PDTW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

PDTW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2023] AATA 152 (4 January 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/9993

Re:PDTW

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndWFMH

OTHER PARTY

Decision

Tribunal:Member Lee Benjamin

Date:4 January 2023

Date of written reasons:        15 February 2023

Place:    Brisbane

The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Social Services and Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 23 November 2021 and substitutes a decision that the Applicant be granted an extension of time (to 3 February 2023), to seek review of the Respondent’s decision dated 23 August 2021.

.........................[SGD ]............................

Member Lee Benjamin

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

PRACTICE and PROCEEDURE - application for extension of time - where application refused in first instance - where notification of decision sent to wrong address - where applicant appealed in timely way - extension of time granted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988

Cases

Brown v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 99 ATC 4516

Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Minister for Home Affairs and Environment (1984) 3 FCR 344
Johnson and Commonwealth of Australia [1990] AATA 1
Kuljic v Secretary, Department of Social Security (1994) 33 ALD 121

Zizza v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 55 ALD 451

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member Lee Benjamin

15 February 2023

The decision under review

  1. The Applicant’s substantive application seeks review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Social Services & Child Support Division) (AAT1) made on 23 November 2021. The decision of the AAT1 was to refuse to grant an extension of time to seek review of a decision of the Child Support Registrar (the Respondent or Registrar) dated 23 August 2021.

    Issue

  2. The issue before this Tribunal is whether it is reasonable in all of the circumstances to grant the Applicant an extension of time to make his application to the AAT1 to review the decision made by the Registrar dated 23 August 2021.

    Background

  3. The Applicant and Other Party are the separated parents of C1 (born 2003) and C2 (born 2005) (the children).

  4. On 12 February 2021, the Applicant filed an application with Services Australia (the Agency) for a change of assessment (Exhibit 1, T5, p 30) for the following reasons:

    (a)C1 is working full time as an apprentice carpenter and earns significant income;

    (b)The Other Party has recorded an increase in income whilst the Applicant has no income; and

    (c)The Applicant has a duty to support two other children.

  5. The Applicant’s request for change of assessment was refused on 14 April 2021 as a reason had not been established (Exhibit 1, T18, p 65).

  6. On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PDTW and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 152
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for an extension of time to seek review of a child support objection decision. The applicant, PDTW, sought to appeal a decision made by the Child Support Registrar on 23 August 2021, which had been partially allowed. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) had previously refused the applicant's application for an extension of time to lodge his review application, determining it was seven days out of time. The applicant then sought review of the AAT's decision in this Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it was reasonable in all the circumstances to grant the applicant an extension of time to lodge his application for review of the Registrar's objection decision. This involved considering the length of the delay, the applicant's awareness of his appeal rights, and the explanation provided for the delay. The Tribunal also had to determine whether the applicant had been properly notified of the Registrar's decision, given his assertion that the notification was sent to an incorrect email address.

The Tribunal considered that the delay of seven days was not substantial. Crucially, the applicant argued that he was unaware of the Registrar's decision until he discovered it on the myGov portal, as the notification had been sent to an old and redundant work email address, despite the Registrar having acknowledged his correct email address on 9 July 2020. The Tribunal accepted this explanation, finding that the applicant had not received due notification of the decision due to the incorrect email address being used. This lack of proper notification was considered a sufficient reason to grant an extension of time.

The Tribunal ordered that the applicant be granted an extension of time to lodge his application for review of the Registrar's objection decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue before this Tribunal is whether it is reasonable in all of the circumstances to grant the Applicant an extension of time to make his application to the AAT1 to review the decision made by the Registrar dated 23 August 2021. Background The Applicant and Other Party are the separated parents of C1 (born 2003) and C2 (born 2005) (the children). On 12 February 2021, the Applicant filed an application with Services Australia (the Agency) for a change of assessment (Exhibit 1, T5, p 30) for the following reasons: (a)C1 is working full time as an apprentice carpenter and earns significant income; (b)The Other Party has recorded an increase in income whilst the Applicant has no income; and(c)The Applicant has a duty to support two other children. The Applicant’s request for change of assessment was refused on 14 April 2021 as a reason had not been established (Exhibit 1, T18, p 65). On 13 May 2021, the Applicant lodged an objection to the decision to refuse his request for change of assessment (Exhibit 1, T19, p 72). A decision was made by an authorised objections officer in the Agency on 23 August 2021 who allowed the objection in part (objection decision) (Exhibit 1, T30, p 114). The Applicant submits that the decision was made 103 days after the objection application was made. The Applicant drew the Tribunals attention to subsection 87(1)(b) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Collection Act). This provides that within 60 days of the objection being lodged, the Registrar must either disallow the objection or allow it in whole or in part (Exhibit 5, p 2 at [5]). The Respondent contends that this decision was delivered to the Applicant electronically on 30 August 2021 (Exhibit 2, Attachment E). The Application denies that the decision was delivered to the Applicant electronically on 30 August 2021 and says that the Registrar sent the email notification to an incorrect email address (Exhibit 5, p 1 at [3]). On 4 October 2021 the Applicant applied for review in the AAT1 of the objection decision (Exhibit 2, Attachment A). On 23 November 2021 the AAT1 determined that the application was lodged out of time (by seven days) and refused to grant an extension of time to seek review of the objection decision (Exhibit 1, T2, p 4). On 20 December 2021 the Applicant sought review in this Tribunal of the AAT1 decision refusing to grant an extension of time to seek review of the objection decision (Exhibit 1, T1, p 1). The Registrar issued a Departure Prohibition Order against the Applicant on 22 February 2022 which the Applicant says has adversely affected his ability to gain employment. As at 7 June 2022, the Applicant says that his child support arrears were $7,088.10. By decision dated 25 February 2022, the Tribunal decided to join the Other Party as a party to these proceedings (Exhibit 2, Attachment B). On 1 August 2022, a Hearing was held for this application. At the Hearing, the Applicant and the Other Patty appeared by telephone, were self-represented and gave evidence under affirmation. The Respondent was represented by TinYan Wong of Services Australia, who appeared by telephone.Legislation and case law principles

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant provided the following explanation for the delay in filing his application: “MEMBER: I’m interested to hear about the length of delay. What is the reason?APPLICANT: The reason is…Member, is after 103 days I stopped looking at the myGov portal. It’s an unreasonable timeframe. I was aware that an objection decision was required to be made by the registrar within 60 days. I was checking the portal regularly up until that point. In my initiating application I had a screen shot of when I noted, and I was looking for a - on myGov portal for another matter I noted that there was a letter there from the registrar. I read it and immediately acted on that, but prior to that I simply wasn’t aware of it and that was due to the 103 days’ timeline between my application and the decision, and also I wasn’t - I do not receive any notification, and the registrar’s asserting that I was notified and my response to that is I wasn’t because you sent it to the wrong email address, even though on 9 July 2020 you acknowledged by email that you had my current email address…The reason is that I simply do not get any alert or any information from the registrar in relation to the decision, and as soon as I did - and I wasn’t (indistinct) standing on my rights, Member. I was waiting for a decision. And what I would add to that is when I have a statement of account it gets mailed to me. When the part share prohibition order was filed against me, that was mailed to me. The registrar doesn’t seem to have any issue contacting me on these other matters, but in this matter they delayed for 103 days, and then sent it to the wrong email address.…MEMBER: ...So if I could just summarise, and correct [me] if I’m mishearing you, PDTW, your submission is that you didn’t receive due notification of the registrar’s decision. You say that it was sent to the wrong email address…is that what your submission is?APPLICANT: That’s exactly what I’m saying, Member.”MEMBER: Okay.APPLCIANT: And in the T documents where the registrar outlines the fact that I received a notification you will clearly note the email that that notification was sent to was redundant.MEMBER: Can you just direct me exactly to where in the bundle that is?…APPLICANT: In the registrar’s outline of submissions, Member, it is paragraph 9.…APPLICANT: Yes. And you will note that submission, and then you will note there is reference to an attachment E.MEMBER: Yes. APPLICANT: And you will note the email address.MEMBER: It says [email address redacted]APPLICANT: Yes.MEMBER: Okay. And so what should have the …MEMBER: The [email address redacted] account?APPLICANT: Yes, that’s correct, Member.MEMBER: Okay. APPLICANT: And if I may make a further comment in relation to that?MEMBER: Yes.APPLICANT: I have never given that email address to Services Australia, because that was actually my work address.MEMBER: Work address. Yes, okay.APPLICANT: And I certainly don’t have private matters going to work address. And also that work address was redundant regardless because I no longer worked there, because the company doesn’t exist.MEMBER: Okay.APPLICANT: And you will note that the registrar did acknowledge that on annexure 1 of the applicant’s statement of issues and facts which is easy to find.MEMBER: Yes.APPLICANT: You will note that I received a note or an email from them on 9 July and …APPLICANT: It’s page 3 of exhibit 5, Member. MEMBER: Page 3? Yes. This looks like a - does this refer to the adding of an email address to the MyGov account, is that what this is that’s linking the child support or service to your MyGov account, is that what that APPLICANT: Yes, and it’s also confirming where notifications would go. So that was a consequent - this email came about as a consequence of a conversation that I had on 8 July with the Child Support Agency in relation to me notifying them of my redundancy.MEMBER: Okay.APPLICANT: I, at that point in time, confirmed that I would receive electronic communication, and provided that correct email address, and yet the notification subsequent to that went to an old address.” (emphasis added) (Transcript, p 9, lines 42-47, p 10, lines 1-47, p 11, lines 1-47, p 12, lines 1-27)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The application of these principles to sections 91 and 92 of the Collection Act has been affirmed by the Tribunal on numerous occasions (see, e.g., ZWHJ and Child Support Registrar [2020] AATA 2323; RLDY and Child Support Registrar [2020] AATA 688; PRZR and Child Support Registrar [2019] AATA 4617) (Exhibit 2, p 5, at [24]). consideration In considering the issue before this Tribunal, I have had regard to the evidence and submissions placed before it, in writing and made at the Hearing. In applying the relevant principles to the evidence before me, I make the conclusions set out below.Length of delay The Applicant does not dispute that his substantive application to the AAT1 was lodged seven days beyond the stipulated statutory deadline. The length of delay involved in a case is a relevant consideration. The Respondent concedes that “it is not [a] long [delay]…” (Transcript, p 5, lines 40-43). On the one hand, the short delay does not automatically mean that an extension of time ought to be granted. On the other hand, an extension of time should be granted if it is proper to do so. Awareness of appeal rights and explanation for the delay The Applicant does not dispute that he was aware of his appeal rights:“MEMBER: Can I confirm that you were aware of your appeal rights and that you were aware that the number of days was 28 to appeal, but in response to that you say that you were not aware until much later?APPLICANT: Yes, Member, because I couldn’t appeal the decision, because, in my mind, no decision has been made because I had not been notified of it.MEMBER: And how long after you were - so, what is the date on which you say you were aware of the decision?…APPLICANT: And as soon as I was aware of it I lodged with AAT.” (Transcript, p 12, lines 29-37, p 13, lines 1-6) The Respondent contends that the Applicant has provided not provided a substantive explanation for the delay in filing his application (Transcript, p 5, lines 43-45). With due respect to the Respondent, I do not accept this contention. The Applicant provided the following explanation for the delay in filing his application: “MEMBER: I’m interested to hear about the length of delay. What is the reason?APPLICANT: The reason is…Member, is after 103 days I stopped looking at the myGov portal. It’s an unreasonable timeframe. I was aware that an objection decision was required to be made by the registrar within 60 days. I was checking the portal regularly up until that point. In my initiating application I had a screen shot of when I noted, and I was looking for a - on myGov portal for another matter I noted that there was a letter there from the registrar. I read it and immediately acted on that, but prior to that I simply wasn’t aware of it and that was due to the 103 days’ timeline between my application and the decision, and also I wasn’t - I do not receive any notification, and the registrar’s asserting that I was notified and my response to that is I wasn’t because you sent it to the wrong email address, even though on 9 July 2020 you acknowledged by email that you had my current email address…The reason is that I simply do not get any alert or any information from the registrar in relation to the decision, and as soon as I did - and I wasn’t (indistinct) standing on my rights, Member. I was waiting for a decision. And what I would add to that is when I have a statement of account it gets mailed to me. When the part share prohibition order was filed against me, that was mailed to me. The registrar doesn’t seem to have any issue contacting me on these other matters, but in this matter they delayed for 103 days, and then sent it to the wrong email address.…MEMBER: ...So if I could just summarise, and correct [me] if I’m mishearing you, PDTW, your submission is that you didn’t receive due notification of the registrar’s decision. You say that it was sent to the wrong email address…is that what your submission is?APPLICANT: That’s exactly what I’m saying, Member.”MEMBER: Okay.APPLCIANT: And in the T documents where the registrar outlines the fact that I received a notification you will clearly note the email that that notification was sent to was redundant.MEMBER: Can you just direct me exactly to where in the bundle that is?…APPLICANT: In the registrar’s outline of submissions, Member, it is paragraph 9.…APPLICANT: Yes. And you will note that submission, and then you will note there is reference to an attachment E.MEMBER: Yes. APPLICANT: And you will note the email address.MEMBER: It says [email address redacted]APPLICANT: Yes.MEMBER: Okay. And so what should have the …MEMBER: The [email address redacted] account?APPLICANT: Yes, that’s correct, Member.MEMBER: Okay. APPLICANT: And if I may make a further comment in relation to that?MEMBER: Yes.APPLICANT: I have never given that email address to Services Australia, because that was actually my work address.MEMBER: Work address. Yes, okay.APPLICANT: And I certainly don’t have private matters going to work address. And also that work address was redundant regardless because I no longer worked there, because the company doesn’t exist.MEMBER: Okay.APPLICANT: And you will note that the registrar did acknowledge that on annexure 1 of the applicant’s statement of issues and facts which is easy to find.MEMBER: Yes.APPLICANT: You will note that I received a note or an email from them on 9 July and …APPLICANT: It’s page 3 of exhibit 5, Member. MEMBER: Page 3? Yes. This looks like a - does this refer to the adding of an email address to the MyGov account, is that what this is that’s linking the child support or service to your MyGov account, is that what that APPLICANT: Yes, and it’s also confirming where notifications would go. So that was a consequent - this email came about as a consequence of a conversation that I had on 8 July with the Child Support Agency in relation to me notifying them of my redundancy.MEMBER: Okay.APPLICANT: I, at that point in time, confirmed that I would receive electronic communication, and provided that correct email address, and yet the notification subsequent to that went to an old address.” (emphasis added) (Transcript, p 9, lines 42-47, p 10, lines 1-47, p 11, lines 1-47, p 12, lines 1-27)