Perkin-elmer Corporation v. Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd.

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952 - and - In the Matter of Application No. 516147 for a Patent of Addition by PERKIN-ELMER CORPORATION - and - In the Matter of Opposition thereto under Section 59 by VARIAN TECHTRON PTY. LTD.

 

DECISION OF A SUPERVISING EXAMINER OF PATENTS:

Background

Application No. 516147 by Perkin Elmer Corporation is a Convention application based on a U.S. application lodged 22 May, 1978, and is for an invention entitled AN AUTOMATIC FLUID SAMPLING TRANSPORT SYSTEM. The application was lodged on 28 August, 1978 and was advertised as accepted in the Official Journal of 21 May, 1981. A Notice of Opposition under Section 59 to the grant of a patent was lodged on 20 August, 1981 by Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd.

A request to amend the complete specification under Section 77 was lodged on 26 May, 1982. Acceptance of that request was advertised in the Official Journal of 26 August, 1982. Notice of Opposition to the acceptance under Section 82 was lodged on 13 September, 1982 by Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd. This matter was heard by me in Melbourne on 8 February, 1983, and in May 1983, I issued a derision dismissing the opposition.

The opposition under Section 59 was heard by me in Melbourne in August 1983 and in November of that year I issued a decision determining that grounds had been made out under sub-sections 59(l)(e), (g), (h) and (i). The decision concluded with a statement to the effect that, as I believed the defects in the specification could be removed by amendment, I would allow the applicant 60 days in which to propose amendments for that purpose.

On 13 January, 1984, the applicant did propose such amendments under S.77, and these were subsequently allowed - unopposed - by the delegate of the Commissioner and have now been incorporated into the specification.

It is this latter specification which formed the subject of the present proceedings, the matter being heard in Melbourne in February 1985. At the hearing Mr. Wayne McMaster of Edwd. Waters & Sons, Patent Attorneys, Melbourne, represented the applicant, and Dr. J.MCL. Emmerson of Counsel instructed hy Mr. T.J. Collins of Phillips, Ormonde and Fitzpatrick, Patent Attorneys, Melbourne, represented the opponent.

The Practice of the Patent Office

Where there has been a hearing in accordance with sub-section 60(1), and the Commissioner (or his delegate) has decided the case by allowing the applicant to propose amendments to correct defects found in the specification, it is the practice of this Office, after amendment of the specification, to invite the opponent to be heard again before the fate of the application is @finally determined. If the opponent does wish to be heard, the applicant is, of course, invited to attend the hearing. The point is, that while the amendments proposed under Section 77 are opposable under Section 82, the only ground of opposition is that the amendment is not allowable under Section 78 on the other hand the specification as amended may…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perkin-elmer Corporation v. Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1985] APO 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Perkin-Elmer Corporation sought to patent an automatic fluid sampling transport system, which was opposed by Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd. The dispute involved the validity and clarity of the patent claims in light of prior art and the necessity for amendments to the patent specification. The Supervising Examiner of Patents, J. L. Roveta, had previously ruled that the initial claims were not fairly based and anticipated by prior art. Perkin-Elmer amended the claims, and the Examiner needed to determine whether the amended specification met the previous ruling's requirements.

The legal issues centered on whether the amended claims now fairly represented the invention, adequately distinguished it from prior art, and met the statutory requirements for patentability. The opponent argued that the amendments did not sufficiently address the earlier objections, while the applicant maintained that the changes resolved the issues and complied with the prior decision.

The Examiner reviewed the amended specification and claims, finding that they met the requirements set out in the previous decision. The amended claims clearly defined the invention, distinguished it from prior art, and satisfied the statutory criteria for patentability. The Examiner also dismissed the opponent's argument that certain drafting errors invalidated the specification. Consequently, the Examiner concluded that the amended specification met the requirements of the earlier decision and dismissed the opposition, awarding costs against the opponent. The decision allowed the patent application to proceed to sealing, subject to any potential appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Perkin-Elmer Corporation lodged a patent application for an automatic fluid sampling transport system on 28 August 1978, based on a U.S. application from 22 May 1978. The application was advertised as accepted in the Official Journal of 21 May 1981. Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd. opposed the grant of a patent under Section 59 on 20 August 1981. Perkin-Elmer Corporation then requested to amend the complete specification under Section 77 on 26 May 1982, which was accepted and advertised on 26 August 1982. Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd. also opposed this acceptance under Section 82 on 13 September 1982. The opposition under Section 59 was heard in August 1983 and the decision was issued in November 1983, determining that grounds had been made out under sub-sections 59(l)(e), (g), (h), and (i). Perkin-Elmer Corporation proposed amendments on 13 January 1984, which were allowed and incorporated into the specification.

The initial opposition to the patent application by Varian Techtron Pty. Ltd. was heard, and the opposition under Section 59 was also heard. A decision was issued in November 1983, allowing Perkin-Elmer Corporation to propose amendments to correct defects found in the specification. Following the amendments, the matter was heard again in February 1985 to determine if the amended specification met the requirements of the previous decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the amended specification meets the requirements of the decision issued in November 1983.
2. Whether the amended specification is in conflict with the terms of the decision issued in May 1983.
3. Whether the opponent is entitled to raise Section 40 matters in the present circumstances.

Held
1. The amended specification meets the requirements of the decision issued in November 1983.
2. The amended specification is not in conflict with the terms of the decision issued in May 1983.
3. The opponent is entitled to raise Section 40 matters in the present circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the amended specification and determined that it met the requirements set forth in the November 1983 decision. The court found that the amendments successfully addressed the defects identified in the prior specification, thus meeting the requirements of the earlier decision. In addressing the second issue, the court concluded that there was no conflict between the amended specification and the terms of the May 1983 decision. The court noted that the earlier decision focused on the fair basis of the claims and did not require simultaneous rotation of the sample holding means and probe carrying means, which was confirmed by the language and context of the November 1983 decision. Finally, regarding the third issue, the court held that the opponent was entitled to raise Section 40 matters, even though the amendments were allowable under Section 78, because the amended specification could introduce new problems not previously present. The court reasoned that forcing the opponent to two hearings when one would suffice would be unjust. The court emphasized the importance of ensuring that the amended specification does not introduce new issues and that the opponent has a fair opportunity to address any new concerns arising from the amendments. The court relied on the practice of the Patent Office, which allows for a further hearing after amendment of the specification to ensure that all issues are properly addressed. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an amended specification must meet the requirements set out in a prior decision, but the opponent remains entitled to raise valid objections concerning the amended specification, even if those objections could have been raised earlier. The court distinguished the present case from prior authority by clarifying that an "interim decision" is a final decision insofar as it determines all issues capable of final determination at that stage of the proceedings. The court followed the principle that a decision once made cannot be reheard, but it departed from the notion that an opponent cannot raise new objections after amendments are allowed, by recognizing the need for a further hearing to address new issues introduced by the amendments.