| [2024] FWCFB 236 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604—Appeal of decision
Pedro Alfaro
v
ATM Cleaning Management Pty Ltd
(C2024/764)
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAUNDERS | SYDNEY, 26 APRIL 2024 |
Appeal against decision [2023] FWC 148 of Deputy President Boyce at Sydney on 18 January 2024 in matter number C2023/7353
On 29 November 2023 Mr Alfaro Pedro made an application under section 773 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) against ATM Cleaning Management Pty Ltd. ATM Cleaning Management Pty Ltd raised jurisdictional objections to Mr Alfaro’s application on the basis that it was not ever Mr Alfaro’s employer and, in the alternative, Mr Alfaro was prohibited from pursuing his unlawful termination application due to the operation of s 723 of the Act.
Deputy President Boyce scheduled a hearing, on 9 February 2024, to deal with the respondent’s jurisdictional objections and made directions requiring the parties to each file materials prior to the hearing.
On 17 January 2024 Mr Alfaro sent an email to Deputy President Boyce’s chambers indicating that he would not be filing any materials in accordance with the directions made, or attending the scheduled hearing, and that “if the Deputy President likes [he can] dismiss my application today. Please do so.”
On 18 January 2024 Deputy President Boyce dismissed Mr Alfaro’s application, publishing his reasons for doing so in Alfaro v ATM Cleaning Management [2024] FWC 148.
Mr Alfaro has applied for permission under section 604 of the Act to appeal the decision of Deputy President Boyce.
The Deputy President’s reasons for dismissing Mr Alfaro’s application were succinctly stated in his published decision:
[1] On 29 November 2023, Mr Pedro Alfaro (Applicant), filed an application pursuant to s.773 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) with the Fair Work Commission (Commission), being an application to deal with an alleged unlawful termination dispute (Application). The Respondent to the Application is ATM Cleaning Management Pty Ltd (Respondent).
[2] On 20 December 2023, the Respondent filed a Form F9A, being a response to the Application. The Respondent objects to the Application, and says that the Applicant relevantly was not an “employee” of the Respondent, including for the purposes of Part 4-6 of the Act. Further, the Respondent says that even if the Applicant was relevantly an “employee” of the Respondent (including for the purposes of Part 4-6 of the Act), the Applicant is prohibited from pressing his unlawful termination application before the Commission due to the operation of s.723 of the Act which provides that “A person must not make an unlawful termination application in relation to conduct if the person is [or was at the time that the unlawful termination application was filed] entitled to make a general protections court application in relation to the conduct” (noting Part 3-1 of the Act, and more specifically, ss.337-342, 351-352 and 365 of the Act).
[3] On 22 December 2023 directions were issued to parties, and a hearing was set down for 9…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pedro Alfaro v ATM Cleaning Management Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FWCFB 236
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Full Bench were whether Mr Alfaro had identified any grounds for appeal and whether there were any grounds for granting permission to appeal. The Full Bench needed to determine whether the decision of Deputy President Boyce was correct and whether there were any grounds for overturning the decision. The Full Bench also needed to consider whether the appeal raised any matter of public interest or any other basis for granting permission to appeal.
The Full Bench considered the decision of Deputy President Boyce, the materials filed by Mr Alfaro, and the limited oral submissions made by Mr Alfaro at the hearing. The Full Bench found that Mr Alfaro had not identified any appealable error and that it was within the discretion of the Deputy President to dismiss Mr Alfaro's application, particularly given that Mr Alfaro had asked the Deputy President to do so and had clearly communicated his intention not to prosecute his case before the Fair Work Commission.
The Full Bench refused permission to appeal, stating that it did not have any impact on any underpayment of wages claim which Mr Alfaro may choose to pursue against the respondent in a court of competent jurisdiction. The Full Bench emphasised that Mr Alfaro did not need a certificate from the Fair Work Commission to pursue such a claim in a court.
The Full Bench's decision to refuse permission to appeal was based on the fact that Mr Alfaro had not identified any grounds for appeal and that there were no other grounds for granting permission to appeal. The Full Bench found that the decision of Deputy President Boyce was correct and that there were no grounds for overturning the decision. The Full Bench also found that the appeal did not raise any matter of public interest or any other basis for granting permission to appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi