TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Application by Parchem Construction Products Pty Ltd for an extension of time to serve evidence in support of its opposition to registration of trade mark application 894658(1,2,19) - CHEMPROOF - in the name of Peerless Industrial Systems Pty Ltd.
Delegate: Deirdre O'Brien Representation: Opponent: Richard McCormack of counsel instructed by Wray & Associates
Applicant: Chris Bevitt of Acuiti LegalDecision: Extension of time to 3 January 2004 granted.
Costs awarded against applicant.Background
1. Peerless Industrial Systems Pty Ltd (the applicant) is applying to register the trade mark chemproof per application 894658. Registration is opposed by Parchem Constructions Products Pty Ltd (the opponent). Notice of Opposition was filed on 3 January 2003. Since then Registrar has granted two extensions of time, each of three months, under the provisions of subregulation 5.15 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 for the service of evidence in support of the opposition. Those extensions were granted on the basis of settlement negotiations between the parties. On 3 October 2003 the opponent applied for a third extension of time until 3 January 2004. It gives as reason that it requires more time to prepare and serve its evidence as settlement negotiations had recently broken down. The applicant objected to the extension being granted and asked to be heard in the matter.
The hearing was held by teleconference on 11 November 2003 before me, as the Registrar's delegate. Mr Richard McCormack of counsel, instructed by Wray & Associates, represented the applicant. Mr Christ Bevitt of Acuiti Legal represented the opponent.
Submissions
In his submissions on behalf of the applicant, Mr McCormack points to what he says are deficiencies in the opponent's supporting declaration, being a declaration made by Mr Chris Bevitt of the opponent's agent. Mr McCormack cites Kimberley-Clark Ltd v Commissioner of Patents (No. 3)[1] as establishing the opponent must provide proof of the facts on which its extension application is based. Mr McCormack says the opponent is requesting the Registrar's indulgence and such indulgence cannot be granted unless there has been full and frank disclosure of all the circumstances leading to the opponent's decision to delay preparing and serving its evidence. In Agro-K v Ag Direct Sales Pty Ltd[2] the Registrar's delegate was not satisfied as to the intentions of the party applying for the extension and Mr McCormack says a similar situation applies here. He believes the Bevitt declaration has limited probative value, not having been made by an authorised officer of the opponent. He alleges some of the facts in the declaration are open to a different interpretation than that given them by Mr Bevitt and that Mr Bevitt has failed to disclose other pertinent information. Mr McCormack submits the opponent has a collateral purpose in delaying the preparation of its evidence, perhaps for commercial reasons or in order to gain an advantage in the other opposition proceedings in which the applicant and opponent are involved.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Peerless Industrial Systems Pty Ltd v Parchem Construction P... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] ATMO 75
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Registrar's delegate was whether to grant Parchem an extension of time to serve its evidence. This involved considering the length of the requested extension, the reasons provided for the delay, the potential prejudice to the parties, and the public interest in the proper determination of trade mark disputes. The delegate also had to assess whether Parchem had demonstrated a proper case for the extension, taking into account the circumstances of the case, including ongoing negotiations and parallel opposition proceedings.
The Registrar's delegate reasoned that the nine-month period already afforded to Parchem was reasonable, particularly given that negotiations between the parties had only recently broken down. The delegate found that Parchem's explanation for the delay, namely its hope for a settlement and its subsequent efforts in evidence preparation, including seeking information under the FOI Act and evaluating the applicant's evidence in a related opposition, constituted a full and frank disclosure and a reasonable course of action. The delegate also considered that refusing the extension would cause greater prejudice to Parchem than granting it would cause to Peerless, and that it was in the public interest for the Registrar to have all relevant material before making a decision.
Consequently, the Registrar's delegate was satisfied that it was appropriate to grant the extension of time to Parchem. The delegate noted that Parchem indicated a further extension was unlikely to be required.
Background
Background to the litigation
Initially, negotiations between Peerless and Parchem were ongoing, with both parties hopeful of reaching a settlement. Parchem, represented by Mr. Bevitt, did not prioritise the preparation of its evidence due to this hope for a negotiated settlement. During the negotiations, Parchem made a request for information on the official file for Peerless' trade mark application under the Freedom of Information Act and evaluated Peerless' evidence in support of its opposition to Parchem's application 851535. Mr. Bevitt declared that it was unlikely a further extension would be required, as his firm was responsible for preparing Parchem's evidence for service.
The Registrar, considering the extended time Peerless had to serve its evidence, the importance of the issues of trade mark ownership and public deception, and the potential consequences for Parchem if the extension were refused, granted the extension. The Registrar noted that the statutory three-month period for preparing evidence is often insufficient and considered twelve months to be a reasonable extension period in this context. The decision emphasised the importance of having all relevant material before the Registrar to ensure a fair and informed decision.
Peerless Industrial Systems Pty Ltd v Parchem Construction Products Pty Ltd involves an application for an extension of time to file evidence in opposition to the registration of a trade mark. This case came before the Registrar as an interlocutory application for an extension, rather than a first-instance hearing or appeal. The matter had previously been before the Registrar in relation to the applicant's opposition to the opponent's registration of a trade mark, chemproof. The opponent had initially applied for a registration of the same trade mark, which the applicant opposed. The opponent's application to extend the time for filing its evidence was supported by a declaration from Mr Bevitt, who explained the reasons for the delay and outlined the steps taken towards preparing the evidence. The applicant argued against the extension, but the Registrar found that the opponent had made out a proper case for the extension, taking into account the Registrar's guidelines and relevant precedents. The Registrar also considered the potential consequences for the opponent if the extension were to be refused, as well as the public interest in having all relevant material before the decision-maker.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Registrar's decision in Peerless Industrial Systems Pty Ltd v Parchem Construction Products Pty Ltd addresses the issue of whether an extension of time for serving evidence beyond the statutory three-month period should be granted. The court carefully considered several factors before concluding that an extension of twelve months was reasonable under the circumstances. Firstly, the Registrar acknowledged that the statutory three-month period often proves insufficient for the preparation of evidence, particularly when negotiations between the parties are involved. The Registrar noted that while a nine-month period is typically considered reasonable in the absence of negotiations, a fifteen-month period is deemed reasonable when negotiations are ongoing. Given that the negotiations in this case broke down only a few days before the extension application was filed, the Registrar deemed an extension of twelve months to be neither excessive nor unreasonable.
Secondly, the court evaluated the opponent's declaration, which provided a full and frank disclosure of the events leading up to the extension application. The opponent's representative, Mr. Bevitt, explained that the opponent had hoped negotiations would result in a settlement and thus did not prioritize the preparation of its evidence. The court found this approach reasonable, particularly in light of the Registrar's published guidelines and the precedent set in Australian Olympic Committee v Brennan. The declaration also outlined specific actions taken by the opponent in preparing its evidence, such as requesting information from the official file under the Freedom of Information Act and evaluating the applicant's evidence. The court accepted that these actions were reasonable, especially considering the overlapping nature of the proceedings involving the same parties and trade mark.
Moreover, the court considered whether it was reasonable for the opponent to delay the preparation of its evidence in anticipation of a settlement. The Registrar found that the opponent's approach was reasonable, despite the applicant's different approach in the other proceedings. Mr. Bevitt's declaration further reassured the court that it was unlikely a further extension would be required, as his firm was responsible for organizing the opponent's evidence. This statement from a party in a position of knowledge provided additional comfort to the Registrar.
The consequences of refusing the extension were also weighed. The Registrar concluded that the consequences for the opponent if the extension were refused were significantly greater than those for the applicant if the extension were granted. Refusal would mean the opponent could not rely on any evidence in the proceedings, potentially disadvantaging its case. The public interest in having all relevant material before the Registrar when making a decision was also considered. The Registrar referenced Bundy American Corp v Rent-A-Wreck (Vic) Pty Ltd, which emphasized the importance of the Registrar having all pertinent information.
In summary, the Registrar exercised discretion in granting the extension based on the reasonableness of the twelve-month period, the full and frank disclosure provided by the opponent, the reasonableness of delaying evidence preparation in anticipation of settlement, and the disproportionate consequences of refusal. The decision reflects a balanced approach to the statutory timeframes and the practicalities of litigation, ensuring that the Registrar has all relevant material before making a decision. The ratio decidendi here is that the Registrar has the discretion to grant an extension beyond the statutory three-month period when negotiations have broken down shortly before the application, provided the extension is reasonable and the consequences of refusal are disproportionately severe for the opponent.