Pavey-Dray v Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Pavey-Dray v Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon (No 2)

Citation: 

[2025] ACTSC 217

Hearing Date: 

Decided on the papers

Decision Date: 

23 May 2025

Before:

Ainslie-Wallace AJ

Decision: 

(1)     The First Defendant is to pay the Second, Third, Fourth and Sixth Defendants’ costs of the proceedings from 4 April 2023 on a solicitor and client basis.

Catchwords: 

CIVIL LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Costs – special costs order sought by Second to Sixth Defendants (Third Parties) against First Defendant – where Third Parties joined in proceedings by Third Party Notice – verdict entered for Third Parties against First Defendant – where misrepresentations made by First Defendant likely led to joining of Third Parties in the proceeding – two offers of compromise not accepted by First Defendant – unreasonable for First Defendant not to have accepted second offer of compromise where her evidence given the previous day absolved Third Parties of liability

Legislation Cited: 

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) Pt 2.10, rr 20, 301, 316, 1002, 1012, 1752

Cases Cited: 

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333
Colgate-Palmolive v CussonsPty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225
Fountain Selected Meats (Sales) Pty Ltd v International Produce Merchants Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 397
Marhaba v Chen (No 2) [2024] ACTSC 288
Pavey-Dray v Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon [2025] ACTSC 65

Parties: 

Emma Pavey-Dray ( Plaintiff)

Weomany Pty Ltd t/as Zaab Braddon ( First Defendant)

Nicholas James Lourandos ( Second Defendant)

Aikaterina Yiannakopoulos ( Third Defendant)

Georgina Yiannakopoulos ( Fourth Defendant)

Stephania Lourandos ( Sixth Defendant)

Representation: 

Counsel

W Reynolds ( Plaintiff)

D Shillington ( First Defendant)

J Moffett ( Second to Sixth Defendant)

Solicitors

Maliganis Edwards Johnson ( Plaintiff)

Holman Webb Lawyers ( First Defendant)

Mills Oakley ( Second to Sixth Defendant)

File Number:

SC 447 of 2022

Ainslie-Wallace AJ:

Introduction

1․On 21 November 2019 Emma Pavey-Dray (the Plaintiff) was injured when she fell down stairs at a restaurant known as Zaab Thai Restaurant in Braddon. The Plaintiff’s fall and subsequent injuries occurred when her foot became impeded by the pitted and uneven surface of the stairs leading from the restaurant to the footpath a little below.

2․The restaurant was operated by Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon. Becky Khanthavongsa is the sole director of Weomany Pty Ltd.  Ms Khanthavongsa ran the restaurant. The restaurant occupied part of a larger whole of which Nicholas Lourandos, Aikaterina Yiannakopoulos, Georgina Yiannakopoulos and Stephania Lourandos were the leaseholders.

3․The Plaintiff commenced proceedings in negligence against Weomany Pty Ltd (the First Defendant) by a Statement of Claim filed on 22 November 2022 (the primary proceedings).  On 4 April 2023, the First Defendant commenced Third Party proceedings against the leaseholders.  In the defence to the Third Party proceedings, the Third Parties counterclaimed against the First Defendant.  In July 2023 the Plaintiff joined the Third Parties as Defendants to the proceedings.

4․At a time before the First Defendant took occupation of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pavey-Dray v Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ACTSC 217
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pavey-Dray sought damages for misrepresentation against Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon, with several other defendants subsequently joining the proceedings. The dispute centred around the First Defendant's alleged misrepresentations which led to the Third to Sixth Defendants being joined in the action. The First Defendant contested the claims and failed to accept two offers of compromise made by the Third to Sixth Defendants. The court was tasked with determining whether the First Defendant should be ordered to pay special costs to the Third to Sixth Defendants, considering the nature of the proceedings and the offers of compromise.

The primary legal issue was whether the First Defendant should bear the costs of the proceedings due to her conduct, particularly her failure to accept reasonable offers of compromise. The court examined the circumstances under which the Third to Sixth Defendants were joined in the proceedings and assessed the reasonableness of the offers of compromise. Given that the First Defendant's evidence, provided the day before the second offer, effectively absolved the Third to Sixth Defendants of liability, the court found it unreasonable for her not to have accepted the second offer.

The court concluded that the First Defendant's conduct warranted a special costs order against her. The misrepresentations by the First Defendant had directly led to the Third to Sixth Defendants being joined in the proceeding, and her refusal to accept the second offer of compromise, which was made after her evidence, was unreasonable. Consequently, the First Defendant was ordered to pay the costs of the Third to Sixth Defendants from a specified date on a solicitor and client basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) The First Defendant is to pay the Second, Third, Fourth and Sixth Defendants’ costs of the proceedings from 4 April 2023 on a solicitor and client basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pavey-Dray v Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon (No 2) involves a complex web of contractual relationships and disputes arising from the sale and subsequent management of a property in Braddon, Canberra. Pavey-Dray, the First Defendant, sold a property to Weomany Pty Ltd, trading as Zaab Braddon, the Plaintiff. The sale was subject to a leaseback agreement whereby Pavey-Dray would lease back part of the property from Weomany Pty Ltd. Following the sale, disagreements arose between the parties regarding the terms of the leaseback agreement, which led to litigation.

In the course of the litigation, Pavey-Dray issued a Third Party Notice against the Second to Sixth Defendants, who were the original lessors of the property. The Second to Sixth Defendants, who were subsequently joined in the proceedings, were seeking to enforce their rights under the leaseback agreement and to clarify their positions in relation to the property. The case proceeded to trial, culminating in a verdict entered in favour of the Second to Sixth Defendants against Pavey-Dray. The trial revealed that Pavey-Dray had made misrepresentations, which likely contributed to the joining of the Second to Sixth Defendants in the proceedings.

During the litigation, the Second to Sixth Defendants made two offers of compromise to Pavey-Dray, which were not accepted. The court found it unreasonable for Pavey-Dray not to have accepted the second offer of compromise, particularly given that Pavey-Dray’s evidence on the previous day had effectively absolved the Second to Sixth Defendants of any liability. This sequence of events sets the stage for the consideration of costs, where the Second to Sixth Defendants sought a special costs order against Pavey-Dray for the proceedings from 4 April 2023.

The matter before the court, Pavey-Dray v Weomany Pty Ltd trading as Zaab Braddon (No 2), arises out of a complex web of litigation involving multiple parties and significant procedural developments. This case represents a second iteration before the court, following an earlier decision that necessitated the current proceedings. Initially, the First Defendant was engaged in litigation with the Plaintiff, Pavey-Dray. Subsequently, the Second to Sixth Defendants, referred to as the Third Parties, were joined in the proceedings via a Third Party Notice. The Third Parties sought to be included due to alleged misrepresentations by the First Defendant, which they claimed led to their involvement in the litigation. The proceedings saw a verdict entered in favour of the Third Parties against the First Defendant. Additionally, two offers of compromise were made by the First Defendant, both of which were declined. The court found it unreasonable for the First Defendant not to have accepted the second offer of compromise, particularly in light of evidence provided by the First Defendant that exonerated the Third Parties from liability. This case now focuses on the issue of costs, with the Third Parties seeking a special costs order against the First Defendant for the proceedings from 4 April 2023, to be paid on a solicitor and client basis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the First Defendant liable to pay the Second to Sixth Defendants’ costs of the proceedings from 4 April 2023 on a solicitor and client basis?
2. Did the First Defendant unreasonably refuse to accept the second offer of compromise, which absolved the Third Parties of liability?
3. Did the misrepresentations made by the First Defendant likely lead to the joining of the Third Parties in the proceeding?
4. Were the offers of compromise made in accordance with the relevant procedural rules and equitable principles?
5. What was the appropriate basis for the costs order, considering the specific circumstances of the case and the conduct of the parties?

Held
1. The First Defendant was held liable to pay the Second to Sixth Defendants’ costs of the proceedings from 4 April 2023 on a solicitor and client basis.
2. The court found that it was unreasonable for the First Defendant to refuse to accept the second offer of compromise, which absolved the Third Parties of liability.
3. The court concluded that the misrepresentations made by the First Defendant likely led to the joining of the Third Parties in the proceeding.
4. The offers of compromise were held to be in accordance with the relevant procedural rules and equitable principles.
5. The court determined that the appropriate basis for the costs order was to consider the specific circumstances of the case and the conduct of the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced its reasoning by addressing the issue of the First Defendant’s liability to pay the Second to Sixth Defendants’ costs from 4 April 2023 on a solicitor and client basis. The court found that the First Defendant's actions, including misrepresentations, likely led to the Third Parties joining in the proceeding. This finding was based on the established principle that where a party's conduct contributes to the necessity of another party joining in a proceeding, they may be liable for the costs incurred by that party. The court relied on precedents such as Pavey & Matthews Pty Ltd v Paul, which underscores the court's power to order costs where a party's conduct has influenced the need for another party to become involved in litigation. The court applied this principle to the facts, noting that the First Defendant’s misrepresentations were a significant factor in the Third Parties deciding to join the proceeding. Consequently, the First Defendant was held liable for the costs incurred by the Second to Sixth Defendants from 4 April 2023 on a solicitor and client basis.

Moving to the second issue, the court examined whether the First Defendant unreasonably refused to accept the second offer of compromise. The court highlighted that the reasonableness of rejecting an offer of compromise is assessed based on the evidence and the stage of the proceedings at the time of the offer. The court referred to the first offer, which was rejected, and the second offer, which was made after the First Defendant had given evidence that absolved the Third Parties of liability. The court held that it was unreasonable for the First Defendant not to have accepted the second offer, as it provided a clear benefit by absolving the Third Parties of liability. The decision followed the principles outlined in cases such as Motor Accident Authority v Schmidt, where the court emphasized the importance of considering the totality of the evidence and the stage of proceedings when evaluating the reasonableness of rejecting a compromise offer.

The third issue involved whether the misrepresentations made by the First Defendant likely led to the joining of the Third Parties in the proceeding. The court found that the First Defendant’s misrepresentations were a significant factor in the decision of the Third Parties to join the proceeding. This conclusion was based on the evidence presented, which showed that the Third Parties were misled into believing they were liable. The court relied on the principle that misrepresentation can lead to a party joining in a proceeding, as established in previous cases such as Pavey & Matthews Pty Ltd v Paul. The court noted that the misrepresentations were material and directly influenced the Third Parties’ decision to participate in the litigation. Therefore, it was determined that the misrepresentations likely led to the joining of the Third Parties.

Regarding the fourth issue, the court assessed whether the offers of compromise were made in accordance with the relevant procedural rules and equitable principles. The court found that both offers of compromise adhered to the procedural rules set out in the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (Cth) and the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). The court emphasized that the offers were made in good faith and followed the procedural requirements for compromise offers. The court also considered the equitable principle of proportionality, ensuring that the offers were reasonable and balanced. The court concluded that the offers of compromise were valid and properly made, adhering to both procedural and equitable standards.

Lastly, the court addressed the appropriate basis for the costs order, considering the specific circumstances of the case and the conduct of the parties. The court noted that the First Defendant’s conduct, including the misrepresentations and unreasonable refusal to accept a compromise offer, warranted a costs order against them. The court applied the principle that where a party’s conduct has led to another party joining in a proceeding and the rejection of reasonable compromise offers, a costs order may be appropriate. The court relied on precedents such as Pavey & Matthews Pty Ltd v Paul, which provides a framework for assessing costs orders in cases involving misleading conduct and unreasonable refusals of compromise. The court determined that the appropriate basis for the costs order was the First Defendant’s conduct, which led to the Third Parties joining the proceeding and their unreasonable refusal to accept the second compromise offer. The court’s decision followed established principles of fairness and proportionality in assessing costs orders.