Perpetual Trustee Co (Ltd) v Pacific Coal Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
93 CLR 479

Mines and Minerals-Coal-Fixed rent plus royalty-Calculation of royalty-

Provision prescribed in lease-Arrears-Claim-Royalty a form of rent- Reduction-Statutory provisions applicable-National Security (Prices) Regu- lations (made under the National Security Act 1939-1940 (Cth.)), regs. 3, 23 (2)- Prices Regulation Order No. 985, par. 2 (c)-Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1932-1947 (N.S.W.), 8. 15 (1). Mines and Minerals-Landlord and tenant-Emergency legislation- Service "

" Right or privilege "___" Royalty

By reg. 3 of the National Security (Prices) Regulations, made under the National Security Act 1939-1940 (Cth.), it was provided "In these regula-

(b) any rights or privileges for which remuneration is payable in the form of royalty value of goods produced".

Regulation 23 (2) empowered the Commonwealth Prices Commissioner to "fix and declare the maximum rate at which any declared service may be supplied

, and by par. (2) of the Prices Regulation Order No. 985 made by the commissioner on 18th March 1943, it was provided: " I fix and declare the maximum rates per ton of coal mined at which mining rights may be supplied in respect of coal mined from the classes of mining properties men- tioned hereunder to be

(c) properties not subject to Crown lease which were privately leased on August 31 1939-the amount per ton of coal mined payable on 31st August 1939."

The Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1932-1947 (N.S.W.), which was in force on 31st August 1939, provided, inter alia, for a reduction by twenty-two and one-half per cent of "rent reserved by or under any lease " to which the Act applied.

93 CLR 480

The appellant, by a mining lease dated 1st September 1919, demised to the respondent, a company incorporated in New South Wales and carrying on the business of coal mining, mines of coal under certain land for a term of forty. three years. The lease reserved a yearly rental of £819, but provided that the respondent should be permitted to win " 'such a quantity of coal Co. (LTD.)

should at the rate per ton hereinafter mentioned produce in any one year the said sum of £819 and at a royalty per ton of all coal wrought and brought

over and above such quantity as may be worked in respect of such rent as aforesaid as follows" and the lease then set out that the royalty was to be calculated at a rate per ton depending on the selling price

The appellant claimed against the respondent for arrears of rent and royalty alleged to be due and payable under the lease for (so far as relevant to this appeal) two periods, one from 1st July 1948 to 20th September 1948, and the other from 20th September 1948 to 31st December 1950. The appellant alleged that the Prices Regulation Order No. 985 did not apply to the lease

SO as to reduce the amount payable by the respondent by way of royalty for the above two periods. The respondent contended that it was, inter alia, paying for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trustee Co (Ltd) v Pacific Coal Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1955] UKPCHCA 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Perpetual Trustee Co (Ltd) v Pacific Coal Co Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the appellant, Perpetual Trustee Co (Ltd), and the respondent, Pacific Coal Co Pty Ltd, concerning arrears of rent and royalty allegedly due and payable under a mining lease. The mining lease, dated 1st September 1919, reserved a yearly rental of £819 and a royalty per ton of all coal wrought and brought over and above the quantity worked in respect of the rent. The appellant claimed arrears for two periods, one from 1st July 1948 to 20th September 1948, and the other from 20th September 1948 to 31st December 1950, arguing that the Prices Regulation Order No. 985 did not apply to the lease to reduce the amount payable by the respondent by way of royalty. The respondent contended that it was paying for rights or privileges by way of royalty on goods produced and that therefore the regulations applied. The High Court of Australia had previously allowed the appeal of the respondent from part of a judgment of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, and the appellant now appealed from that decision. The key legal issues were whether the rights possessed by the respondent under the lease were "rights or privileges for which remuneration is payable in the form of royalty" within the meaning of reg. 3 (b) of the Prices Regulations, and if so, whether the Prices Regulations contemplated the lessor under a mining lease as providing a supply of mining rights throughout the term of the lease. The House of Lords found that the rights which the respondent possessed under the lease were indeed "rights or privileges for which remuneration is payable in the form of royalty" within the meaning of reg. 3 (b) of the Prices Regulations. The court also held that the Prices Regulations contemplated the lessor under a mining lease as providing a supply of mining rights throughout the term of the lease, as and when the lessee exercised those rights. Consequently, when the commissioner made Order No. 985 on 18th March 1943, he had power to fix the maximum rates payable by the respondent under the lease. The court further held that the phrase "the amount per ton of coal mined payable on 31st August 1939" in par. 2 (c) of the commissioner's order meant the amount of royalty payable per ton of coal mined on that date, and that the amount of royalty which the respondent was bound to pay in respect of coal mined on that date depended on the provisions of the lease and of the Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1932-1947 (N.S.W.). The court concluded that the appellant's appeal should be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.