Pendlebury and TT Line Company Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

Pendlebury and TT Line Company Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2024] AATA 3620 (10 October 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2022/1184, 2022/5973, 2023/4068

Re:Brett Pendlebury

APPLICANT

AndTT Line Company Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:10 October 2024

Place:Hobart

Pursuant to s 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the Tribunal decides as follows:

1.In respect of application 2022/1184:

(a)  The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision dated 16 March 2022.

(b)  In substitution therefor, the Tribunal decides:

(i)The Applicant continues to suffer from the effects of the injury he suffered to his spine, sustained on 8 May 2020;

(ii)The Applicant is totally incapacitated for work;

(iii)The Respondent, under s 26 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation andCompensation Act 1992 (SRC Act), has an ongoing liability under s 31 of the Act for incapacity payments and s 28 of the SRC Act for medical expenses in relation to the injury;

(iv)That the Applicant’s claim be remitted to the Respondent for determination of his entitlements for incapacity payments and medical expenses from 18 November 2021 to date;

(v)That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs, as agreed or assessed

2.In respect of application 2022/5973:

(a)  The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision deemed to have been made on 22 May 2022;

(b)  In substitution therefor, the Tribunal decides:

(i)That the Applicant sustained an injury to his lumbosacral spine involving the aggravation and acceleration of a degenerative condition of his lumbosacral spine as a consequence of the nature and conditions of his employment over the period from 2003 to 8 May 2020 working for the Respondent;

(ii)That the Applicant is totally incapacitated for work;

(iii)The Respondent under s 26 of the SRC Act has ongoing liability under s 31 of the SRC Act for incapacity payments and s 28 of the SRC Act for medical expenses in relation to the injury;

(iv)That the Applicant’s claim be remitted to the Respondent for determination of his entitlements to incapacity payments and medical expenses from 18 November 2021 to date;

(v)That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs, as agreed or assessed.

3.In respect of application 2022/4068:

(a)  The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision dated 8 May 2023;

(b)  In substitution therefore, the Tribunal decides:

(i)That the Applicant has suffered a psychiatric injury described as an adjustment disorder, as a consequence of the condition of his lumbosacral spine;

(ii)That the Respondent has, under s 26 of the SRC Act, an ongoing liability under s 31 of the SRC Act for incapacity payments and s 28 of the SRC Act for medical expenses in relation to the Applicant’s consequential psychiatric injury;

(iii)That the Applicant’s claim be remitted to the Respondent for determination of his entitlements;

(iv)That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs, as agreed or assessed.

................................[signed]........................................

Senior Member D. J. Morris

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – SEAFARER - applicant lodged claim for workers’ compensation for back injury – respondent determined no present liability to pay compensation – applicant lodged…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pendlebury and TT Line Company Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3620
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Pendlebury against TT Line Company Pty Ltd for workers' compensation. The applicant claimed compensation for a back injury sustained on 8 May 2020, an aggravation of a degenerative spinal condition due to the nature of his employment, and a consequential psychiatric injury. The respondent had determined no present liability to pay compensation. The applications were heard together by the Tribunal.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant had suffered a compensable injury, specifically whether his degenerative spinal condition was contributed to by the nature of his work, and whether he had sustained an injury on 8 May 2020. The parties also agreed that if the applicant was successful on either of these injury claims, the consequential psychiatric injury would be conceded as compensable. The Tribunal was required to consider expert medical evidence to determine these issues.

The Tribunal found that the applicant suffered from a degenerative spinal condition, lumbar spondylosis, which was contributed to by the nature of his employment with the respondent from 2003 to 8 May 2020. The Tribunal accepted that the applicant sustained an injury on 8 May 2020, finding that a typographical error in his statement explained his description of the action. Furthermore, the Tribunal acknowledged the concession by the respondent that the applicant suffered a consequential psychiatric injury if successful on his other claims.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reviewable decisions and substituted new decisions. It found that the applicant continued to suffer from the effects of the spinal injury sustained on 8 May 2020, and that his degenerative spinal condition was aggravated and accelerated by his employment. The Tribunal determined the applicant was totally incapacitated for work and that the respondent had an ongoing liability for incapacity payments and medical expenses. The claims were remitted to the respondent for determination of entitlements, and the respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Pendlebury and TT Line Company Pty Ltd (Compensation) revolves around the applicant, Mr Pendlebury, a seafarer who worked as an integrated rating for the respondent, TT Line Company Pty Ltd, from 2003 to the date of the injury. Mr Pendlebury’s work involved handling lashings, which were used to secure cargo on the respondent's Spirit of Tasmania vessels. The nature of this work required significant physical exertion, including bending under trucks and using hefty bars to tighten the lashings, often causing him to use his whole body weight. On 8 May 2020, Mr Pendlebury experienced severe back pain while performing his duties on the vessel, specifically when he was pulling tension on a lashing strap. He reported the pain to the medic on board, who provided painkillers, and he continued to work the next day. However, the pain persisted and intensified, leading to difficulties in walking by the following morning. Mr Pendlebury reported this worsening condition to his supervisor, who instructed him to see the medic again.

The Tribunal heard evidence from various expert medical witnesses who confirmed Mr Pendlebury's degenerative spinal condition, specifically lumbar spondylosis, and concluded that his work had contributed materially to the aggravation and acceleration of this condition. The Tribunal also considered the impact of this injury on Mr Pendlebury's ability to work and his subsequent psychiatric injury due to the ongoing physical and mental strain. The parties agreed that if Mr Pendlebury succeeded in his claims for the compensable injuries, the respondent would concede the existence of a consequential psychiatric injury. The Tribunal found that Mr Pendlebury was totally incapacitated for work and set aside the respondent's previous decisions, substituting them with new decisions that the respondent has ongoing liability for incapacity payments and medical expenses.

This case involves a claim for workers' compensation brought by Mr. Pendlebury against TT Line Company Pty Ltd (the respondent) for injuries sustained while working as an integrated rating on the respondent's Spirit of Tasmania vessels. The applicant has lodged multiple claims for compensation: for an initial back injury, for the aggravation of a pre-existing degenerative condition, and for a consequential psychiatric injury. These claims were heard together by the tribunal. The matter came before the tribunal following the respondent's determination that there was no present liability to pay compensation. The tribunal set aside the respondent's decisions and substituted new decisions in favour of the applicant. Key procedural steps included the lodging of multiple claims by the applicant, the respondent's determinations, and the tribunal's consideration of expert medical evidence and oral testimony from the applicant and medical professionals. The tribunal was satisfied that the applicant has a degenerative spinal disease, that his condition was materially contributed to by his work, and that he suffered an injury on 8 May 2020. The tribunal also accepted that if the applicant was successful on either of his compensable injury claims, the parties conceded that a consequential psychiatric injury would be acknowledged and compensable.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Hilliard said that the Applicant had been referred by his general practitioner to a neurosurgeon and has had interventions but no surgery at this stage. He said it got to the point where fusion surgery was recommended.ORAL EVIDENCEThe Applicant Mr Pendlebury adopted his witness statement dated 11 November 2022. The Applicant was asked about an MRI scan said to have been done in 2010. He said he had visited his general practitioner and asked for copies. He said he had numerous x-rays in 2020 relating to a broken ankle which was repaired, and told the Tribunal that this ankle injury was not work-related. He could not remember an MRI at this time. The Applicant confirmed that he worked as an integrated rating since 2003, and full-time from 2004. His work is exclusively on the Respondent’s Spirit of Tasmania vessels, which run a regular passenger and vehicle/cargo service across Bass Strait, at this time between the River Mersey in Devonport in Tasmania and Station Pier in the Port of Melbourne. The Applicant said his work cycle was 28 days on duty and then 28 days off. During the duty period he said that he had to remain on the vessel, and was allocated his own cabin, which he vacated at the end of the 28-day cycle for another integrated rating. He said that more recently, since 2016, he had made an arrangement with a work colleague to do a cycle of 14 days, and then 14 days off. He said that a month of lashing cargo was becoming too much. Mr Pendlebury told the Tribunal about the difference between a single and a double sailing, and that the latter occurs during holiday periods, and especially during school holidays. He said a typical day for a double sailing would begin at 4 am. All integrated ratings would go to the vehicle decks, unlash all the lashings, remove the straps and then drag them to a rail ready for freight to discharge. He said if the vessel is arriving at Devonport, they could not commence unlashing until the ship had entered the Mersey, and the captain of the ship had given permission; in the Port of Melbourne they had more time. Once the ship has docked, stevedores would come on and drive trucks off. The integrated ratings would tidy the lashings, ready to re-use them for the freight and trucks coming on board. Mr Hilliard referred to the report of Mr Michael Armitage dated 8 August 2020 which was before the Tribunal (‘the Armitage report’) (Exhibit A2). The Applicant said he had read it and it was an accurate summary of the type of work he and the other integrated ratings did. He explained the process, and the various lengths of lashings, and that they have a ratchet mechanism to be tightened. Mr Pendlebury said they had a 20-tonne breaking strain. The Applicant estimated that the lashings generally weighed around 12 kilograms, with some being a little more. Depending on the style of the lashing, he said integrated ratings had to bend down under trucks. He would use a hefty bar to tighten the lashings, to get tension, and to do that he had to use his whole bodyweight.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal notes that the parties decided not to call psychiatrist expert witnesses, and the Respondent agreed that, should the Tribunal find in favour of the Applicant, it was conceded that Mr Pendlebury suffered a psychiatric injury, and that the condition results in an incapacity to work. The Tribunal acknowledges that concession in terms of its finding in favour of the Applicant in relation to that particular application.DECISION In respect of application 2022/1184:(h)The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision dated 16 March 2022.(i)In substitution therefor, the Tribunal decides:(i)The Applicant continues to suffer from the effects of the injury he suffered to his spine, sustained on 8 May 2020;(ii)The Applicant is totally incapacitated for work;(iii)The Respondent, under s 26 of the Act, has an ongoing liability under s 31 of the Act for incapacity payments and s 28 for medical expenses in relation to the injury;(iv)That the Applicant’s claim be remitted to the Respondent for determination of his entitlements to incapacity payments and medical expenses from 18 November 2021 to date;(v)That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs, as agreed or assessed. In respect of application 2022/5973:(a)The tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision deemed to have been made on 22 May 2022.(b) In substitution therefor, the Tribunal decides:(ii)That the Applicant sustained an injury to his lumbosacral spine involving the aggravation and acceleration of a degenerative condition of his lumbosacral spine as a consequence of the nature and conditions of his employment of the period from 2003 to 8 May 2020 working for the Respondent;(iii)That the Applicant is totally incapacitated for work;(iv)The Respondent under s 26 of the Act has an ongoing liability under s 31 of the Act for incapacity payments and s 28 for medical expenses in relation to the injury;(v)That the Applicant’s claim be remitted to the Respondent for determination of his entitlements to incapacity payments and medical expenses from 18 November 2021 to date and continuing;(vi)That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs, as agreed or assessed. In respect of application 2023/4068:(a) The Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision dated 8 May 2023.(b) In substitution therefor, the Tribunal decides:(i) That the Applicant has suffered a psychiatric injury described as an adjustment disorder, as a consequence of the condition of his lumbosacral spine;(ii)That the Respondent has, under s 26 of the Act, an ongoing liability under s 31 of the Act for incapacity payments and s 28 for medical expenses in relation to the Applicant’s consequential psychiatric injury;(iii)That the Applicant’s claim be remitted to the Respondent for determination of his entitlements;(iv)That the Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs, as agreed or assessed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Hilliard noted that three neurosurgeons disagree with Dr Jonathan’s views about the Applicant, but Dr Allen agreed. Dr Jonathan responded, “Yes. My views are mine.”CONSIDERATION It is not in contest between the parties that the Applicant has a degenerative condition affecting his spine; lumbar spondylosis. That is evidenced from the MRI reports which are referred to in the several medical reports before the Tribunal, and in the oral evidence of five expert medical witnesses who gave evidence at the hearing. There was evidence about an MRI scan apparently done in 2010 showing degeneration at L2/3 and L4/5, which is referred to in a medical letter Dr Alaishkevich wrote to the Applicant’s general practitioner, Dr O’Donoghue, on 11 June 2020. However, Dr Alaishkevich, whilst confirming in his oral evidence that his notes say he was told by the Applicant when he examined him that he had an MRI on 14 September 2020, he did not have a copy of any MRI report. None of the other expert medical witnesses who gave evidence had a copy of a 2010 MRI and some had no knowledge of one. Mr Pendlebury himself gave evidence that he remembered x-rays around that time, but he could not recall an MRI. During his evidence, Professor Bittar called up the Victorian portal, which medical professionals can use to find historical imaging reports including MRIs. Professor Bittar told the Tribunal that there is no evidence of the Applicant having an MRI on that portal, whilst noting that, if it had occurred in Tasmania, it might not necessarily appear on the portal. Overall, because of the lack of firm evidence, the Tribunal cannot make a finding that there was an MRI in 2010. On 7 December 2012, an MRI scan was taken which revealed a right-sided posterior-central disc protrusion, causing marked compromise of the S1 nerve, and marked compromise of the S1 nerve root on the right. The MRI scan report also noted posterolateral degenerative chances to discs. In his witness statement dated 11 November 2022, Mr Pendlebury described suffering an injury on 8 May 2020. He said:On 8 May 2020 my back became very painful during my lashing duties on the Spirit of Tasmania. At that time I was pulling tension on the lashing straps. Mr Harding asked the Applicant what he was doing when he felt the pain on 8 May 2020. He said he was crouched under the tray of a truck putting tension on a lashing strap, using a tension bar. Counsel for the Respondent asked why he had stated that he was ‘pulling’ in his statement. The Applicant said that he meant to type the word ‘putting’. The Tribunal accepts that this is a typographical error; the grammar of the sentence admits that the word should be ‘putting’, and the Tribunal accepts that is what Mr Pendlebury was trying to convey, in terms of his mechanical actions at the time. He went to the medic on board who gave him some painkillers. He returned to work the next day. On 9 May, whilst lashing, he felt a sharp pain in his back. He again saw the medic. The next morning, he reported to a supervisor that the pain had increased considerably, and he was finding it difficult to walk. The supervisor told him to again report to the medic.