PC INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD and CITY OF ARMADALE

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   PC INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD and CITY OF ARMADALE [2023] WASAT 45

MEMBER:   MS R LAVERY, MEMBER

HEARD:   21, 22 AND 24 JUNE 2022 (WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS DATED 25 OCTOBER 2022, 15 FEBRUARY 2023, 28 FEBRUARY 2023 AND 13 MARCH 2023)

DELIVERED          :   23 JUNE 2023

FILE NO/S:   DR 252 of 2021

BETWEEN:   PC INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

CITY OF ARMADALE

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Demolition - Whether local heritage building should be demolished - Level of heritage significance - Feasibility of restoration or adaptive reuse - Feasibility of incorporation into redevelopment - Community benefit of proposed development - Weight to be given to inconsistency between proposed development and draft structure plan

Legislation:

City of Armadale Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 1.6, cl 3.2.11, cl 3.2.11(b), Sch 8, cl 66.1
Heritage Act 2018 (WA), s 103
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 1A(1)(e), cl 7, cl 8(1), cl 15(a)(ii), cl 27(2), cl 67(2), cl 67(2)(a), cl 67(2)(b), cl 67(2)(c), cl 67(2)(g), cl 67(2)(h), cl 67(2)(k), cl 67(2)(l), cl 67(2)(y), cl 67(2)(zb)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 241(1)(a), s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27(2)

Result:

Application for review dismissed
Decision of respondent is affirmed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr C Wallace
Respondent : Mr CA Slarke

Solicitors:

Applicant : Lavan
Respondent : McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

McDonald's Australia Limited and Presiding Member of the Metropolitan Central Joint Development Assessment Panel [2015] WASAT 146

Nicholls and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 40; (2005) 149 LGERA 117

Paz and City of Stirling [2011] WASAT 157

Rampono and City of Stirling [2014] WASAT 20

Terra Spei Pty Ltd and Shire of Kalamunda [2015] WASAT 134

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. PC Infrastructure Pty Ltd (applicant) made application to the City of Armadale (respondent, Council or City) for the demolition of an existing building known as 'The Manse' that is listed in the City's Heritage List (HL) and City of Armadale Local Heritage Survey (LHS) at No 31 (Lot 709) Church Avenue, Armadale (subject land or No 31).

  2. The application for development approval was lodged with the City on 18 June 2021 and refused by the respondent on 3 November 2021. On 30 November 2021 the applicant made application under s 252(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act) seeking an order that the Tribunal set aside the respondent's decision to refuse the application and grant development approval for the demolition of the building on the subject land.

Subject land

  1. The subject land is more particularly described as Lot 709 being the whole of land described on Certificate of Title Volume 2654 Folio 894, is 914m2 in area and is situated on Church Street,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PC INFRASTRUCTURE PTY LTD and CITY OF ARMADALE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASAT 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the State Administrative Tribunal involves a dispute between PC Infrastructure Pty Ltd and the City of Armadale over a development application seeking approval to demolish a local heritage building, known as The Manse, located in Armadale. The application raises questions about the cultural heritage significance of The Manse, the relevant statutory planning provisions, and their interaction with the draft Structure Plan.

The legal issues for the Tribunal to decide centred on whether the approval of the proposed demolition was the correct and preferable decision. Specifically, the Tribunal needed to assess the cultural heritage significance of The Manse, the relevant provisions in the South Metropolitan Regional Planning Scheme (SPP 3.5) and Local Planning Policy (LPP 3.8), and how these related to the draft Structure Plan. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's burden to justify the demolition based on the significance of the building, the feasibility of restoration or adaptation, the potential community benefits of the proposed redevelopment, and the relevance of local planning policies.

The Tribunal found that The Manse, while having considerable significance, was not of such a level to warrant exceptional measures to preserve it. The evidence presented by both parties, including expert opinions, indicated that while The Manse held considerable heritage value, it was feasible to restore or adapt the building, or incorporate it into the proposed redevelopment. The potential community benefits of the redevelopment, such as improved public facilities and infrastructure, were also considered significant. The Tribunal further noted that the draft Structure Plan did not explicitly mandate the preservation of The Manse, allowing for flexibility in the planning process.

Consequently, the Tribunal determined that the approval of the proposed demolition was the correct and preferable decision, taking into account the cultural heritage significance of The Manse, the relevant statutory provisions, and the draft Structure Plan. The Tribunal's decision recognised the need to balance heritage conservation with contemporary urban development needs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 6.5 of SPP 3.5 provides the specific matters that should be considered in assessing an application for approval to demolish a heritage place as: Alterations, extensions, change of use or demolition affecting a heritage place (including a place within a heritage area)•The level of heritage significance of the place, based on a relevant heritage assessment. •Measures proposed to conserve the heritage significance of the place and its setting. •The structural condition of the place, and whether the place is reasonably capable of conservation. •Whether the place is capable of adaptation to a new use which will enable its retention and conservation.[18][18] Respondent's s 24 Bundle of Documents, Tab 8, pages 262-267 - SPP 3.5, s 6.5 Government Gazette, WA 29 May 2007, page 2481. With respect to the proposed demolition of a heritage place, cl 6.6 of SPP 3.5 sets out the following development control principles: Demolition of a heritage place (including a place within a heritage area) •Demolition of a State heritage place is rarely appropriate and should require the strongest justification. Demolition of a local heritage place should be avoided wherever possible, although there will be circumstances where demolition is justified. The onus rests with the applicant to provide a clear justification for it. The parties identified the following issue for determination in relation to this matter:Is approval of the proposed demolition application the correct and preferable decision, having regard to: (a)the cultural heritage significance of the place; (b)SPP 3.5; (c)LPP 3.8; and (d)the draft Structure Plan. As these matters are interrelated, they will be dealt with together. The parties agree that SPP 3.5 at cl 6.6 sets the development principles for demolition of a local heritage place. Therefore, it is anticipated in applying for the demolition of The Manse the applicant will provide justification for the demolition on the basis of the four matters in cl 6.6. The four principle matters as agreed by the parties are:•the significance of the building or place;•the feasibility of restoring or adapting it, or incorporating it into new development;•the extent to which the community would benefit from the proposed redevelopment; and•any local planning policies relating to the demolition of heritage places. In relation to these matters the Tribunal had the benefit of expert evidence from Ms Laura Gwendolyn Gray a heritage and conservation consultant and Mr Nikolas Edward Hidding a town planning consultant called on behalf of the applicant, and Ms Flavia Boghossian Kiperman a heritage architect, Mr Joe Algeri a town planning consultant, and evidence from Mr Terence John Holton an architect, planner and member of the respondent's CHAG and resident of the City and Mr Jeffrey Errol Green a graduate architect and historian and long-time member of the City's CHAG called on behalf of the respondent. There is no dispute between the parties that The Manse has been included in the City of Armadale Municipal Heritage Inventory (MHI) and LHS since the inaugural document in 1995 when it was given a Category B level of significance in the MHI. The MHI, now LHS, has been reviewed three times in 2008, 2015 and 2019 by two separate heritage architects and the level of significance allocated to The Manse as Management Category 2 in the LHS has not diminished despite the changing context surrounding the place. The Manse maintains the equivalent level of significance to Category B, Management Category 2 pursuant to the LHS, meaning that the place has been consistently identified as having 'Considerable Significance'.