PAYNE and ALLEGRETTA

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   COMMERCIAL & CIVIL

ACT: BUILDERS' REGISTRATION ACT 1939 (WA)

CITATION:   PAYNE and ALLEGRETTA [2010] WASAT 36

MEMBER:   MR P McNAB (MEMBER)

MR R AFFLECK (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   16 MARCH 2010

FILE NO/S:   CC 196 of 2009

BETWEEN:   JACQUELINE ANN PAYNE

Applicant

AND

ALDO  ALLEGRETTA
MARYANNE ALLEGRETTA
Respondents

FILE NO/S              :CC 197 of 2009

BETWEEN              :ALDO ALLEGRETTA

MARYANNE ALLEGRETTA
Applicants

AND

JACQUELINE ANN PAYNE
PAUL CHIDLOW
Respondents

Catchwords:

Building and construction - Faulty or unsatisfactory building work - Residential building - Whether work done in a proper and workmanlike manner - Review of order to remedy made by the Building Disputes Tribunal (BDT) - Application of Building Code of Australia (BCA) - BDT decision on roofing material - Acceptable corrosion protection for sheet roofing - Marine and coastal areas - Building located more than 100 metres from shoreline - Whether Colorbond standard or higher standard Colorbond Ultra or equivalents mandated under BCA - BDT holding that higher standard required to be installed by builder - Whether Safety Bay relevantly a 'severe' or 'moderate' marine environment - Application of concept of 'breaking surf' - Manufacturer's published views specifically classifying Safety Bay as 'exposed marine' but not subject to 'breaking surf' - BDT holding that all coastal areas subject to 'breaking surf' - Application for review allowed - Safety Bay to be classified relevantly as 'moderate' environment - Colorbond standard permitted under BCA - Order to remedy varied - Consideration of 2009 amendments to the BCA which clarify concept of 'breaking surf' - Words and phrases: 'breaking surf'.

Legislation:

Builders' Registration Act 1939 (WA), s 12A
Building Code of Australia

Result:

Application allowed and order to review varied

Category:    B

Representation:

CC 196 of 2009

Counsel:

Applicant:     Self-Represented

Respondents                 :     Self-Represented

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondents                 :     Self-represented

CC 197 of 2009

Counsel:

Applicants:     Self-Represented

Respondents                 :     Self-Represented

Solicitors:

Applicants:     Self-represented

Respondents                 :     Self-represented

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Builders' Registration Board of Western Australia and Elliott [2009] WASAT 44

Lombardi Investments (WA) Pty Ltd and City of Cockburn [2009] WASAT 65

Plunkett Homes (1903) Pty Ltd and Stephens [2007] WASAT 295

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. In this review of a decision of the Building Disputes Tribunal, the central issue was the interpretation and application of a provision in the Building Code of Australia giving the builder direction as to the standard of roof coating to be installed in coastal and marine environments.

  2. The builder (Ms Payne) had supplied and installed a BlueScope Steel roofing product known as Colorbond, or Colorbond standard.  The owners (Mr and Mrs Allegretta) lived about 113 metres from the shoreline of Safety Bay.  The Building Disputes Tribunal found that the work had 'not been carried out in a proper and workmanlike manner' because, in its view, the Building Code of Australia and BlueScope Steel required a more corrosive­resistant roofing material to be installed, namely Colorbond Ultra or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PAYNE and ALLEGRETTA and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASAT 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Payne and Allegreta involved a dispute over the quality of building work carried out on a residential property. The homeowner, Payne, alleged that the builder, Allegreta, had failed to carry out the work in a proper and workmanlike manner. The dispute specifically centred around the quality of the roofing material used. Payne claimed that the roofing material was not suitable for the coastal location and did not provide adequate corrosion protection. The case was reviewed by the Building Disputes Tribunal (BDT), which ruled in favour of Payne. The BDT held that the builder was required to use a higher standard of roofing material, specifically Colorbond Ultra, and that the failure to do so constituted a breach of the Building Code of Australia (BCA). The builder appealed the decision to the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT).

The legal issues before the SAT involved the interpretation and application of the BCA in relation to the use of roofing material in a coastal location. The key question was whether the BCA required the use of Colorbond Ultra, a higher standard of roofing material, or if the standard Colorbond roofing sheets used by the builder were sufficient. The SAT also had to determine whether the location of the property, more than 100 metres from the shoreline, was subject to a'severe' or 'moderate' marine environment, which would affect the required standard of corrosion protection. The classification of the environment and the interpretation of the phrase 'breaking surf' were central to the decision.

The SAT found that the BDT had erred in classifying the location as 'severe' and requiring the use of Colorbond Ultra. The tribunal considered the 2009 amendments to the BCA, which clarified the concept of 'breaking surf', and held that not all coastal areas were subject to 'breaking surf'. The SAT determined that Safety Bay, where the property was located, should be classified as a'moderate' marine environment. As a result, the standard Colorbond roofing sheets were acceptable under the BCA. The SAT allowed the application for review, varied the order to remedy, and permitted the use of standard Colorbond roofing sheets. The builder was not required to replace the roofing material with Colorbond Ultra.

The SAT's decision clarified the application of the BCA in relation to roofing materials in coastal locations and the concept of 'breaking surf'. The tribunal held that the classification of the environment and the required standard of corrosion protection were dependent on specific factors, including the distance from the shoreline and the presence of 'breaking surf'. The SAT's decision provided guidance for builders and homeowners in similar situations and emphasised the importance of complying with the BCA and understanding the specific requirements for coastal locations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The BCA is the overarching building code for all building work in Australia and was adopted by the Western Australian Government on 1 July 1997. In Builders' Registration Board of Western Australia and Elliott [2009] WASAT 44, this Tribunal said, at [50]:… It is correct [to say] that reg 5 of the Building Regulations [(WA)] has the effect of giving the BCA [the] force of law and obliges a builder to comply with its requirements. The contract for the roofing work is dated 26 April 2006. The BCA is a 'living document' and is subject to ongoing amendment. The BCA (2006 ed) was adopted by the Western Australian Government on 1 May 2006. Hence, BCA (2005 ed), which was adopted on 1 May 2005, arguably might apply, at least to the contractual arrangements between the parties. The BDT assessed the builder's workmanship by reference to the standards of the BCA (2006 ed) as being applicable at the point when the work was done. There is no error in that course and in this review, we intend to do the same. In any case, it appears that there is no material difference between the two editions of the BCA on the central questions in this review. The BCA sets out various performance requirements. It is an extensive and detailed document. Speaking generally, compliance with these performance requirements may be achieved by complying either with the 'deemed to satisfy' provisions of the BCA, or by the formulation of an 'alternative solution' which complies with the 'performance requirements' (or is shown to be at least equivalent to the deemed to satisfy provisions), or by a combination of both. It is unnecessary for the purposes of this review to set out the provisions of the BCA in this regard. They are discussed in, for example, Plunkett Homes (1903) Pty Ltd and Stephens [2007] WASAT 295, at [10]-[15] and in Lombardi Investments (WA) Pty Ltd and City of Cockburn [2009] WASAT 65. The performance requirements of the BCA are in effect minimum standards and thus it is open to building designers to adopt higher standards of performance. Speaking generally, in cases of this nature, the issue will usually be whether work has been 'carried out in a proper and workmanlike manner' under s 12A of the BR Act and will be answered by a close examination of the standards found in the BCA and the application of those standards to the work in question. In this matter, the BDT applied the BCA and other standards it thought relevant as follows:Item 1(a):Roofing screws not correct grade.The class 3 screws used do not conform with the recommendation of BlueScope Steel (technical bulletin TB -16, Table 1 (Fastener Materials for use with Roofing and Walling Manufactured from BlueScope Steel Strip and Sheet Products) [)], which states that fasteners conforming to AS 3655, class 4, should be used on Colorbond Ultra Steel Sheeting. Specifically, BlueScope Steel states [that] "Fasteners conforming to AS 3566, class 3, should not be used within 400 metres of the ocean or other severe marine influence".The [builder] admits that the premises are between 100 and 200 metres from the ocean at Safety Bay.We find the complaint proven to our satisfaction. The use of class 3 screws is in breach of s 12A of the [BR Act] …Item 1(b):Roof sheeting not correct grade for coastal location.There is no evidence that the [builder] was specifically contracted by the [owners] to install "Colorbond Ultra" roof sheeting. The written estimate of the [builder] dated 24 April 2006 for $4,361.00 plus GST does not specify the use of any particular roofing material.The [owners] asked for a "suitable roof" and the [builder] has installed "standard" Colorbond roofing sheets. The [owners] complain that the [builder] should have used Colorbond Ultra in the coastal location of their home and that its failure to do so resulted in BlueScope Steel (the manufacturer) refusing to warranty the roof.The issue for the [BDT] is whether or not the Building Code of Australia … imposes an obligation on the Respondent to use Colorbond Ultra (or similar material) in this location.