PBVS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

PBVS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2022] AATA 74 (20 January 2022)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/7984 & 2021/1651

Re:PBVS & NPPT

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndXPVK

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member K Millar

Date:  20 January 2022

Place:Adelaide

The decision in relation to J is set aside and substituted with a decision that the existing percentage of care determination is revoked on 2 October 2018 and a new determination made on 3 October 2018 that the applicant has 0% care of J.

The decision in relation to O is set aside and substituted with a decision that a determination that the applicant has 50% care of O until 12 November 2018, and a determination that he has 0% care from 13 November 2018. The decision to decline to make a determination under s 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 is affirmed.  This means the date of effect of the decision in relation to O is 26 October 2020.

.................[Sgnd].........................

Senior Member K Millar

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – change in percentage of care – whether percentage of care changed – whether care arrangement is complied with – whether reasonable action taken to obtain care of the children – decision under review partly set aside

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
A New Tax System (Family Assistance) Act 1999
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988

Family Law Act 1975

Cases

Stevenson v Hughes [1993] FamCA 14

Francis & Sabin [2008] FMCAfam 1410

Secondary Materials

Organisations (Definition of Family Counsellor) Designation 1 July 2019 – 30 June 2024 (Updated 7 November 2019) (ag.gov.au)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member K Millar

20 January 2022

BACKGROUND

  1. PBVS and NPPT[1] (“Mr X”) and XPVK (“Ms Y”) are the parents of J, who is now 19 years of age, and O who is now 14. In accordance with Court orders made 25 November 2012 Mr X and Ms Y had 50% shared care of the children.   

    [1] PBVS and NPPT are the same Applicant, who will be referred to singularly throughout the decision as “Mr X”.

  2. On 23 October 2018, Ms Y contacted the Child Support Agency informing them that the care of the children had changed, and she had 100% care of both children from 23 September 2018.    Mr X disputed the care change and stated that Ms Y was withholding care of the children, and he had taken reasonable action to obtain care of the children.

  3. An element of the formula used to decide how much child support a parent is required to pay is the percentage of care…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PBVS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review by the Child Support Registrar regarding a dispute between Mr X and Ms Y concerning the percentage of care of their children, J and O. The core of the dispute revolved around whether the percentage of care had changed from an initial 50% shared care arrangement under a court order, to Mr X having no overnight care of the children from a disputed date. The Tribunal was required to determine the date from which any change in care arrangements should be effective.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether the care arrangements had changed, whether the existing care arrangement was being complied with, and whether reasonable action had been taken to obtain care of the children. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider the provisions of Division 4 of Part 5 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, particularly sections relating to changes in care percentages and the definition of "regular care." The Tribunal also had to assess the admissibility and weight of text messages provided as evidence, noting that incomplete message records and the absence of years on some messages made them unreliable for precise dating.

The Tribunal's reasoning involved a careful consideration of the evidence, including text messages, and the relevant legislative provisions. It found that while Mr X had previously shared 50% care of the children, the circumstances had changed such that he had no overnight care from a disputed date. However, the Tribunal was not satisfied that there were special circumstances preventing Mr X from lodging an application earlier. Consequently, for child J, the existing percentage of care determination was revoked on 2 October 2018, with a new determination of 0% care made on 3 October 2018. For child O, a determination of 50% care was made until 12 November 2018, with 0% care thereafter, but the effective date of this change was ultimately determined to be 26 October 2020, aligning with when Mr X lodged his application. The Tribunal affirmed the decision to decline a determination under section 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a child support dispute between Mr X and Ms Y concerning their two children, J and O. Prior to a disputed date, Mr X had regular care of the children under a Court order, which mandated that each parent have 50% care. This arrangement continued until Mr X ceased to have overnight care of the children from a certain date, which is contested. Mr X subsequently sought to have the Tribunal consider text messages between himself and Ms Y’s husband; however, the Tribunal deemed these messages irrelevant to the issues at hand and did not consider them further. The text messages between the parties, which were provided to the Tribunal, were incomplete and taken out of context, which the Tribunal acknowledged and factored into its assessment. Both parents involved their children in the dispute, with Ms Y admitting to having the younger child read through toxic text exchanges between her and Mr X, and Mr X sending a copy of some documents to one of the children. These actions are deemed detrimental to the children and not in their best interests.

The dispute centres on whether the percentage of care changed and whether the arrangement was complied with. Under Division 4 of Part 5 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, a change in the percentage of care can lead to the revocation of a care determination if certain conditions are met. According to the parties, Mr X had care of the children, which then ceased from a disputed date. The previous arrangement was under a Court order stipulating 50% care for each parent, classified as at least regular care. The Tribunal’s decision hinges on whether Mr X took reasonable action to obtain care of the children and whether Ms Y notified the Registrar that Mr X had no care during a reasonable period, as per section 54G of the Act. The parties provided various documents and text messages to support their respective positions, although the Tribunal noted the limitations of such evidence.

This case pertains to a second review of a child support determination under Division 4 of Part 5 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989. The matter initially came before the Child Support Registrar (CSCRD) and was subsequently referred to the Tribunal for review. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether there had been a change in the percentage of care for the children and whether the care arrangement was being complied with. A key aspect of the review involved assessing the text messages provided by the parties, which were considered but not relied upon heavily due to their partial nature and potential for being taken out of context. Both parties had involved the children in the dispute, which was noted as being detrimental to the children's interests. The Tribunal's decision was to set aside part of the CSCRD's decision and substitute it with new determinations regarding the percentage of care for each child, effective from specific dates. The Tribunal also affirmed the CSCRD's decision to decline making a determination under section 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr X sought to have before the Tribunal text messages between himself and Ms Y’s husband. The Tribunal did not consider these relate to the issues before it and did not have further regard to these messages. EVIDENCE The Tribunal has before it documents provided by the Registrar and information from the parties. Included among these are various text messages between the parties and between Mr X and the children. These texts messages are extracts and are not a complete record. Ms Y said that before the hearing she went through the children’s phones and took copies of other parts of conversations. She decided not to tender these copies. While the text messages assist in establishing what occurred at particular dates, the Tribunal is aware these messages can be taken out of context when the whole conversation is not provided. It has taken this into account when assessing the information before it. Messages provided were not in date order. The day of the week, date and month are included, however the year of the message is not. The Tribunal is not willing to rely on text messages being on a particular date unless the day of the week and date align with the calendar of that year. It is not prepared to find that messages were sent on a particular date where no date appears on the message. Both parties have involved the children in this dispute. It is apparent Ms Y had the younger child O read through text exchanges, which she admits were toxic, between herself and Mr X. Ms Y states that Mr X has sent a copy of part of the documents provided by the Registrar to one of the children. Both have involved the children in discussions about the dispute between the parents. Neither course of action paints the parties in a good light and is not in the best interests of the children.LEGISLATION Division 4 of Part 5 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (the Act) addresses the percentage of care, which is used to decide a person’s cost percentage. There are a number of pathways to address a percentage of care determination. The parents agree that that the circumstances in this case are that Mr X had care of the children, and then from a disputed date Mr X had no overnight care of the children. The previous care of the children occurred under a Court order that provided that each parent was to have 50% care. This level of care is at least regular care.[3][3] Section 5(2) of the Act defines regular care as at least 14% but less than 35% during a care period. Under s 54G of the Act if:·Mr X was to have at least regular care of the children, and ·He has had no care of the children during a care period under a determination made under s 50 despite Ms Y making the children available to him;·A determination of Ms Y’s percentage of care has been made under s 50;·Ms Y notifies the Registrar that Mr X has had no care of the children in a period that is reasonable in the circumstances;then the care determination must be revoked at the end of the day before the care changed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is not satisfied there are special circumstances that prevented him lodging an application. As a result, the date of effect of the decision in relation to O is the date Mr X lodged his application with SSCSD, being 26 October 2020, and the decision of the SSCSD declining to make a determination under s 95N(2) of the Registration and Collection Act is affirmed. DECISION The decision in relation to J is set aside and substituted with a decision that the existing percentage of care determination is revoked on 2 October 2018 and a new determination made on 3 October 2018 that Mr X has 0% care of J. The decision in relation to O is set aside and substituted with a decision that a determination that Mr X has 50% care of O until 12 November 2018, and a determination that he has 0% care from 13 November 2018. The decision to decline to make a determination under s 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 is affirmed. This means the date of effect of the decision in relation to O is 26 October 2020.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in this case considered whether the percentage of care for child J and child O changed from 50% to 0% on the dates specified. The court found that the percentage of care for child J changed from 50% to 0% on 2 October 2018. The parents agreed that Mr X had care of the children, and from a disputed date, Mr X had no overnight care of the children. Under section 54G of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, if Mr X was to have at least regular care of the children and he had no care during a care period despite Ms Y making the children available to him, then the care determination must be revoked at the end of the day before the care changed. The court relied on this statutory provision to determine that the percentage of care for child J changed on 2 October 2018.

Regarding child O, the court found that the percentage of care changed from 50% to 0% on 13 November 2018. The court based its decision on the same statutory provision, section 54G, and found that the evidence supported the change in the percentage of care on that date. The court distinguished this case from the situation with child J, as the evidence and timeline differed for child O.

The court also addressed whether it could consider text messages that were not in date order or lacked year information in determining the percentage of care. The court held that it was not willing to rely on text messages being on a particular date unless the day of the week and date aligned with the calendar of that year. The court was not prepared to find that messages were sent on a particular date where no date appeared on the message. This decision was based on the need to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the evidence presented.

In considering whether the involvement of the children in the parents' dispute constituted reasonable action to obtain care of the children, the court found that neither party acted reasonably. Ms Y had the younger child read through toxic text exchanges, and Mr X sent a copy of part of the documents provided by the Registrar to one of the children. Both actions involved the children in discussions about the dispute between the parents, which the court found was not in the best interests of the children.

The court further considered whether the parties' actions of involving the children in their dispute were in the best interests of the children. The court found that these actions were not in the best interests of the children and did not paint the parties in a good light. The court emphasised that the welfare of the children should be the paramount consideration in such disputes.

Lastly, the court examined whether there were special circumstances that prevented Mr X from lodging an application within the required timeframe. The court found that there were no special circumstances that prevented Mr X from lodging an application. Consequently, the date of effect of the decision in relation to child O was the date Mr X lodged his application with SSCSD, being 26 October 2020. The decision of the SSCSD declining to make a determination under section 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 was affirmed. This means the date of effect of the decision in relation to child O is 26 October 2020.