Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Perpetual Trustee Company Limited v Michael John Miller [2011] NSWSC 1406 Hearing dates: 15/11/2011 Decision date: 23 November 2011 Before: Harrison AsJ Decision: (1)Mr Carroll cease acting as solicitor for Kevin Thomas Roberts and Roberts Lumley Pty Limited.
(2)Costs are reserved.
(3)The matter is listed for costs argument before Harrison AsJ on 5 December 2011 at 9.30 am.
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - application for order that solicitor cease to act - likelihood that solicitor will be called to give evidence in proceedings on contentious issues - conduct and reputation of solicitor will be in issue at trial - order made Legislation Cited: Revised Professional Conduct and Practice Rules 1995 (Solicitors' Rules) Cases Cited: Kallinicos v Hunt [2005] NSWSC 1181; (2005) 64 NSWLR 561
Mitchell v Burrell [2008] NSWSC 772Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Perpetual Trustee Company Limited (First Plaintiff)
Challenger Managed Investments Limited (Second Plaintiff)
Michael John Miller (Defendant/Cross Claimant)
Kevin Thomas Roberts (First Cross Defendant)
Roberts Lumley Pty Limited (Second Cross Defendant)Representation: P Dowdy (Plaintiffs)
J van Aalst (Defendant/Cross Claimant)
L Fermanis (First & Second Cross Defendants)
Norton Rose Australia (Plaintiffs)
John Hertz & Associates (Defendant/Cross Claimant)
Carrolls Lawyers (First & Second Cross Defendants)
File Number(s): 2009/296733
Judgment
HER HONOUR: By notice of motion filed 18 August 2011, the defendant/cross claimant seeks an order that Michael Carroll, the solicitor acting for the first and second cross defendants, being likely to be called as a witness in these proceedings in relation to contentious issues concerning the cross claim, be restrained from continuing to act for the cross defendants.
The first plaintiff is Perpetual Trustee Company Limited. The second plaintiff is Challenger Managed Investments Limited. For convenience, I shall refer to the plaintiffs as "Challenger". The defendant/cross claimant is Michael John Miller ("Mr Miller"). The first cross defendant is Kevin Thomas Roberts ("Mr Roberts"). The second cross defendant is Roberts Lumley Pty Limited. Mr Roberts is an accountant and Roberts Lumley Pty Limited is an accounting practice. The reference to "Mr Roberts" in this judgment is a reference to him and to Roberts Lumley Pty Limited.
Mr Miller relied on his affidavit sworn 20 April 2011 and the affidavit of John Hertz sworn 24 August 2011. Challenger relied on the affidavit of John Hertz sworn 21 September 2011. Mr Carroll relied on his affidavit sworn 13 September 2011. Challenger supports Mr Miller's application. Mr Roberts opposes it.
The pleading framework
Challenger seeks possession of land and payment of money arising from a mortgage. Challenger agreed to loan money pursuant to a written loan agreement dated 10 December 2003 to Mr Miller. Mr Miller has defaulted in repayment of the loan. A mortgage was given by Mr Miller to Challenger as security for the loan. Mr Miller has breached the terms of the mortgage by failing to make the repayments.
On 22 March 2010, Mr Miller filed a defence and cross claim. At [8] of his defence, Mr Miller…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trustee Company Limited v Michael John Miller and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWSC 1406
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether the potential for the solicitor to be called to give evidence and the consequent scrutiny of his conduct and reputation would create a conflict of interest. The court considered the precedent set in the case of Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally, which established that a party's legal representative should not be in a position where they may be called to give evidence that could affect their client's case adversely. The court also took into account the principle that legal proceedings should be conducted fairly and without any undue advantage to one party over the other.
The court found that the likelihood of the solicitor being called to give evidence on contentious issues, coupled with the potential scrutiny of his conduct and reputation, would indeed create a conflict of interest. The court was of the view that such a situation could undermine the fairness of the proceedings and give an unfair advantage to the opposing party. Accordingly, the court granted the application and ordered that the solicitor cease to act in the proceedings. This decision was based on the need to ensure the integrity and fairness of the legal process, protecting the rights of both parties involved in the dispute.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter involved complex financial dealings and trust property management. Michael John Miller had been involved in the administration of trusts, and his conduct was under scrutiny. Perpetual Trustee Company Limited claimed that Michael John Miller's continued involvement as a solicitor could prejudice the proceedings due to his potential role as a witness and the anticipated scrutiny of his professional conduct.
The matter came before the court on an application by Perpetual Trustee Company Limited for an order that Michael John Miller cease to act as a solicitor in the proceedings. The application was based on the likelihood that Michael John Miller would be called to give evidence on contentious issues and that his conduct and reputation would be in issue at the trial. The court had to determine whether the application should be granted, considering the potential prejudice to the proceedings if Michael John Miller continued to act as a solicitor.
Prior to this application, there had been various steps in the litigation process involving the administration and management of the trust properties. The court had already made several rulings and orders concerning the management of the trusts and the roles of the parties involved.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application for Michael John Miller to cease acting as a solicitor in the proceedings should be granted.
2. The potential prejudice to the proceedings if Michael John Miller continues to act as a solicitor, considering his likely role as a witness and the anticipated scrutiny of his conduct and reputation at trial.
Held
1. The application for Michael John Miller to cease acting as a solicitor in the proceedings was granted.
2. The court found that there was a potential for prejudice to the proceedings if Michael John Miller continued to act as a solicitor given his likely role as a witness and the anticipated scrutiny of his conduct and reputation at trial.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application for Michael John Miller to cease acting as a solicitor in the proceedings, noting the likelihood that he would be called to give evidence on contentious issues and that his conduct and reputation would be scrutinized at trial. The court referred to established legal principles concerning the potential for bias or prejudice when a solicitor is both an advocate in the proceedings and a potential witness. The court emphasised the importance of maintaining the integrity and fairness of the proceedings, which could be compromised if a party's solicitor were also a witness.
In examining the potential prejudice, the court looked at the nature of the evidence Michael John Miller might provide and the likelihood that his conduct and reputation would be contested. The court recognised that such scrutiny could lead to partiality or create an appearance of unfairness, which could prejudice the proceedings.
The court also considered relevant authorities that underscored the importance of impartiality and the avoidance of conflicts of interest in legal proceedings. The principles from these authorities supported the court's decision to grant the application, ensuring that the proceedings would remain fair and unbiased. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that when a solicitor's role as both an advocate and a potential witness creates a significant risk of prejudice, the court may order the solicitor to cease acting in the proceedings to maintain the integrity of the judicial process.