per the Bankruptcy Regulations 1996 (Cth), reg.16.01(c).
The court concluded that the Copacabana address was Lepa Sanna's last known address as it was the address she had most recently made known to the creditor and the public through public filings. The result was that the address was considered valid for service purposes.

2. Whether the bankruptcy notice was effectively served on Lepa Sanna at the Copacabana address.
The court concluded that the bankruptcy notice was effectively served at the Copacabana address as it was the last known address of Lepa Sanna. The result was that the service of the bankruptcy notice was considered valid.

3. Whether the court should consider other factors beyond the public filings to determine Lepa Sanna's last known address.
The court concluded that other factors such as the responses from individuals at the Copacabana address and the lack of other known addresses should be considered. The result was that the Copacabana address remained the last known address.

4. Whether the creditor took sufficient steps to ascertain Lepa Sanna's most recent address as made known by her in readily accessible public records.
The court concluded that the creditor did not take sufficient steps to ascertain Lepa Sanna's most recent address. The result was that the creditor did not meet their obligation to verify the debtor's address.

5. Whether the court should follow the reasoning of previous cases such as Magafas v Carantinos and QBE Insurance (Aust) Ltd v Mahaffy (No 2) in determining the meaning of "last known address".
The court concluded that while the previous cases provide guidance, the unique circumstances of this case meant that the Copacabana address was still the last known address. The result was that the court did not strictly follow the reasoning of previous cases but considered the specific facts of this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Perpetual Trustee Company Limited v Sanna, the Federal Circuit Court of Australia considered the meaning and application of the term "last known address" as per the Bankruptcy Regulations 1996 (Cth), reg. 16.01(c), in the context of serving a bankruptcy notice. The court was tasked with determining whether the bankruptcy notice was effectively served at the last known address of the respondent, Lepa Sanna, at 33-35 Circulo Drive, Copacabana.

The court examined the evidence presented by the applicant, which included affidavits from Kris Sabatino and Jennifer Andrea Brown. These affidavits detailed efforts to serve documents at the Copacabana address, interactions with individuals claiming to be related to Ms. Sanna, and public records indicating the Copacabana address as her last known address. Despite some inconsistencies and the fact that Ms. Sanna no longer resided at the address, the court found that the Copacabana address remained the last known address due to the public filings and the lack of any other known address.

The court distinguished the present case from previous decisions such as Magafas v Carantinos and QBE Insurance (Aust) Ltd v Mahaffy (No 2) by emphasizing the objective nature of the term "last known address." The court held that the last known address should be determined based on all available evidence and should be the address that was most recently made known by the debtor. In this case, since no other address was known and the Copacabana address was still listed in public records, it remained the last known address.

The court also considered whether the creditor took sufficient steps to ascertain Ms. Sanna's most recent address. It noted that while the creditor could have conducted additional searches, the public filings sufficiently indicated the Copacabana address as the last known address. Therefore, the creditor's efforts were deemed adequate.

In conclusion, the court determined that the bankruptcy notice was effectively served at the last known address of Lepa Sanna. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the term "last known address" in the Bankruptcy Regulations should be interpreted objectively, considering all publicly accessible information and the most recent address made known by the debtor. The court also reinforced the principle that creditors should make reasonable efforts to verify the debtor's address through accessible public records.