PAV v Director of Child Protection Litigation

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

[2016] QCA 271

COURT OF APPEAL

MARGARET McMURDO P
GOTTERSON JA
McMEEKIN J

Appeal No 9378 of 2016
DC No 3576 of 2016

PAV  Appellant

v

DIRECTOR OF CHILD PROTECTION LITIGATION
HG
CD  Respondents

BRISBANE

TUESDAY, 25 OCTOBER 2016

JUDGMENT

THE PRESIDENT:  The appellant filed a Notice of Appeal in this Court on 12 September 2016 from an order on 9 September 2016 of a District Court judge constituting the Childrens Court sitting in the appellate jurisdiction.  The appeal to the District Court judge constituting the Childrens Court was from orders made by the Childrens Court constituted by Magistrate Quinn on 30 August 2016, namely:

“1.Authorising an authorized officer [or] police officer to have contact with the children

2.That the children be separately legally represented in these proceedings

3.The Department of Child Safety is to immediately provide all of the material filed in these proceedings to the Independent Children’s Lawyer in the Federal Circuit Court proceedings and to inform the Registrar, before whom the parents will be appearing on Thursday 2/9/2016, of the Department of Child Safety’s concerns

4.Leave is granted to the Director of Child Protection Litigation to amend the Child Protection applications”

The District Court judge sitting as the Childrens Court on appeal ordered:

“1.The decision of the learned Magistrate on 30 August 2016, in which he declined to make an order granting temporary custody of either of the children, to the Chief Executive, be set aside.

2.Order that interim custody of [GH] be granted to the Chief Executive for the period of the adjournment.

3.Order that [the appellant] have no contact, direct or indirect, with [GH], for a period of 3 months from 9 September 2016

4.Order that a copy of transcripts from proceedings be prepared urgently and provided to the parties

5.Order that an authorised officer or police officer enter and search any place the officer reasonably believes the child is, to find the child, to enforce the order

6.Further reasons to be given by Judge Dearden on 16 September 2016 at 9am”.

The period of the adjournment referred to in the District Court judge’s order 2 was until 11 October 2016 when Magistrate O’Shea, constituting the Childrens Court, made further like orders and adjourned the matter to 6 December for further mention.  The appellant has appealed under the Child Protection Act 1999 (Qld) s 117 from the orders of Magistrate O’Shea and that appeal is to be heard shortly in the Childrens Court constituted by a District Court judge.

The appellant also filed a stay application in this Court in respect of the orders of the District Court judge constituting the Childrens Court on 9 September 2016.  That application was refused by Justice Philip McMurdo: see PAV v Director of Child Protection Litigation & Ors [2016] QCA 234. His Honour refused the stay for absence of jurisdiction as the appellant had no right to appeal to this Court. In light of his Honour’s reasons, the Registry invited the appellant to file a Form 68…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PAV v Director of Child Protection Litigation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCA 271
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in this case concerns a dispute involving the appellant, PAV, and the Director of Child Protection Litigation, represented by the HGCD. The matter originated in the Children's Court and was subsequently appealed to a District Court judge sitting in the appellate jurisdiction of the Children's Court. The appellant, PAV, appealed the orders made by the District Court judge, which included granting temporary custody of a child to the Chief Executive, prohibiting PAV from having contact with the child for three months, and ordering an urgent preparation and provision of transcripts to the parties. The appeal was brought to the Court of Appeal, which was required to determine whether it had jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the District Court judge's decision.

The Court of Appeal considered whether it had jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the District Court judge's orders. The Court noted that under the Child Protection Act 1999 (Qld), only the Director of Child Protection Litigation had the right to appeal from a Children's Court decision to a District Court judge. The Court of Appeal had consistently held that the Child Protection Act allows for only one level of appeal from such decisions, and no appeal lies to the Court of Appeal from the District Court judge's decision. The Court emphasized that the absence of jurisdiction was not a determination of the merits of the case but a jurisdictional issue. The Court further highlighted that the appellant should focus on her pending appeal from the Children's Court's decision, which would be heard and determined on its merits.

The reasoning of the Court of Appeal was clear and straightforward. It was established that the Court of Appeal did not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the District Court judge's orders. The Court dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction and advised the appellant to concentrate on her other pending appeal, which would be heard on its merits. The Court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to statutory provisions regarding the right of appeal in child protection matters.

The final order of the Court of Appeal was that the appeal is dismissed for absence of jurisdiction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established