PCJN and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

PCJN and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2023] AATA 403 (17 March 2023)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2022/5905          

Re:PCJN  

APPLICANT

Child Support RegistrarAnd  

RESPONDENT

AndHPPG

OTHER PARTY

Decision

Tribunal:Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC

Date:17 March 2023

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review, which is remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration with the following directions:

(a)Special circumstances prevented the Applicant from objecting to the amended care percentage within the allowable timeframe. The Tribunal exercises the discretion at s 87AA(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) to extend the time for the Applicant to lodge her objection to 16 December 2021.

(b)There was no terminating event on 5 April 2016 to justify a change in care percentages. The Tribunal revokes the Respondent’s decision dated 6 February 2020, which amended the percentage of care as of 5 April 2016 to 0% for both the mother and father.

(c)Consistent with the care determination in place since 28 January 2010, the percentage of care has consistently remained at 100% care by the mother and 0% for the father.

(d)The date of effect of this decision is 5 April 2016.

.........................[sgd]............................................

Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether parent continues to provide care where child living with grandmother – whether parent has responsibility for making decisions in relation to the welfare of the child – whether parent continues to provide financial and emotional support – special circumstances in time taken to lodge objection– decision under review set aside

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth), ss 79D, 87A, 87AA, 89, 96A(b)
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth), ss 7B, 22, 51, 54A, 54F, 54G, 54H, 55C

Child Support (Assessment) Regulations 2018 (Cth)

Cases

Allman v Setford [2019] AATA 1197

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60
Minister for Home Affairs v G (2019) 164 ALD 103
Nathanson v Minister for Home Affairs (2022) 96 ALJR 737
P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
Polec & Staker (2011) 253 FLR 339

Shi v Migration Agent Review Authority [2008] 235 CLR 286

Secondary Materials

Child Support Guide Version 4.69 - Released 6 February 2023

Anonyms are used in this decision because the dispute involves the interests of a minor child, which merit protection. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed and replaced with generic information so as not to identify individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)-16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (“Collection Act”).

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC

17 March 2023

INTRODUCTION

  1. The parties and witnesses in this matter are set out in the following table:

Ms AA

 17-year-old child of PCJN and HPPG

PCJN

 Ms AA’s biological mother (also referred to as “the mother”)

HPPG

 Ms AA’s biological father…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PCJN and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 403
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of a decision by Services Australia regarding the percentage of care for a child, Ms AA. The dispute arose from the father's claim that the mother had not been the primary carer for Ms AA for at least five years, leading to a review of the care percentages. The mother contended that despite Ms AA residing with her own grandmother, Ms GR1, for schooling purposes, she retained the primary decision-making authority and continued to provide financial and emotional support.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Ms AA's living arrangements with her grandmother constituted a change in the primary care percentage from 5 April 2016. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider whether special circumstances justified the mother's delay in lodging her objection to the amended child support decision within the permissible timeframe. The father's claim was that Ms GR1 had assumed full custody and financial responsibility for Ms AA, thereby negating the need for child support payments.

The Tribunal found the grandmother, Ms GR1, to be a credible witness, and accepted that any financial or practical contributions she made were acts of love for her granddaughter. The Tribunal accepted the mother's evidence that she retained decision-making power regarding Ms AA's education, medical care, and general welfare, even when Ms AA resided with Ms GR1 for schooling. The Tribunal concluded that Ms GR1 provided delegated care, which was arranged by the mother, and this did not diminish the mother's status as the principal carer. The Tribunal also found that special circumstances, including the mother's intellectual disability, intermittent mental health issues, and difficulties exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, prevented her from lodging her objection within the required time.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review. It exercised its discretion to extend the time for the mother to lodge her objection and revoked the decision that amended the care percentages to 0% for both parents from 5 April 2016. The Tribunal determined that the care percentage had consistently remained at 100% for the mother and 0% for the father since 28 January 2010, with the date of effect for this decision being 5 April 2016.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has decided to set aside the decision under review.BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY In response to the father’s claim that Ms AA had not been cared for by the mother ‘for at least five years’, Services Australia asked him why he continued to pay child support and did not report the change in care much earlier? His response is recorded as follows:‘…[The mother] is difficult and he wanted to keep the peace and he was allowed to visit his daughter regularly at her grandmother’s house. He stated that he has had enough, and he cannot agree with $2,048.75 to pay back to her when [Ms AA] is not being cared for by [the mother].[8] [8] Ibid 24. Even at this early stage, and prior to the mother or Ms GR1 responding to the father’s claim, Departmental records state that the ‘most likely decision type’ was to reduce the percentage of care of both the mother and father to ‘0%’:‘*Based on the information obtained from [the father], the most likely decision type will be:Actual - actual care, where there is no court order, parenting plan, or written agreement.Below 14% Care - below regular determination is made when the current care is 14% or more and Child Support is notified that the care has not or has ceased to be in accordance with that care.Calculator summary for child: [Ms AA]--------------------------------------------------Care period start date: 01/01/2014Care period end date: 31/12/2014Care detailsCustomer percentage: 0%Customer care level: Below regular careOther party percentage: 0% There are references in the Departmental records to the father being asked to provide supporting evidence for his claims.[9] He subsequently lodged two statements from his mother and sister-in-law as follows:(a)A letter from Ms GR2 dated 12 November 2019,[10] which stated that the mother was receiving child support payments while Ms AA was living with and relying ‘on her grandmother to financially support her’. (b)A letter from HPPG’s sister-in-law dated 26 November 2019, which is in comparable terms to Ms GR2’s letter.[11] The author claimed she had built up ‘an online friendship’ with the mother, who purportedly admitted to her that: the father’s child support payments were used ‘to financially support herself’; and Ms AA was financially supported by her maternal grandmother. The sister-in-law further claimed she had text messages from Ms GR1 dated August 2016 confirming this arrangement. Finally, the sister-in-law stated she had ‘access to [Ms GR1’s] partner’s…social media’, with pictures posted of Ms AA attending venues in the vicinity of her grandparent’s residence. The sister-in-law was not called by the father to give evidence at this hearing and the 2016 text messages were not tendered.[9] Ibid 25.[10] Ibid 26.[11] Ibid 33-39.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK AND PRINCIPLES Section 25(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), in conjunction with ss 87A and 96A(b) of the Collection Act, enliven the Tribunal’s jurisdiction in this matter.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This application turns on whether the care arrangement for Ms AA changed from 5 April 2016 because she began residing with Ms GR1 during school weeks.[19] Consideration must also be given to the mother’s delay in lodging her objection within the permissible timeframe. and whether special circumstances prevented her from doing so.[19] The Father has been determined to have 0% care for the Child and has made no claim this determination is incorrect or needs to be varied. Mother’s Evidence A central pillar of the mother’s oral evidence, and submissions on her behalf by Ms Stoilkovska, is that she retained decision-making power over Ms AA, irrespective of where the child lived, the amount of financial contribution made, or the effects of her illness. This includes having the ‘final say’ on issues such as Ms AA’s schooling, medical care, and general welfare. The Applicant contends that the circumstances did not justify a change in the care determination that had been in place since January 2010. The mother’s evidence is summarised as follows:(a)There was a period where the father had court-ordered access when Ms AA was initially born, which expired long ago. The father’s contact with Ms AA since has been ‘pretty spontaneous’ and the mother estimated he ‘maybe had her ten to fifteen times throughout her whole life’. She claimed the father was largely uninvolved with Ms AA and had not seen her for several years. This is disputed by the father, although not much turns on this in circumstances where a 100% to 0% assessment had been in place in favour of the mother for almost a decade prior to the father seeking a percentage of care review. (b)The mother said she and Ms AA lived with Ms GR1 for most of their lives, except for a period when she rented a premises in a seaside town approximately 150 km from Melbourne (“the seaside rental”). There is no independent corroboration regarding the duration of the lease, but the mother said it expired in August 2019, after which she resumed living with Ms GR1. The mother said she was living at the seaside rental in April 2016, when Ms AA went to live with Ms GR1, predominantly for schooling purposes. The mother said she suffered periodic mental illness at this time and did not want Ms AA to see her when unwell. She said the intended duration of this arrangement was undefined and depended on her illness. The mother described the seaside rental as their ‘happy place’ and was grateful Ms GR1 assisted her with Ms AA’s care. The mother said Ms GR1 routinely brought Ms AA to stay with her at the seaside rental on weekends and public holidays. A bedroom in the house continued to be maintained exclusively for Ms AA’s use. On other occasions, the mother stayed with Ms AA at Ms GR1’s home.(c)In terms of decision-making, the mother said that even when her mental health was poor, ‘nothing happened [regarding Ms AA] without [her] say so’. She decided matters relating to Ms AA’s education, medical care, approval for camps or excursions, and who Ms AA spent time with after school hours. Both she and Ms GR1 attended parent-teacher meetings, because the mother has never held a driver’s licence and Ms GR1 drove her to appointments. (d)When asked about a report in evidence that legal guardianship for Ms AA passed to Ms GR1 at some stage in 2016, the mother explained she had to complete a Statutory Declaration for Ms AA’s school enrolment. The mother said Ms GR1 did many of the things a loving grandmother does, which included funding most of Ms AA’s $6000 annual school fees. The mother said she contributed to these fees as her financial situation allowed and paid for other costs such as uniforms and books. She routinely reimbursed Ms GR1 for expenditure relating to Ms AA. After moving in with Ms GR1 when the tenancy on the seaside rental ended, she made an even greater financial contribution.(e)The mother said she sometimes transferred money electronically to Ms GR1 and provided cash at other times. She did not keep records for this amicable family arrangement, because it had never occurred to her or Ms GR1 that this was necessary. The mother said she often took Ms AA shopping for clothes and shared the costs of food with Ms GR1 when they were under the same roof. When Ms AA stayed at the rental premises on ‘the majority of weekends’ and school holidays, the mother said she funded all their requirements.(f)When asked if she ever kept the father’s child support contributions for herself, the mother replied: ‘Never’. When asked if she ever told any of the father’s relatives that she used child support money for herself, the mother responded: ‘No’.(g)When asked about her sources of income, the mother said she receives DSP as a result of her intellectual disability and other physical and psychological conditions. Her memory and ability to process information is consequently affected, and she has trouble engaging with bureaucratic or legal issues without assistance. She relies predominantly on Ms GR1 for this. The mother claimed to be suffering severe ill-health, feeling overwhelmed, and ‘backed into a corner’ when the Respondent initiated the percentage of care review in late 2019. This was exacerbated by difficulties in contacting the Department once the COVID-19 Pandemic struck in early 2020. She feared no one would believe her and was at a loss to understand how the father’s claims could be believed, when neither he nor his relatives had any personal knowledge of how Ms AA’s care was organised. Ms GR1’s Evidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is satisfied that any financial or practical contribution made by Ms GR1 to Ms AA’s care were the loving acts of someone who wants the best for their granddaughter. The mother’s financial contribution was commensurate with her financial capacity. This should not be seen as a zero-sum-game, where the contribution of a grandmother diminishes that of the mother. Family interactions are not like that. The essence of Ms GR1’s evidence, which the Tribunal accepts, is that she provided delegated care[25] for Ms AA, which the mother organised. Arranging delegated care is still credited to the mother.[26] [25] Polec & Staker (2011) 253 FLR 339.[26] The Assessment Act, s 54F(3).DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review, which is remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration with the following directions:(a)Special circumstances prevented the Applicant from objecting to the amended care percentage within the allowable timeframe. The Tribunal exercises the discretion at s 87AA(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) to extend the time for the Applicant to lodge her objection to 16 December 2021.(b)There was no terminating event on 5 April 2016 to justify a change in care percentages. The Tribunal revokes the Respondent’s decision dated 6 February 2020, which amended the percentage of care as of 5 April 2016 to 0% for both the mother and father.(c)Consistent with the care determination in place since 28 January 2010, the percentage of care has consistently remained at 100% care by the mother and 0% for the father.(d)The date of effect of this decision is 5 April 2016.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Closing submissions are summarised as follows:(a)Ms Stoilkovska said the mother continued to be the main decision-maker for Ms AA, irrespective of day-to-day living arrangements. She said no weight should be given to the claims made by the father and his relatives, because they had ‘no direct knowledge of what occurred’ between the mother, Ms GR1, and Ms AA. Ms Stoilkovska cited Allman v Setford[23] as apposite to this matter. She also emphasised that any delay in the mother formally objecting to the amended child support decision arose from special factors, including her intellectual disability and intermittent mental health issues, which made her feel overwhelmed. This was exacerbated by access issues during the COVID Pandemic and Ms GR1’s absence in Tasmania. It was only after Ms GR1 returned to the mainland, that the mother got the support she needed to lodge an objection. Ms Stoilkovska said denying the mother’s appeal because of this delay ‘would cause great hardship’, which was unwarranted.(b)Mr Noonan made closing submissions consistent with the RSFIC. (c)When invited to make closing submissions, the father re-stated his belief that PCJN gave ‘full custody’ of Ms AA to Ms GR1 in 2014 and ‘did not provide any financial assistance at all’. On that basis, he should not be expected to pay child support. TRIBUNAL CONSIDERATION[23] Allman v Setford [2019] AATA 1197.Change in the care of the child? The Tribunal found Ms GR1 to be an honest, forthright, and persuasive witness. Aspects of the mother’s evidence, however, were inconsistent at times, resulting in the Tribunal warning her on several occasions about interjecting when others, including the father, gave evidence. The Tribunal accepts this may have been contributed to by conditions the mother suffers, as detailed in medical and other records. That said, key aspects of the mother’s evidence regarding the care of Ms AA were consistent with that of Ms GR1. In contrast, the basis of the father’s claim that Ms GR1 assumed full custody and financial responsibility for Ms AA since 2014 or 2015 came across as uncorroborated assertion at best. This is only reinforced by Departmental records where several requests for the father to provide evidence, did not elicit more than supportive assertions from his relatives. The Tribunal accepts the father visited Ms GR1’s home to pick up Ms AA, but this was relatively infrequent. Neither he nor the relatives who support his version of events could have known where the mother was, or what financial and practical arrangements were agreed with Ms GR1 for Ms AA’s care. There is also no challenge to Ms GR1’s evidence that she never applied for benefits to support Ms AA, because the mother already received these and continued to perform the principal carer and decision-making roles. The father’s claim that both Ms GR1 and the mother told him and other relatives that child support funds were not being spent on Ms AA, was expressly denied by Ms GR1 and the mother. No reliable finding can be made about this.