DARRYL JOHN PEARCE & GERALDINE ANNE PEARCE v MELLOR OLSSON
[2000] SADC 42
Judge Lunn
Civil.
REASONS ON THE APPEAL AGAINST THE ORDER OF A MASTER REFUSING TO STRIKE OUT THE ACTION.
The plaintiffs have sued the defendant by a summons issued on 6 October 1999. The defendant is a firm of solicitors which has been sued in its firm name. The plaintiffs have not been legally represented in these proceedings. The plaintiffs became bankrupt on 11 December 1996 and were discharged from that bankruptcy on 12 December 1999.
The plaintiffs’ causes of action as pleaded in their amended statement of claim filed on 24 January 2000 can be paraphrased as follows. On 8 September 1994 the 1st plaintiff was injured in a road accident. The plaintiffs retained the defendant to claim damages on their behalf resulting from this accident. The defendant instituted an action in this Court for that purpose. On 8 October 1996 the defendant in that action lodged an offer to consent to judgment for $50,000. The defendant misrepresented to the plaintiffs the effect of this offer and negligently did not advise them of its true effect. The plaintiffs rejected the offer and the action went to trial. The defendant negligently failed to put before the trial Judge evidence of the 1st plaintiff’s good character and honesty. The trial Judge did not believe the evidence of the 1st plaintiff, dismissed the claim and ordered costs against the plaintiffs. The causes of action which are to be distilled from the pleadings are in contract and tort that the defendant breached its duties to the plaintiffs by misrepresenting the effect of the lodged offer and by not giving proper advice about its effect and separately in not putting forward character evidence at the trial. These are merely allegations in the amended statement of claim. Whether they can be proved or not is not my present concern.
The amended statement of claim then pleaded various heads of damage which the plaintiffs had suffered as a result of the causes of action, although without always separating what loss allegedly flowed from which breach. I paraphrase these pleaded heads of damages as follows:
1...... The moneys which the plaintiffs would have recovered if the offer to consent had been accepted.
In the alternative to 1, the damages which the plaintiffs would have recovered if the action had gone to trial and the Judge had believed the 1st plaintiff.
On the cause of action related to not calling the character evidence “severe embarrassment, loss of personal reputation and self-respect”.
As a result of the bankruptcy of the plaintiffs the “loss of personal reputation, embarrassments, inconveniences” they thereby suffered.
As a result of the bankruptcy “lost opportunities” (which are not particularised) and financial loss attributable to the loss of their home.
It is the nature of the items of damage claimed which is in issue here and so the lack of particularity in some instances is not relevant on this application.
On 18 October…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pearce v Mellor Olsson No. DCCIV-99-1436 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SADC 42
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the plaintiffs’ causes of action and the resultant damages claimed were for personal injury or a property right. If the latter, they would vest in the trustee in bankruptcy and could not be pursued by the plaintiffs. The court considered the relevant provisions of the Bankruptcy Act and judicial authorities on the interpretation of "personal injury" and "personal wrong". The court held that the plaintiffs' claim for what they would have recovered if their accident action had been successful should be characterised as a property right, not personal injury. However, the damages for personal embarrassment and loss of reputation were for personal injury and could be pursued by the plaintiffs. The court also found that the plaintiffs' discharge from bankruptcy did not revest any property in them.
The appeal was allowed, and the order of the Master refusing to strike out parts of the statement of claim was set aside. The plaintiffs could only pursue their claims for personal injury damages, while the other claims had vested in the trustee in bankruptcy. The court noted that the plaintiffs may be able to obtain an assignment of the vested claims from the trustee and potentially incorporate them into this action under a new rule coming into effect on 3 June 2000. The plaintiffs were also advised of their right of appeal to the Supreme Court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi