PBZB and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

PBZB and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 3385 (20 October 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/2584

Re:PBZB

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D. Barker

Date:20 October 2023  

Place:Sydney

  1. The Tribunal sets aside the Decision Under Review and remits this matter to the NDIA with a direction that within 14 days of the date of this Decision, the NDIA is to facilitate the approval of a new SOPS for PBZB (New SOPS) which includes the following provisions:

    (a)a provision specifying that the reassessment date will fall on the 12-month anniversary of the date of approval of the New SOPS (Reassessment Date);

    (b)provisions approving funding for:

    i.14 hours per week Early Intensive Behaviour Intervention, 50 weeks per year, at Therapy Assistant Level 2 weekday rate for the period 30 October 2020, until the date of his commencement of school in 2023;

    ii.1 hour a week for therapy program supervision, 50 weeks per year, for the period 30 October 2020, until the date of his commencement of school in 2023;

    iii.speech therapy – 2 hours per week for an initial 6 month period commencing on the date PBZB commenced school in 2023, then 1 hour per week for a further period to end on the Reassessment Date, plus 4 hours of report writing per year;

    iv.psychology - 1 hour per week for an initial 6 month period commencing on the date PBZB commenced school in 2023, then 1 hour per fortnight for a further period to end on the Reassessment Date, plus 8 hours per annum to fund a standardised assessment by a psychologist;

    v.occupational therapy - 1 hour per week for an initial 6 month period commencing on the date PBZB commenced school in 2023, then 1 hour per fortnight for a further period to end on the Reassessment Date, plus 4 hours of report writing per year;

    vi.school consultation – 18 hours per annum;

    vii.dietician – 4 hours per annum;

    viii.replication (on a pro-rata basis) of all other existing supports in PBZB’s  current SOPS (except for any one-off funding which has already been expended or any funding for supports to be replaced by the supports referred to in paragraph 1(b) above); and

    provision(s) specifying that the plan is to be managed as presently specified in PBZB’s current SOPS.

    ...................................[SGD].....................................

    Member D. Barker

    CATCHWORDS

    NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE AGENCY – whether early intervention supports are reasonable and necessary – Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider the inclusion of supports from the date of approval of a Statement of Participant Supports – reimbursement – Tribunal has discretion to determine the weight of evidence – whether supports are value for money – whether supports are effective and beneficial – decision set aside and remitted with directions.

    LEGISLATION

    Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

    National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

    CASES

    Beezley v Repatriation Commission (2015) 150 ALD 11

    Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2019) 266 CLR 250

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PBZB and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3385
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by PBZB, a seven-year-old boy diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder (Level 2), and his parents, against a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The dispute centred on the NDIA's refusal to fund Applied Behavioural Analysis (ABA) therapy as a reasonable and necessary support under PBZB's NDIS plan. The NDIA's internal review had affirmed the initial decision, finding that the requested ABA therapy did not meet the criteria of being value for money or effective and beneficial, particularly in light of existing funded supports and PBZB's age.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the NDIA's decision to refuse funding for ABA therapy was correct, specifically considering the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports under section 34 of the NDIS Act 2013 (Cth). This involved assessing whether the proposed therapy was value for money, effective, and beneficial, and whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to consider the inclusion of supports from the date of approval of a Statement of Participant Supports. The Tribunal also had to consider the weight to be given to the evidence presented.

The Tribunal found that the NDIA reviewer had erred in their assessment of the evidence regarding the ABA therapy. While acknowledging the NDIA's discretion in determining the weight of evidence, the Tribunal concluded that the reviewer had not adequately considered the evidence supporting the effectiveness and necessity of ABA therapy for PBZB, particularly in preparing him for school. The Tribunal noted that the reviewer's assessment of "value for money" and "effective and beneficial" was based on an insufficient understanding of the proposed therapy and the existing supports. The Tribunal also confirmed its jurisdiction to consider supports from the date of approval of a Statement of Participant Supports.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter back to the NDIA for reconsideration. The NDIA was directed to facilitate the approval of a new Statement of Participant Supports for PBZB, incorporating the necessary therapeutic interventions as outlined in the Tribunal's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal sets aside the Decision Under Review and remits the matter to the Respondent for reconsideration with a direction that the Respondent facilitates the approval of a New SOPS for PBZB as outlined in the Decision (on pages 1 and 2 above).BACKGROUND PBZB is a 7-year-old boy living with his mother and father in Victoria. PBZB’s mother works fulltime, his father has retired from the workforce in order to be available to provide required care to PBZB. PBZB was conceived by in vitro fertilisation and was born at full-term by caesarean section in 2016. He is reported to have grown slowly as a toddler and was slow to achieve early developmental milestones.[5] He was assessed by a speech pathologist in March 2020 and found to have receptive and expressive language abilities below average for his age.[6] PBZB was subsequently diagnosed with ASD (level 2) by Associate Professor Connell, Consultant Paediatrician at the Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne.[7][5] Diagnostic Assessment Report, prepared by Susan Glencross, psychologist, Autism Partnership Australia, dated 28 September 2020, T11, 31.[6] Ibid.[7] Letter of Associate Professor Connell, dated 4 September 2020, T10. PBZB was accepted as a participant of the NDIS in October 2020, with his initial NDIS Plan approved by the NDIA on 30 October 2020.[8][8] NDIS Plan, dated 30 October 2020, T18.PBZB’s October 2020 NDIS Plan The NDIS Plan approved on 30 October 2020 (the October 2020 NDIS Plan) specified his goals, objectives and aspirations as follows:(a)Short-term goal – PBZB’s parent’s would like PBZB to improve his fine motor skills so he can be more independent in daily living tasks up to an age appropriate level.(b)Medium or long-term goal - PBZB’s parent’s would like PBZB to build his communication skills so he can initiate and [be] involved in conversations.(c)Medium or long-term goal - PBZB’s parent’s would like PBZB to build more skills around his self-care tasks. Parents also want PBZB to have support so he can be toilet trained.(d)Medium or long-term goal - PBZB’s parent’s would like PBZB to recogni[s]e his emotions and behaviours and express how he feels to others.(e)Medium or long-term goal - PBZB’s parent’s would like PBZB to build his level of awareness so he can behave safely when he is at home, out at park or shopping centres.(f)Medium or long-term goal - PBZB’s parent’s would like PBZB to build his social skills and be better at maintaining and building friendships. The Statement of Participant Supports component of PBZB’s October 2020 NDIS Plan provided funding as follows:Core Supports Budget Basic (Level 1) and standard (Level 2) assistive technology $1,000Continence products $657.04Total Core Supports – self managed $1,657.04Capacity Building Supports Improved Daily Living (CB Daily Activity)Provision of Early Childhood intervention supports to work togetherwithin the home and community settings, utilising relevant disciplines to support and advise the family in order to meet the participants plan goals. To include a progress report at plan review on outcomes against the NDIS plan goals and the participants ongoing functional needs. Total Capacity Building Supports – self managed $18,995.19 Internal Review Decision of 26 March 2021

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 26 March 2021, the NDIA “reviewer” affirmed the decision to approve the SOPS contained in PBZB’s October 2020 NDIS Plan (the Internal Review Decision).[14] The “reviewer” noted that they were not satisfied the requested funding for ABA therapy,[15] when assessed against each of the criteria of s 34 of the NDIS Act, was a reasonable and necessary support. The explanation for not accepting PBZB’s parent’s request for funding to pay costs associated with the Little Learners program was set out in the Internal Review Decision as follows:Value for Money – s 34(1)(c) In order to meet this criteria, a support must be considered value for money. To determine if a support is value for money, I look at whether the cost of the support is reasonable in light of the benefits it provides, and the cost of alternative supports that could provide a similar outcome for a lower cost.Effective and Beneficial – s 34(1)(d)In order to meet this criteria, a support must be likely to be effective and beneficial having regard to current good practice. I am not satisfied that this requirement has been met. The NDIS had funded 96 hours totalling $18,623.04 for therapies in [PBZB]’s plan. In a phone conversation on 23 March 2021 (Materials reviewed, Item 8), you advised that you have made a deposit of $11,000 to secure a place in an ABA program and that your intention was for [PBZB] to participate in ABA therapy for 27 hours per week to prepare [PBZB] for school in 2022. I have insufficient qualified evidence at this time that additional therapy hours would be more effective for [PBZB] given that no therapeutic intervention has been implemented. The current Capacity Building Improved Daily Living budget provides for multidisciplinary therapy supports for weekly interventions to develop age appropriate independence in activities of daily living, develop expressive and receptive language and develop sound social skills. [PBZB] is only 4 years of age and under Participant Rules 3.4 (Item 8), his parents are responsible for providing substantial care and support, which includes supporting [PBZB] with the consistent implementation of therapy strategies in his natural settings. I cannot be satisfied that funding approximately $120,000 per annum for ABA is value for money based on the significant Capacity Building supports already funded. You have choice and control to implement the most appropriate therapeutic intervention for [PBZB].Parents or providers will often request specific programs to be funded. It is important to remember that the NDIS does not approve funding based on specific ‘programs’ but rather, we consider the evidence that an intensive level of capacity building supports is required. I am not satisfied the requested support would give the desired effect and be the most advantageous in supporting [PBZB] to build his capacity and therefore is not reasonable and necessary and cannot be funded by the NDIS.[14] NDIA Internal Review Decision dated 26 March 2021, T2.[15] Term used by NDIA reviewer when referring to the Autism Partnership Little learners program.Review application

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established