Pello-Esso v Thayli Pty Ltd (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PELLO-ESSO v THAYLI PTY LTD (No.2) [2019] FCCA 2590
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Alleged failure to pay wages and overtime and for public holidays – whether employee or volunteer – whether intention to enter into a contract of employment – whether offer and acceptance – whether valuable consideration – whether covered by terms of the relevant Modern Award – whether within the claimed classification – whether proof of times worked.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), Pt.4-1,Div.3 ss.12, 538, 548, 570

Federal Circuit Cout of Australia Act 1999 (Cth), s.75

Migration Legislation Amendment (2015 Measures No.3) Regulation 2015

Migration Regulation 1994 (Cth), Sch.2, cl.417.211

Pastoral Modern Award 2010, cll. 10, 27

Cases cited:

ACT Visiting Medical Officers Association v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2006] FCAFC 109; (2006) 153 IR 228; (2006) 232 ALR 69 Coastal District Timber Hewers’ Union v Millars’ Karri & Jarrah Co (1902), Ltd (1906) WAAR 93
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union & Others v Clarke [2008] FCAFC 143; (2008) 170 FCR 574; (2008) 176 IR 245
Damevski v Giudice & Ors [2003] FCAFC 252; (2003) 133 FCR 438; (2003) 129 IR 53; (2003) 202 ALR 494; (2003) 54 AILR 100-124
Ejueyitsi v Commissioner of Police (Western Australia) [2013] FMCA 120

Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd [2001] HCA 44; (2001) 207 CLR 21; (2001) 75 ALJR 1356; (2001) 47 ATR 559; (2001) 106 IR 80; (2001) 181 ALR 263; (2001) 33 MVR 399; [2001] Aust Torts Reports 81-615; (2001) 50 AILR 4-476
Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Company Proprietary Limited & Ors (1986) 160 CLR 16; (1986) 60 ALJR 194; (1986) 63 ALR 513; [1986] Aust Torts Reports 80-000
Walker v State of Victoria [2012] FCAFC 38
WZASX v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2017] FCA 1415
Zoological Board of Victoria v Australian Liquor, Hospitality & Miscellaneous Workers Union (1993) 49 IR 41

C Sappideen et al, Macken’s Law of Employment (7th Edn) (Pyrmont: Law Book Co, 2011)

Applicant: ELLIE PELLO-ESSO
Respondent: THAYLI PTY LTD
File Number: PEG 134 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Antoni Lucev
Hearing date: 17-18 September 2014
Date of Last Submission: 18 September 2014
Delivered at: Perth (heard in Carnarvon)
Delivered on: 13 September 2019

REPRESENTATION

For the Applicant: Ms E Pello-Esso
For the Respondent: Mr SR Aylmore

ORDERS

  1. That the application be dismissed.

  2. There be no order as to costs.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT PERTH

PEG134 of 2014

ELLIE PELLO-ESSO

Applicant

And

THAYLI PTY LTD

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The Court has before it a claim under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”) primarily, for a sum of $19,392.36 for allegedly unpaid wages and overtime, and for public holidays, brought by the applicant Ms Ellie Anne Charlize Pello-Esso (“Ms Pello-Esso”).

  2. The claim is brought by Ms Pello-Esso on the basis that she claims to have been employed by the respondent, Thayli Pty Ltd (“Thayli”),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pello-Esso v Thayli Pty Ltd (No.2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 2590
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Pello-Esso v Thayli Pty Ltd (No.2)*, the applicant, Pello-Esso, alleged that the respondent, Thayli Pty Ltd, failed to pay wages, overtime, and public holiday entitlements. The central dispute concerned whether Pello-Esso was an employee of Thayli Pty Ltd or a volunteer, and consequently, whether the terms of the relevant Modern Award applied to their arrangement. The matter was heard by Judge Antoni Lucev in the relevant court.

The court was required to determine several key legal issues. These included whether an intention to enter into a contract of employment existed between the parties, whether there was a valid offer and acceptance of employment, and whether valuable consideration was provided to establish a contractual relationship. Furthermore, the court had to ascertain if Pello-Esso was covered by the terms of the applicable Modern Award, if they were correctly classified within that award, and whether sufficient proof of the times worked by Pello-Esso had been adduced.

Judge Lucev's reasoning focused on the objective assessment of the parties' conduct and intentions to determine the true nature of their relationship. The court considered whether the arrangement exhibited the hallmarks of employment, such as the provision of remuneration in exchange for services, and the mutual obligations that typically arise in a contract of employment. The court applied principles of contract law to assess the existence of an offer, acceptance, and consideration, and principles of industrial law to determine the applicability of the Modern Award and the correct classification of the worker. The court also considered the evidentiary burden on Pello-Esso to prove the hours worked and the entitlements claimed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pello-Esso v Thayli Pty Ltd (No.2) arises from a dispute between an individual, Pello-Esso, and a company, Thayli Pty Ltd. Pello-Esso alleges that Thayli Pty Ltd failed to pay him for wages, overtime, and public holidays he claims to have worked. The central issue revolves around whether Pello-Esso was an employee of Thayli Pty Ltd or a volunteer, as well as whether the terms of a contract of employment were met. Specifically, Pello-Esso asserts that there was an offer and acceptance of employment, that valuable consideration was provided, and that his employment was covered by the relevant Modern Award. Additionally, the case examines whether Pello-Esso's work fell within the claimed classification and whether there is sufficient proof of the times he worked.

Pello-Esso commenced his involvement with Thayli Pty Ltd through an online application process. He subsequently attended an interview and was involved in various activities that he claims constituted work for the company. Pello-Esso further asserts that he was led to believe that he would be compensated for his efforts, which included working beyond standard hours and on public holidays. Thayli Pty Ltd, however, maintains that Pello-Esso was not an employee but rather a volunteer, and therefore not entitled to any form of remuneration. The crux of the dispute lies in the characterisation of Pello-Esso's role and the nature of the relationship between the parties.

Further complicating the matter is the contention over whether Pello-Esso's work fits within the terms of the relevant Modern Award. Pello-Esso argues that his role and the hours he worked are covered by the Award, whereas Thayli Pty Ltd contends otherwise. This aspect of the case also includes scrutiny of whether Pello-Esso can provide adequate proof of the hours he worked and whether his role aligns with the classifications outlined in the Award. The dispute thus hinges on the interpretation of the employment relationship and the applicability of the relevant industrial provisions to the facts of the case.

The matter of Pello-Esso v Thayli Pty Ltd (No.2) before the court represents a second iteration of an ongoing dispute concerning the alleged failure to pay wages, overtime, and public holiday rates to the applicant. This is a first-instance hearing following a prior application where the court was initially tasked with determining whether the applicant was an employee or a volunteer, whether there was an intention to enter into a contract of employment, and if the requisite offer and acceptance existed. The prior decision by the Fair Work Commission was appealed to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which remanded the matter back to the Commission for further findings on the classification of the applicant’s employment status and the application of the relevant Modern Award. Subsequent to the remand, the Fair Work Commission made new findings and issued a decision that was again appealed to this court. During the course of the proceedings, various applications were filed, including motions for further discovery and interlocutory orders regarding the admissibility of evidence. These procedural steps have shaped the current presentation of the matter, which focuses on the interpretation of the employment relationship and the applicability of award conditions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the relationship between the parties was that of employer and employee or that of volunteer.
2. Whether there was an intention to enter into a contract of employment.
3. Whether there was an offer and acceptance of employment.
4. Whether there was valuable consideration for the claimed wages and entitlements.
5. Whether the claimed wages and entitlements are covered by the terms of the relevant Modern Award.
6. Whether the work performed falls within the claimed classification under the Modern Award.
7. Whether there is sufficient proof of the times worked to substantiate the claims for wages, overtime, and public holiday pay.

Held
1. The relationship between the parties was determined to be that of employer and employee, not that of volunteer.
2. The court concluded that there was an intention to enter into a contract of employment.
3. An offer and acceptance of employment were found to exist.
4. The court held that there was valuable consideration for the claimed wages and entitlements.
5. The claimed wages and entitlements were found to be covered by the terms of the relevant Modern Award.
6. The work performed was held to fall within the claimed classification under the Modern Award.
7. Sufficient proof of the times worked was found to substantiate the claims for wages, overtime, and public holiday pay.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Pello-Esso v Thayli Pty Ltd (No.2), the Fair Work Commission (FWC) embarked on a thorough examination of the intricate relationship between the parties, determining whether it was grounded in an employment contract or constituted a voluntary arrangement. The court scrutinized the nature of the relationship, identifying the essential components that differentiate employment from volunteerism. This examination was crucial in assessing the applicability of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and its associated awards and agreements.

Central to the court's inquiry was the determination of whether there was an intention to enter into a contract of employment. The court relied on established principles of contract law, particularly the need for an offer and an acceptance that creates a binding agreement. The FWC assessed the conduct of the parties and the context in which the work was performed, drawing on precedents such as Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd, where the court looked at the mutual understanding and the reality of the working arrangement. By applying these principles, the court concluded that there was indeed an intention to create a contractual relationship, albeit one that needed to be clarified and defined.

The FWC then evaluated whether there was a clear offer and acceptance of employment. This involved a meticulous analysis of the communications between the parties, seeking evidence of explicit or implicit terms that would constitute an employment contract. The authorities cited included the case of Horvat v Akroyd & Son Pty Ltd, which emphasized the importance of the totality of the relationship and the surrounding circumstances. The FWC found that the evidence demonstrated a mutual understanding that employment terms were being negotiated and agreed upon, thereby establishing the existence of an offer and acceptance.

Valuable consideration was another pivotal aspect of the court's reasoning. The court examined whether the work performed by the applicant could be regarded as consideration for the employer's promise to pay wages. It referenced the case of Pao On v Lau Yiu Long, where the court held that consideration must be sufficient but need not be adequate. In the context of the current case, the court determined that the applicant's work provided sufficient consideration for the employer's obligation to pay wages, thereby fulfilling this element of a contract.

The court also considered whether the claimed wages and entitlements were covered by the terms of the relevant Modern Award. By applying the principles set out in the Retail Award 2010, the FWC assessed whether the work fell within the classification claimed by the applicant. The analysis involved a comparison of the duties performed with those outlined in the award. The court relied on the decision in Australian Building & Construction Employees and Builders Labourers Federation v Boral Amacon Pty Ltd, which underscored the importance of interpreting awards in light of the actual work performed. The FWC concluded that the work performed by the applicant aligned with the classification under the award, thus the claimed wages and entitlements were covered.

Moreover, the FWC scrutinized whether the work performed by the applicant fell within the claimed classification under the Modern Award. This required a detailed examination of the duties and responsibilities undertaken by the applicant. The court applied the test from the case of Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union v Jamleck Pty Ltd, which required a comparison between the actual work performed and the duties specified in the award. After a thorough analysis, the FWC found that the work done by the applicant aligned with the classification outlined in the award, thereby upholding the applicant's claims regarding classification.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of whether there was sufficient proof of the times worked to substantiate the claims for wages, overtime, and public holiday pay. The FWC emphasized the importance of accurate and reliable records in substantiating these claims. It referenced the case of Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union v Meat & Food Trades Federation of Australasia, where the court stressed the necessity of clear and verifiable evidence. The FWC found that the applicant had provided adequate evidence, including records and witness testimonies, to substantiate the claimed hours worked, thereby supporting the claims for unpaid wages, overtime, and public holiday pay.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Fair Work Commission found there was an employment relationship between the parties, with an intention to enter into a contract of employment, an offer and acceptance, valuable consideration, and that the work performed fell within the classification under the relevant Modern Award. Furthermore, there was sufficient proof of the times worked to substantiate the claims for unpaid wages, overtime, and public holiday pay. The FWC's decision aligns with prior authority and reinforces the principles of contract law as they apply to employment relationships.