[2014] QCA 272
COURT OF APPEAL
HOLMES JA
FRASER JA
PHILIPPIDES J
Appeal No 8958 of 2014
QCAT No 413 of 2014
SCOTT PEET
JESSICA PEET Applicants
v
RENTAL DOMAIN First Respondent
SCOTT TURVEY Second Respondent
BRISBANE
THURSDAY, 23 OCTOBER 2014
JUDGMENT
HOLMES JA: Mr and Mrs Peet have filed documents purporting to appeal a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. Section 149 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 permits an appeal in circumstances where the relevant Tribunal was not constituted by a judicial member, only by leave, only on a question of law, and only against a cost amount decision, which is to say, a decision fixing costs under s 107 of the Act.
The Peets’ appearance in the Tribunal on 10 September 2014 was before an adjudicator who, not being the president, deputy president or a Judge, was not a judicial member. As far as can be discerned from the transcript of what occurred when Mr and Mrs Peet appeared in the Tribunal, Rental Domain, the respondent, who are real estate agents, were seeking an unspecified order which would reflect their management of the property which the Peets were renting. The Peets maintained that they had an agreement that the landlord would deal with them direct and raised a number of complaints about the condition of the property. The adjudicator directed that they pay rent to the agent and indicated that they ought to provide a list of their maintenance problems to the agent.
Mr and Mrs Peet now seek a variety of orders in this Court, including a stay of an identified order made on 10 September 2014 and a number of other orders dealing with their occupation of the premises and the contract they assert they entered with the landlord. However, no cost amount decision is identified. No jurisdiction, consequently, exists for this Court to hear an appeal or an application for leave to appeal from them. The notice of appeal and application for orders should be struck out.
FRASER JA: I agree.
PHILIPPIDES J: I also agree.
HOLMES JA: The notice of appeal and application for orders are accordingly struck out, and that’s the end of the matter, as far as this Court is concerned, Mr and Mrs Peet.
MR PEET: Okay.
HOLMES JA: Thank you.
MS PEET: Thank you.
HOLMES JA: We’ll adjourn the Court.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Peet v Rental Domain and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] QCA 272
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue in this case was whether the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to hear the Peets' appeal from the QCAT decision. Under section 149 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009, an appeal to the Court of Appeal is permissible only if certain conditions are met: the appeal must be from a decision of the Tribunal that was not constituted by a judicial member, only by leave, only on a question of law, and only against a cost amount decision. The Peets' appeal did not meet these criteria, as the QCAT decision was made by an adjudicator who was not a judicial member, and no cost amount decision was identified.
The Court of Appeal, comprising Holmes JA, Fraser JA, and Philippides J, concluded that the Court did not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal. The Peets' notice of appeal and application for orders were struck out, effectively dismissing their appeal. The Peets' request for a stay of the QCAT order and other orders related to their tenancy and contract with the landlord could not be entertained due to the lack of jurisdiction.
The final order of the Court of Appeal was to strike out the notice of appeal and application for orders filed by the Peets. This decision underscores the importance of meeting the statutory criteria for an appeal to the Court of Appeal from QCAT. The Peets' attempt to appeal the QCAT decision failed due to the absence of a cost amount decision and the QCAT decision not being made by a judicial member.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Peets filed an appeal to the Queensland Court of Appeal against a decision made by an adjudicator at QCAT on 10 September 2014. The appeal was lodged despite the requirement under Section 149 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009, which permits an appeal only by leave, only on a question of law, and only against a cost amount decision. The Peets sought various orders from the Court of Appeal, including a stay of the QCAT order and orders relating to their occupation of the premises and the contract they claimed to have with the landlord.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Queensland Court of Appeal has jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal.
2. Whether the notice of appeal and application for orders should be struck out due to the lack of jurisdiction.
Held
1. The Queensland Court of Appeal determined it does not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The appeal was dismissed as the tribunal's decision was not a cost amount decision and thus did not fall within the limited grounds for appeal permitted by statute.
2. The notice of appeal and application for orders were struck out due to the lack of jurisdiction, resulting in the dismissal of the Peets' appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal began by noting that the Peets had filed an appeal from a decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). Section 149 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 outlines the circumstances under which an appeal may be made from QCAT, including that the appeal can only be on a question of law, the tribunal was not constituted by a judicial member, and it must relate to a decision on the amount of costs. The Peets' appeal did not satisfy these criteria as their appeal did not pertain to a cost amount decision. The court was clear that the adjudicator who presided over the tribunal hearing was not a judicial member, as required by statute. The Peets sought various orders, but none of these related to the amount of costs. Therefore, the court found it did not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal. The notice of appeal and the application for orders were struck out as there was no jurisdiction to consider them, and the appeal was dismissed. The Court of Appeal adhered to the statutory framework for appeals from QCAT and did not extend the grounds for appeal beyond what the legislation allows.