PCBQ and Commissioner for Fair Trading (NSW) [2022] AATA 3725 (4 November 2022)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2020/4795
Re:PCBQ
APPLICANT
AndCommissioner for Fair Trading (NSW)
RESPONDENT
Decision
Tribunal:The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President
Mr S Evans, Member
Date:13 September 2022
Date of decision: 4 November 2022
Place:Sydney
The Applicant’s Contractor – Builder (General Building Work) licence is varied to include the conditions set out in this decision.
..................................[Sgd]......................................
The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President
Catchwords
MUTUAL RECOGNITION — Application of Mutual Recognition Act 1992 (Cth) — Registration of construction contractor — Application of mutual recognition principles — Substantial equivalence of occupations — Applicant a registered builder in Victoria — registered in New South Wales — Registered by operation of section 21(4) - Whether activities of builder substantially the same as those of a builder under respective registrations – whether restrictions necessary to achieve substantial equivalence — registration varied to include restrictions.
Legislation
Mutual Recognition Act 1992 (Cth)
Cases
Rowe and New South Wales Police Service (1997) 47 ALD 442
Turner and Registrar, Supreme Court of Queensland (No. 2) [2003] AATA 887Secretary, Department of Social Security v Wetter (1993) 29 ALD 310
Secondary Materials
Building Regulations 2018 (Vic)
Home Building Regulations 2014 (NSW)
REASONS FOR DECISION
The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President
Mr S Evans, Member4 November 2022
Introduction
PCBQ (the Applicant) relocated to New South Wales (NSW) from Victoria where he was registered as a Domestic builder (limited to carpentry) (the Victorian licence). In February 2020 the Applicant lodged an application for a Contractor – Builder (General Building Work) licence with appropriate conditions with the Department of Fair Trading NSW relying on provisions of the Mutual Recognition Act 1992 (Cth) (the MRA).[1]
[1] PCBQ and Commissioner of Fair Trading (NSW) [2021] AATA 1436, [4]
The Commissioner of Fair Trading (NSW) (the Respondent) refused to issue the Applicant the licence requested. Instead, the Applicant was offered a combination of two residential building work licenses – a Carpentry licence and a Kitchen, bathroom and laundry renovation licence.[2]
[2] PCBQ and Commissioner of Fair Trading (NSW) [2021] AATA 1436, [7]
The Applicant was not satisfied that the combination of licences offered by the Respondent would enable him to perform substantially the same building work in NSW that he was authorised to carry out in Victoria.[3] Further, he argued that he was entitled to immediate registration as the Respondent had not met its obligation to process his application within one month of lodgement as required by subsection 21(4) of the MRA.[4]
[3] PCBQ and Commissioner of Fair Trading (NSW) [2021] AATA 1436, [6]
[4] PCBQ and Commissioner of Fair Trading (NSW) [2021] AATA 1436, [12]
On 16 July 2020 the Respondent formally refused his application for a Contractor – Builder (General Building Work) licence and the Applicant sought review of the decision at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read PCBQ and Commissioner for Fair Trading (NSW) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] AATA 3725
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant's Victorian builder's registration was substantially equivalent to the requirements for a builder's licence in New South Wales, and if not, what restrictions, if any, were necessary to achieve substantial equivalence under the *Mutual Recognition Act 1992*. This involved determining whether the occupational activities permitted under each registration were the same or to a sufficient degree of equivalence.
The Tribunal considered the purpose of the *Mutual Recognition Act 1992*, which is to facilitate the free movement of individuals between states by ensuring their occupational qualifications are recognised. While the Respondent initially argued for a focus on actual occupational activities rather than regulatory distinctions, they later conceded that framing the Applicant's licence by reference to specific "building work" categories in New South Wales would offer commercial benefits. The Tribunal found that while the Respondent had made concessions, excluding "general building works" from the Applicant's licence would place him at a substantial disadvantage in the New South Wales market. However, the Tribunal also noted that the Applicant's Victorian licence did not permit the construction of swimming pools, and as he had built one in New South Wales, it was appropriate to exclude swimming pools from his New South Wales licence to achieve equivalence.
The Tribunal remitted the matter to the Respondent with a direction that specific conditions, as set out in paragraph 45 of the decision, be applied to the Applicant's unrestricted New South Wales builder's licence. The Tribunal acknowledged the stressful and protracted nature of the Applicant's experience in seeking registration under the Mutual Recognition Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Respondent initially argued that distinguishing between building and a trade authorisations was an artificial distinction by name and the Tribunal should determine equivalency by examining the actual occupational activities carried out, and not the extent to which there are differences in naming between regulations.[27] However, after further consideration the Respondent conceded there were commercial benefits to the Applicant if his licence were to be framed by reference to the ‘building work’ categories in 13(a) of the NSW Regulations.[28] [27] Submissions of the Respondent dated 7 June 2022, [22][28] Transcript of the proceedings dated 13 September 2022, 56Consideration The purpose of the MRA is to enable individuals such as the Applicant to move freely from one state, present their credentials and be recognised as a qualified individual in another. One should not suffer disadvantage simply because the government and officials in one state decided to take a different regulatory approach to another state. The Respondent has made some concessions to accommodate the different constructions of the Victorian and NSW licensing regimes and achieve equivalency for the Applicant. Most notably, the offer to including the work category of structural landscaping with conditions and pre-fabricated metal structures. However, even with these concessions the Applicant’s capacity to work and achieve an income in his profession will be substantially affected if he does not continue to hold a contractors’ licence incorporating general building works, even one which carries restrictions imposed by the Tribunal. Apart from the acknowledged difficulties in establishing equivalency between two different regulatory regimes, the Applicant faces the additional challenge of applying the proposed conditions in the real world. The Applicant gave evidence, to which the Tribunal gave significant weight, that the approach proposed by the Respondent, whereby he is issued a limited contractor license excluding General building works, would place him at substantial disadvantage. He explained that when dealing with customers, local authorities and councils the perceived difference between a limited contractor licence and one which includes General building works is significant and would be an impediment when bidding for work, obtaining council approvals and dealing with customers and suppliers.[29] [29] Transcript of the proceedings dated 13 September 2022, 21 These considerations led us to prefer a simpler path to equivalence over any complex alternative. The Tribunal was given evidence by the Applicant that he had built a swimming pool since being issued a NSW builders licence.[30] He was entitled to do so, and there is no evidence to suggest this work was not compliant or in any way beyond his professional abilities. However, as his Victorian licence did not allow him to construct swimming pools, it is appropriate to exclude swimming pools from his NSW builders licence. [30] Transcript of the proceedings dated 13 September 2022, 25CONCLUSION