Pearson Peterson & Smith v Richard Arear

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
INDUSTRIAL LAW - direction that officials perform and
observe rules of reglstered organisatlon - exclusion
from employment and unlon of members who refuse to
make payment towards expenses of delegates in
accordance with decision of workmates - deliberate
injury without justification - breach of rules -
orders granted.
Conciliation and Arbitration Act, s.141
ROLAND HAVEY VALL PEARSON v. RICHARD ANEAR and others
LYNDA JOY PETERSEN v. RICHARD ANEAR and others
LEE-ANN ELIZABETH SMITH v. RICHARD ANEAR and others
Qld. Nos Q8, 9 and 10 of 1981
15 OCTOBER 1982

FITZGERALD J.
BRISBANE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA)
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY ) Nos. Q 8,9 and 10 of 1981
INDUSTRIAL DIVISION 1

BETWEEN:

ROLAND HARVEY VALL PEARSON

Applicant

AND :

RICHARD ANEAR and others

Respondents

BETWEEN :

LYNDA JOY PETERSEN

Applicant

AND :

RICHARD ANEAR and others

Respondents

BETWEEN :

LEE-ANN ELIZABETH SMITH

Applicant

AND :

RICHARD ANEAR and others

Respondents

_ _ _ _ _ O R D E R
JUDGE MAKING ORDER: FITZGERALD J.
DATE OF ORDER:  15 OCTOBER 1982
BRISBANE MADE: WHERE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.    The respondents other than the respondent

Richard Anear perform and observe the
Rules of the Australian Meat Industry
Employees' Union by ceasing -
(a) to refuse to work with the applicant

(b)

to inclte other members of the Australian Meat Industry Employees

Union to refuse to work with the
applicant
(c) to obstruct the employment of
the applicant at the Bremer River

Abattoir

and

(d)
to obstruct any payment by the
applicant to the Australian Meat
Industry Employees' Union:

2.    the respondent Richard Anear perform and

observe the Rules of the Australian Meat
Industry Employees' Union by ceasing to
support and encourage the other respondents -
(a) to refuse to work with the applicant
(b) to incite other members of the Australian

Meat Industry Employees' Union to refuse to work with the applicant

(c) to obstruct the employment of the applicant at the Bremer River Abattoir

and

(d)
to obstruct any payment by the applicant Union.

\

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY ) Nos Q8,9 and 10 of 1981
INDUSTRIAL DIVISION 1

BETWEEN:

ROLAND HARVEY VALL PEARSON

Applicant

AND :

RICHARD ANEAR and others

Respondents

BETWEEN:

LYNDA JOY PETERSEN

Applicant

AND :

RICHARD ANEAR and others

- Respondents
BETWEEN :

LEE-ANN ELIZABETH SMITH

Applicant

AND :

RICHARD ANEAR and others

Respondents

FITZGERALD J. 15 OCTOBER 1982

-

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

This is the return of separate rules nisl

obtained by the respectlve applicants, each of whom
seeks an order pursuant to s.141 of the Concillation

and Arbltration Act 1904 directing the respondents to

perform and observe the rules of the Australian Meat

Industry Employees Unlon (the “A.M.I.E.U.”), an

organisation of employees registered pursuant to that

Act. The applications were heard together by agreement

and it is common ground that the result in each must be

L .

the same as in the others. The locus stand1 of the

applicants was not in question and no…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pearson Peterson & Smith v Richard Arear and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1982] FCA 221
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Roland Harvey Vall Pearson, Lynda Joy Petersen, and Lee-Ann Elizabeth Smith, sought orders under Section 141 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904 against the respondents, including Richard Anear, the Secretary of the Queensland Branch of the Australian Meat Industry Employees' Union (AMIEU). The applicants sought directions for the respondents to perform and observe the Rules of the AMIEU, specifically to cease actions that prevented their employment and obstructed their ability to make payments to the union. The dispute arose from the applicants' refusal to contribute to a levy for delegates' expenses, leading to their exclusion from union activities and employment at the Bremer River Abattoir.

The court considered whether the respondents' actions were justified under the union's rules and the Act. It noted that the decision-making process for the levy did not comply with the Act and union rules, and there was no clear evidence that the applicants had previously contributed to similar levies. The court found that the penalty imposed on the applicants was disproportionate and not a legitimate response to their refusal to make the payment. It concluded that the respondents' actions were fundamentally incompatible with the nature and purpose of unionism and legislative intent.

The court granted orders directing the respondents to cease actions that obstructed the applicants' employment and payments to the union, and for Richard Anear to stop supporting the other respondents in those actions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established