Penny v Milligan

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read
5 CLR 349

PENNY AND ANOTHER

MILLIGAN AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Will-ConstructionProvision for widow-" In lieu of dower and thirds "-Partial

intestacy-Election-Absolute gift-Condition.

A testator by his will gave the residue of his personal estate to his wife for life, and after her death to his stepdaughter for life with remainder over to such of the stepdaughter's children as should survive her, and declared that the provision for his wife should be "in lieu of dower and thirds." The gift over in remainder having failed owing to the death of the children of the stepdaughter during the lifetime of the tenant for life, their interest fell into intestacy,

Held, that, inasmuch as it appeared from the terms of the will, that the events which happened and the consequent intestacy had never been con- templated by the testator, the declaration could not be construed as imposing a condition that the widow should only take the gift to her on the terms of renouncing any share on a possible partial intestacy, nor as a gift by implication of her share in the personalty to the next of kin, and that consequently she was entitled to both the provision and her share in the intestacy under the Statute of Distributions.

Lett v. Randall, 3 Sm. &G., 83; 24 L.J. Ch., 708, distinguished. Naismith v. Boyes, (1899) A.C., 495, and In re Williams; Williams V. Williams, (1897) 2 Ch., 12, considered and applied.

Decision of Street J., In re Eyers McIntosh v. Milligan, (1907) 7 S.R. (N.S.W.), 83, affirmed.

APPEAL from a decision of Street J. in Equity on an originating

5 CLR 350

OF A. summons brought by executors for the determination of questions

arising upon the construction of a will.

The testator, John Eyers, by his will, after providing for certain legacies, gave his real estate and the residue of his personal estate to his wife for life or SO long as she should continue his widow and unmarried, and after her death or marriage to his step- daughter for life, and after her death to such of her children as should be then surviving. The will contained this provision :- " I declare that the provision hereby made for my said wife is in lieu of dower and thirds." The testator died in June 1888, leaving a large amount of personal property. The widow died in December 1895, and the stepdaughter in January 1906, having had five children, all of whom had died during the life- time of the testator. The gift in remainder to the surviving children of the stepdaughter, therefore, failed. The testator left no issue.

The executors of the will took out an originating summons for the determination of the following among other questions:- Whether or not on the true construction of the will the sequels in title of the widow of the testator are entitled to any and what share in his intestate personal estate ? Street J.,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Penny v Milligan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1907] HCA 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from a decision of Street J. in the Supreme Court of New South Wales regarding the construction of the will of John Eyers. The testator's will provided a life interest in his real estate and personal estate residue to his wife, followed by a life interest to his stepdaughter, and then to such of the stepdaughter's children as survived her. A key provision stated that the gift to the wife was "in lieu of dower and thirds." The gift to the stepdaughter's children failed as they all predeceased the stepdaughter. This failure resulted in a partial intestacy. The dispute centred on whether the widow's estate was entitled to a share of this intestate personal property, in addition to the provision made for her in the will.

The legal issues before the court were: (1) whether the declaration that the provision for the wife was "in lieu of dower and thirds" imposed a condition that excluded her from any share in the partial intestacy; and (2) whether the testator's intention, as evidenced by the will, was to exclude the widow from such a share, thereby implying a gift of her intestate portion to the next of kin. The appellants argued that the declaration, in light of the potential for intestacy, should be construed as a condition preventing the widow from benefiting from any undisposed-of property.

The court, affirming the decision of Street J., held that the widow was entitled to both the provision made for her in the will and her distributive share of the intestate personal estate. The reasoning applied was that the testator had not contemplated the events that led to the partial intestacy. The declaration "in lieu of dower and thirds" was intended to apply to the property that the testator had effectively disposed of by his will. In the absence of a clear intention to exclude the widow from a share in an intestacy that was not foreseen, the general rule that a widow is entitled to her statutory share in undisposed-of property applies. The court distinguished cases where an intestacy was apparent on the face of the will or where the language used unequivocally indicated an intention to exclude the widow from any share in such circumstances. The court found no such clear intention or contemplation of intestacy in the present will.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.